Diaco Hired as Purdue DC

B

Bogtrotter07

Guest
Listen guys.

The arrogance that we should concentrate on in this conversation is the "professors with Harvard, Oxford, and other elitist universities that are professors at ND, and look down their nose at this American Football thing, like acknowledging it will some how cheapen the value of a degree from the University of Notre Dame, or tarnish Notre Dame's reputation. These guys have no sense of history of The University of Notre Dame, whatsoever. The days of ND professors being priests and ND graduates, tough as nails, and solid fans, and supporters is gone forever . . . "

This is a conversation that I just had with a senior ND graduate, and major contributor to multiple ND charitible programs, both athletic and academic, including the Rockne Heritage Foundation.

There is a movement to refund athletics separate of the University. If anybody wanted that information public, I suppose you could find out about it easily enough.

But that is what needs to happen with ND.

Forget about conversations about it being too tough to have a good football team today with ND's standards; conversely, flush all the conversations about all kids have to do the same work and that these student athletes are given 300K worth of education for their time and trouble.

The fact of the matter is, you need a kid that is competent in his background, has superior study, organizational skills, and can read, write, and learn at an above average rate.

Kids that agree to play football at ND commit to between 50 and 80 hours a week between studying, working out, practice, class room activities, and off field football duties. And there are mighty few breaks during the year, (read no summers off.)

The thing that will never change is that ND will never develop an easy pass major, like most schools have. In fact, several alum and administrators I have spoken with talk about the evolution of ND curriculum, and they point to the Physical Education degree ND used to once offer. Knute himself, (An ND chemistry professor, did you know that?) spearheaded the PE program development, and in the early days, ND's PE program produced some of the finest football coaches in America. Look at today's football factories, schools in the SEC, and see how many had an early, successful coach that helped propel that program to prominence, that started as an ND graduate. The point is that ND's Physical Education degree may have started out by producing gridiron leaders, but it quickly evolved into a prestigious major that produced almost as many physicians as any premed program, and more scientists than most degree programs with a BS designation. ND even made PE tough!

So, there are still a lot of folks left around that know that ND being here, even existing has to do with, a) its football reputation, b) ability to present an identity to the immigrant and working class, and c) its reputation for outworking other institutions, which in the final analysis, is why the Navy kept UND open during the Second World War.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,443
Reaction score
1,375
I think if you lower the standards like most of the top programs have (Bama, FSU, OSU, Miami FL & especially USC etc.) people start thinking these schools are not higher institutions of learning but football factories and the cachet that used to exist becomes blurred. With regard to USC, FSU and Miami the face of those universities is still football and inctances where the term Convicts have been applied to Miami and could have as easily been applied to FSU, USC and Florida the reputation of their degrees in the public eye have not diminished. Stanford and ND have not suffered the same fate ever because of their higher academic, ethical and moral standards relative to the other powerhouses in CFB. The inner city athlete that comes to ND is different and wants something different than those who attend these other schools. When 9/10 of them wash out and do not make the pros or CFL what do they have left? No degree and even if they did graduate what kind of degree did they graduate with? Nothing anyone would recognize or respect. The same is not said of the ND and Stanford grads. In summing up my thoughts a college that has a football first win at all costs mentality will see it's educational cachet diminish imo.

With that said as a graduate of a school other than Notre Dame not known for any great athletics I say go all in for football because I want to see another National Championship before I die and if that means the degree from ND takes one step back so be it. 4-8 sucks!!!!
 

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
I think you're forgetting two huge factors: Meyer and Saban would also want the ability to recruit everyone and anyone they want, and they'd want 100% control over player discipline. ND would offer neither.

Couldn't agree more. Why would any big time coach come here? Saban and urban don't have to worry about kids grades the teachers are on the football teams side, they give out good grades and show bias to the football team. At ND the teachers watch you like a hawk

You guys are seriously arguing that Saban and Meyer would turn down millions of dollars over what they're currently making just because of our recruiting restrictions and academic standards? That's ridiculous. Yes, they enjoy winning, and all else being equal (which isn't the scenario we're debating here), they'd prefer to continue coaching where they can win with minimal recruiting and academic obstacles. But this is a mercenary profession, and there's tons of cachet in being the highest paid HC in history.

If ND opened its check book wide enough, Swarbrick could get anyone he wanted. Anyone.
 

zelezo vlk

Well-known member
Messages
18,012
Reaction score
5,055
Better start throwing in some good perks too. "Become the HC and we'll let you touch the Pieta. I know a guy in Florence too if you want to lick the David."
 

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
I get the desire to convince ourselves that Saban and Meyer would never come coach at ND because of X, Y and Z, but it just aint true. It comes off like a shy high school boy pining after the prom queen, but trying to make himself feel better by telling himself "She only dates jocks, so I'd never have a chance."

No, she dates the most popular guys. Just like Saban and Meyer will go coach for whatever school throws the most money at them. Perhaps the kid isn't willing to compromise his values* to get the prom queen to notice him, and in this (admittedly strained) metaphor, that seems to be the situation ND finds itself in. But let's be honest with ourselves here. We could get any coach we wanted badly enough.

*a separate argument addressed earlier in this thread
 
Last edited:

Free Manera

Well-known member
Messages
2,949
Reaction score
3,547
I get the desire to convince ourselves that Saban and Meyer would never come coach at ND because of X, Y and Z, but it just aint true. It comes off like a shy high school boy pining after the prom queen, but trying to make himself feel better by telling himself "She only dates jocks, so I'd never have a chance."

No, she dates the most popular guys. Just like Saban and Meyer will go coach for whatever school throws the most money at them. Perhaps the kid isn't willing to compromise his values* to get the prom queen to notice him, and in this (admittedly strained) metaphor, that seems to be the situation ND finds itself in. But let's be honest with ourselves here. We could get any coach we wanted badly enough.

*a separate argument addressed earlier in this thread

I think that's spot on with Meyer. I think Saban may not be interested just because he's too old to start over somewhere. However, these guys are ultra competitive and all want to be the top guy, (i.e. the highest paid guy), so it's possible he could do a swan song at ND to cement himself as the GOAT.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
I think if you lower the standards like most of the top programs have (Bama, FSU, OSU, Miami FL & especially USC etc.) people start thinking these schools are not higher institutions of learning but football factories and the cachet that used to exist becomes blurred. With regard to USC, FSU and Miami the face of those universities is still football and inctances where the term Convicts have been applied to Miami and could have as easily been applied to FSU, USC and Florida the reputation of their degrees in the public eye have not diminished. Stanford and ND have not suffered the same fate ever because of their higher academic, ethical and moral standards relative to the other powerhouses in CFB. The inner city athlete that comes to ND is different and wants something different than those who attend these other schools. When 9/10 of them wash out and do not make the pros or CFL what do they have left? No degree and even if they did graduate what kind of degree did they graduate with? Nothing anyone would recognize or respect. The same is not said of the ND and Stanford grads. In summing up my thoughts a college that has a football first win at all costs mentality will see it's educational cachet diminish imo.

With that said as a graduate of a school other than Notre Dame not known for any great athletics I say go all in for football because I want to see another National Championship before I die and if that means the degree from ND takes one step back so be it. 4-8 sucks!!!!

You live in SoCal and you think SC's football has lessened the SC degree? If you believe that do you believe any of the following:

- Did Patrick Ewing destroy Georgetown's reputation?

- Has Coach K's one and done basketball program for minimum qualifiers destroyed Duke's Top 10 reputation?

- Have any of the top Public Ivy's like Berkeley, UCLA, UVa, UM or UNC (Who even had fake classes for athletes) dropped out of USN&WR's Top 30?

- Has football/basketball destroyed Vandy or Rice?

- Has having significantly easier admission standards for football and basketball players at ND and Stanford destroyed their reputations?

Just curious.
 

Irishize

Well-known member
Messages
4,531
Reaction score
461
You guys are seriously arguing that Saban and Meyer would turn down millions of dollars over what they're currently making just because of our recruiting restrictions and academic standards? That's ridiculous. Yes, they enjoy winning, and all else being equal (which isn't the scenario we're debating here), they'd prefer to continue coaching where they can win with minimal recruiting and academic obstacles. But this is a mercenary profession, and there's tons of cachet in being the highest paid HC in history.

If ND opened its check book wide enough, Swarbrick could get anyone he wanted. Anyone.

Meyer has been quoted multiple times that he no longer has an interest in Notre Dame. He realizes they'll never compete with the factories...that window has closed.

If it were truly a matter of opening up the checkbook then Meyer, Saban or whichever guy Phil Knight desired would be coaching in Eugene.
 

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,004
You don't believe in the concept?

William & Mary
Miami
Berkeley
UCLA
Michigan
North Carolina
Texas
Vermont
Virginia

The concept was randomly introduced by one dude a long time ago and has no bearing whatsoever on reality today. The schools above are fine schools but Cal and Virginia are the only ones on the same level as the actual Ivy's anymore.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
The concept was randomly introduced by one dude a long time ago and has no bearing whatsoever on reality today. The schools above are fine schools but Cal and Virginia are the only ones on the same level as the actual Ivy's anymore.

To be fair, that "one dude" was an expert.

I'd put William & Mary in that group.

I was at Miami when Moll's book dropped and had just gone through the recruiting cycle which included all the Ivy's except Yale and 4 of the public ivy's. The ranking of various college educations has always fascinated me.
 

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
Meyer has been quoted multiple times that he no longer has an interest in Notre Dame. He realizes they'll never compete with the factories...that window has closed.

Right. Just like every coach currently has his dream job, vehemently denies looking around, and has every intention to coach next year and lead his team to a national title until... he's gone. Meyer has to make statements like that because: (1) there's always a significant portion of our fanbase clamoring to hire him; and (2) ND hasn't made him an offer he couldn't refuse yet. Until that happens (and it's not likely to), his comments on the matter aren't worth much.

If it were truly a matter of opening up the checkbook then Meyer, Saban or whichever guy Phil Knight desired would be coaching in Eugene.

Do you know who Phil Knight wants coaching in Eugene? The guy cares as much or more about #branding as he does about Ws.
 

Wingman Ray

Banned
Messages
1,578
Reaction score
110
And let's be honest, football bought & paid for ND's soul as we know it. ND as it is never would have existed if not for football.

Damn skippy. Amazing how easy it is for one to forget who brought one to the dance in the first place...
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
Do you know who Phil Knight wants coaching in Eugene? The guy cares as much or more about #branding as he does about Ws.

Phil is happy with the Meyer at OSU, Saban at Bama, Harbaugh at Michigan, Dabo at Clemson and Peterson at UW. He's selling gear all across the country.
 

ND NYC

New member
Messages
3,571
Reaction score
209
put me in the camp of disagreeing with whiskey and those who agree with his fervent assertion that ND can get whoever they want they just have to write a big enough check.

also, strongly believe that ND reputation as an institution of higher education would in no way be diminished or our reputation tarnished if we had an entire roster of borderline kids who were good kids who tried hard in class, and stayed out of trouble.

our recent academic scandals, drug, gun arrests are testament that doing it "our way" guarantees absolutley nothing for "reputation maintenance"-to wit we are taking the hit as being "just like the rest of em" anyway. you/we/I may not think so/know so...but the rest of the country does. and there are more of them hiring people out there than ND grads/supporters.

the key is making the right call on the kids we let in and give a chance to. finding those kids is and will be hard, but definitely not impossible.

and can we get rid of the foreign language HS requirement already? this to me demonstrates the ivory tower academics at ND biting the hand that feeds them.

and why not ease these football player in season 80 hour week a bit and give them one less class a semester, especially during the Fall? or maybe just for frosh and sophs as they get acclimated? surely accomodations can be made here. most of these recent academic scandals and infractions were by underclassmen.
 

phgreek

New member
Messages
6,956
Reaction score
433
put me in the camp of disagreeing with whiskey and those who agree with his fervent assertion that ND can get whoever they want they just have to write a big enough check.

also, strongly believe that ND reputation as an institution of higher education would in no way be diminished or our reputation tarnished if we had an entire roster of borderline kids who were good kids who tried hard in class, and stayed out of trouble.

our recent academic scandals, drug, gun arrests are testament that doing it "our way" guarantees absolutley nothing for "reputation maintenance"-to wit we are taking the hit as being "just like the rest of em" anyway. you/we/I may not think so/know so...but the rest of the country does. and there are more of them hiring people out there than ND grads/supporters.

the key is making the right call on the kids we let in and give a chance to. finding those kids is and will be hard, but definitely not impossible.

and can we get rid of the foreign language HS requirement already? this to me demonstrates the ivory tower academics at ND biting the hand that feeds them.

and why not ease these football player in season 80 hour week a bit and give them one less class a semester, especially during the Fall? or maybe just for frosh and sophs as they get acclimated? surely accomodations can be made here. most of these recent academic scandals and infractions were by underclassmen.

Agree with most of this.

The image issue where everyone sees ND as "no different"...they may say it...they may use every single incident as an opportunity to say it...but they KNOW it isn't true. Most people know it isn't true. If they say differently, they are seriously uninformed and likely a homer trying to troll people...can't change for people like that...you can however kick their ass :)!

I still don't understand why ND feels the need to tell an athlete how many credit hours they need while they participate in a sport...that goes for any sport. When I played, I went to a school that had serious GPA requirements, but as long as you did what you needed to in order to have the number of credits by the beginning of the following season, and stay with your class, they left it up to the individual. So I'd do 16-18 in the spring, and 12-14 in the fall. Why is that such a tough concept for ND? If I needed something because I changed my major, I went and got it in the summer. The POWER and beauty of attending a private institution is the attention and flexibility you simply cannot get at a state school...so ND should be allowing all students, including athletes to maximize the use of that attention and flexibility. When you make hokey rules for athletes...ironically, you diminish the power of the academic structure / culture.
 

dublinirish

Everestt Gholstonson
Messages
27,329
Reaction score
13,092
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">just remembered that Nebraska, now playing the 3-4 under Bob Diaco, didn't play 3-4 in the spring game because Diaco didn't want it on film</p>— Dr. Saturday (@YahooDrSaturday) <a href="https://twitter.com/YahooDrSaturday/status/889850176051044354">July 25, 2017</a></blockquote>
<script async src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 

ACamp1900

Counting my ‘bet against ND’ winnings
Messages
48,951
Reaction score
11,234
I'm going to be very interested to see how Diaco does out there...
 

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
19,128
Reaction score
11,077
Diaco's defense will be great against the B1G West's "powers" Iowa and Wisconsin... the bend-but-don't-break will be fine against their pro style offenses.

But it's going to struggle with Northwestern and Purdue.

It could make for some weird conference-standing scenarios if Nebraska wins the big games but loses to the obscure teams behind defensive struggles.
 

GowerND11

Well-known member
Messages
6,539
Reaction score
3,296
Diaco's defense will be great against the B1G West's "powers" Iowa and Wisconsin... the bend-but-don't-break will be fine against their pro style offenses.

But it's going to struggle with Northwestern and Purdue.

It could make for some weird conference-standing scenarios if Nebraska wins the big games but loses to the obscure teams behind defensive struggles.

Technically speaking... Bend but don't break should work just fine against those spread teams. They like to score quick, looking for big plays. If he can force them to sustain drives, that's where spread teams struggle.

That's the philosophy Stanford has used against Oregon with success. We look at Stanford and think of a hard nosed defense, which they are. But they force Oregon into taking small yardage. Gaining 4, 2, 4, 3, 1, 0 yards and so on. Then, with less field to work with Oregon stalls and settles for a field goal, or even if they do score a TD, they've wasted a lot of clock, which plays into Stanford wanting to grind it out.

I'm not saying Diaco's Nebraska D can be Stanford, but I would assume it may match that kind of production against the "less good" teams in the BIG that run a spread.

JMO
 

ACamp1900

Counting my ‘bet against ND’ winnings
Messages
48,951
Reaction score
11,234
It would be nice to see Nebraska gain a bit of it's past glory... dealing with them as the cfb powerhouse in the mid 90s was much easier than just about anyone else we've had to suffer through since.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
Wisconsin will methodically bend them 4.5 yards a snap right into the endzone.
 

Old Man Mike

Fast as Lightning!
Messages
8,979
Reaction score
6,471
I wish Bobby-the-D every success, but do not believe that anything great will happen, unless he has markedly evolved. That "clockwork precision" defensive "geography" that he insists on playing only worked because of a team full of superb defenders (Manti, Tuitt, Nix, KLM, HSmith, Zeke). I rather remember what happened to that predictable "clock" when a team with excellent athletes had a coaching staff capable of fine-tune analyzing it. Bama knew exactly where we'd be on every formation snap. Several B1G OCs will too, unless he's evolved to throw more deception in.

The stud programs are going to have a dedicated analyst studying him all season before their practices against him. Most of the time, one hopes to see "tendencies." With Bobby-the-D you "discover" ironclad laws.

Still, I liked Diaco and hope he has become trickier.
 
Top