There has been some griping about our OLine play. Since I didn't get that impression from anything other than Winovich playing like a man with his hair on fire, I decided to take a "slow-and-pause" look at the first quarter. Anyone else who would like to do similar things would be very welcome.
I don't want to "make a career' out of this so what follows will just be a play-by-play evaluation as to whether a lineman had a "plus" or a minus. If a player didn't have much to do on the play, I can't penalize him for that, and he gets a plus.
First series
Play one --- everyone did their job.
Play two --- Winovich beat Eichenberg and caused some trouble; otherwise OK.
Play three --- Winovich unblocked but by design. All OK. (pass complete)
Play four --- Winovich and Gary "slow-beat" tackles but BW steps up to clean spot.
Play five --- Hainsey beautifully runs Gary way out of play, and all others good.
Play six --- Winovich unblocked by design and BW correctly reads.
Play seven --- Outstanding run blocking everywhere; Kraemer pancakes. (TD)
Second series
Play eight --- TV cut to tornado watch --- missed it.
Play nine --- SWEEP RIGHT (shouldn't do this vs Michigan.) Receivers blow their assignments and Mustipher misses block. Kraemer OK but in impossible clogged situation.
Play ten --- all pass protection positive.
Play eleven --- all blocking good (BW reads the unblocked end correctly)
Play twelve --- everyone did their job.
Play thirteen --- Both tackles got speed-rushed wide, but interior smothered theirs and BW made fast effective "inside" scramble.
Play fourteen --- blocked the waddin' out of everyone (Finke score.)
Third series
Play fifteen --- SWEEP LEFT (don't do this vs UofM) --- TE misses block and Eichenberg too. Hainsey whiffs on back side and Winovich catches play.
Play sixteen --- everybody good but BW blows pass.
Play seventeen --- wide speed rushes "beat" Eichenberg and Hainsey but inner three stuff everyone including two blitzers. BW steps up but blows pass.
End of quarter.
My opinions:
Eichenberg --- positive 12 out of 17. Four of five errors were on speed rushes (one run block). Three of four speed rushes were negated by the inner three stuffing their players and cleaning a pocket. The run blocking bust was a sweep.
Bars --- no busts.
Mustipher --- one "bust" but a hard sweep pull ask.
Kraemer --- no busts.
Hainsey --- positive 13 out of 17. All busts were by wide speed (mainly Winovich --- Gary didn't do much this quarter; it was this guy and the linebacker.) 3 of busts were made good by the inner guys cleaning pockets for step ups.
Overall assessment of first quarter: Three inner guys played like AAs. (sometimes plays get stopped by "the other guys" being too many or too good.) Our tackles had fits with Winovich --- HE definitely was AA. Gary was "some" trouble but not as much.
If we play like this all season, we're trophy winners again.