Kelly said several times last year that the good hands people, as far as catching punts was concerned, were John Goodman, Harrison Smith, and Robbie Toma. He probably would have said Mike Floyd too, except that he didn't want to play him there.
Everybody wants to see some production out of punting returns. But if we have good quarterbacking, the Kelly Offense can score from anywhere on the field. (just like we did last year when there were no Interceptions, sacks, or fumbles [or fifteen yarders]). It takes something spectacularly bad [and usually self-inflicted] to stop Kelly's offense --- run or pass.
So, we MUST CATCH THE BALL. I'd love it if one of the new guys like Neal could catch the ball. I'd love it if we'd try to regularly attempt blocked punts to create returnable semi-flubs. But NOTHING supercedes catching the ball. With our defense it's really tough to score against us, unless we give them most of the field for free.
An aside: in high school GAIII returned the Kickoffs, but Josh returned the punts. Why hasn't Josh gotten a look here? Or has he?