'14 FL WR Isaiah McKenzie ( Georgia ¯\_(ツ)_/¯)

woolybug25

#1 Vineyard Vines Fan
Messages
17,677
Reaction score
3,018
There is no comparison with Tony Rice. None.

Tony Rice's HS academic credidentials would make him INELIGIBLE for a FBS Scholarship today.

He would be a non-qualifier.

A 690 SAT would require a 2.825 GPA on the NCAA Sliding Scale. Conversely, a 2.0 would require an SAT of 1010.

A 700 would require 2.80 while a 2.05 (a little North) would require a corresponding 990.

Oh and he would have to take an additional 4 core courses.

Yes, he was in the first Prop 48 class but 1986 was the only year ND took any Prop 48's. It was Holtz's first year and he had a lot of leverage following the Faust Era. He pushed for the exception and got it from Hesburgh on a trial basis. In 2010 I posted the following about ND's Prop 48s:

Ha... you say that they have NO COMPARISON... but then yet outline an almost identical academic profile. The difference is that Isaiah had to work to improve his and Tony didn't. Past that, there are a myriad of similarities between them as people.

- Both freaky athletes
- Both from the poor south
- Both undersized
- Both chose (hopefully, in IM's case) Notre Dame, albeit the more difficult path.

So i'm not sure where you are going with them not being similar, as they clearly are. If your point was that Rice wouldn't have been able to get in today, who knows what he would have done if were in IM's shoes. Maybe he would have rose to the occasion as well.
 

GoldenIsThyFame

Well-known member
Messages
10,899
Reaction score
789
Barton Simmons on Bill King this morning said UF is trending to land McKenzie.
 
Last edited:
K

koonja

Guest
Anyone want to make a vbet?

I'll pay anyone 500 mill if he makes it to campus, I want 1 billion if he doesn't make it to campus.

That's as high as I'll go, anyone wants to go lower and keep the ratio the same Ill consider it.

Proposal:

I do not have enough vbucks and I have a couple of looming bets, but I would do this.

I will bet you 100 million vbucks that he makes it to ND's campus for a visit, against your 50 million vbucks (keeping your requested ratio in tact). However, IFF he makes the visit AND he ultimately signs with ND over Florida, Ole Miss, etc., I get an additional 50 million from you.

So here's the scenarios:

1) He doesn't visit, commits elsewhere, 100 mill to you.
2) He doesn't visit, commits to ND, 100 mill to you.
2) He does visit but doesn't commit to ND, 50 million to me.
3) He does visit, commits to ND, 100 mill to me.

What say you?
 

Monk

Active member
Messages
593
Reaction score
41
Anyone want to make a vbet?

I'll pay anyone 500 mill if he makes it to campus, I want 1 billion if he doesn't make it to campus.

That's as high as I'll go, anyone wants to go lower and keep the ratio the same Ill consider it.

I have just over one thousand. I'll take that bet.
 

JTLA

Active member
Messages
231
Reaction score
73
wait huh?

wait huh?

b12.png

Is that a quote from Godfather with a pic from Scarface attributed to Carlito's Way?

or is that the joke and now you're all laughing at me?
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,584
Reaction score
20,035
Just curious where the pessimistic attitude is coming from? People just tired of recruiting games?

I ask because the updates have been positive for some time. I believe it was Loy who hinted not to get distracted by the offers coming in and IM having fun because he's never had the chance until recently. I think its IM creating drama just to have his chance to truly commit.

The kid has busted his ass in the classroom and now is reaping what he has sown through hard work. I'm glad he's having fun.

Loy/Wiltfong expect him to be apart of the class and with ND getting the last official, I see little reason to think otherwise.

And the off chance he does go elsewhere, I'll still root for him because he worked hard to get his chance playing at D1. He took the road less traveled and for that I salute him.

chuck-norris-approves_zps6a207f77.gif
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,584
Reaction score
20,035
There is no comparison with Tony Rice. None.

Tony Rice's HS academic credidentials would make him INELIGIBLE for a FBS Scholarship today.

He would be a non-qualifier.

A 690 SAT would require a 2.825 GPA on the NCAA Sliding Scale. Conversely, a 2.0 would require an SAT of 1010.

A 700 would require 2.80 while a 2.05 (a little North) would require a corresponding 990.

Oh and he would have to take an additional 4 core courses.

Yes, he was in the first Prop 48 class but 1986 was the only year ND took any Prop 48's. It was Holtz's first year and he had a lot of leverage following the Faust Era. He pushed for the exception and got it from Hesburgh on a trial basis. In 2010 I posted the following about ND's Prop 48s:

I think you're splitting hairs here. While prop 48 isn't around and the academics at ND have been elevated, both scenarios are still based on the same main points.

They're both students who had performed poorly while in HS and want to play FB at ND.
 

zelezo vlk

Well-known member
Messages
18,010
Reaction score
5,049
Are those SAT statistics taking into account the old scoring vs the new scoring?
 

IrishFaninTX

New member
Messages
1,038
Reaction score
46
Are those SAT statistics taking into account the old scoring vs the new scoring?

That's what I was thinking because the old scoring had I believe 1600 as a perfect score and 1600 is about average now, isn't it? So a 690 today would be extremely low but Tony Rice's score would like be higher than that just based on the new scoring system.
 

wizards8507

Well-known member
Messages
20,660
Reaction score
2,661
Are those SAT statistics taking into account the old scoring vs the new scoring?

That's what I was thinking because the old scoring had I believe 1600 as a perfect score and 1600 is about average now, isn't it? So a 690 today would be extremely low but Tony Rice's score would like be higher than that just based on the new scoring system.

Irrelevant. The only difference is the writing section, which Notre Dame ignores in their admissions process anyways. A 690 is equally horrendous both then and now because when someone says 690 now, they're still just talking about math plus verbal. 1600 is still perfect for the two sections that count. For reference, must ND students have around a 690 on a single section.

Edit: The NCAA sliding scale is also only based on two sections, or 1600 points.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S III using Tapatalk 4
 
Last edited:

BGIF

Varsity Club
Messages
43,946
Reaction score
2,922
I think you're splitting hairs here. While prop 48 isn't around and the academics at ND have been elevated, both scenarios are still based on the same main points.

They're both students who had performed poorly while in HS and want to play FB at ND.

Splitting hairs? In a specious premise? The post I responded to note similarities like size, etc

Tony Rice was 6-1 190 pounds. Isiah McKenzie is 5-8 165 pounds

Neither the height nor weight is close to similar


They're both from the South. he noted.

Yeah, 700 miles apart the same distance as from South Bend IN to Montgomery AL.


One was a prime time QB with offers from everybody. The other is a 3 star WR/KR who's prime offers about a half dozen.

One comes from The Piedmont region near the mountains around elevation 800 in a town of 4000 and a medium family income of $24,000 (today) and a HS that graduates 200 students a year. The other lives at sea level just west of Ft Lauderdale in a city of 85,000 with a medium family income of $80,000 and a HS that has 2,700 students.

Both may been below the poverty line but one has advantages the other didn't know existed.


But their physical builds, hometown, school, and family 1040 don't have a single thing to do with whether they attend.

The irony is one was declared a NON QUALIFIER because he failed to pass the minimum requirements for an NCAA scholarship and for that reason got to attend ND under a one time program while the other is a QUALIFER for a NCAA scholarship BUT may not be admitted to ND and if he is may still chose to go elsewhere where he won't have to work as hard in the classroom as Tony Rice did. Tony Rice jumped at the chance to come to ND and worked his butt off in the classroom and on the field.

Under Prop 48 Rice could go to class and could study. That was mandated by the NCAA Prop 48 program. Not only could he not play as a freshman, he could not practice. Class to study hall. Study hall to class.
 

BGIF

Varsity Club
Messages
43,946
Reaction score
2,922
That's what I was thinking because the old scoring had I believe 1600 as a perfect score and 1600 is about average now, isn't it? So a 690 today would be extremely low but Tony Rice's score would like be higher than that just based on the new scoring system.

Wizard's got it right, the NCAA only considers two of the three parts, Math and Verbal on the SATs.

1600 was a perfect score on the exam for Students and Athletes in Rice's day. 2400 is perfection for STUDENTS, not athletic scholarships, today. It's still 1600 when looking at an an NCAA Grant in Aid.

The sum of the Math and Verbal scores are used on the NCAA Sliding Scale so a 1600 is still the max test score for the NCAA whether today or 30 years ago.

A lot of recruits today report their three part score to the media. So a kid with a 1500 could be carrying a 300 on his math test and the public wouldn't be the wiser. It's not as easy to tell today from recruiting service reports.

And for whoever brought up re-centering, yes, the SAT scoring system has been reconfigured twice, I believe, since Tony took his exams. So let's give him another 50 points today. He would still be INELIGIBLE not just for ND but for an athletic scholarship at ANY FBS school just as he was in '86. Only the Prop 48 program is gone so Tony would be going JUCO or playing for a lower division school.

Tony worked very hard and has been commmended for his success but realize he came in through a window that has only existed for one ND recruiting class.

Paddy Mullen from MO was academically deficient and worked hard his Senior Year of HS after being told by ND that his GPA was too low and had to be raised although he was already eligible by NCAA standards. Paddy made the grades and was admitted. There are others that have done the same.

Aldo de la Garza was a Texas OL who wanted ND dearly. He also buckled down his Senior year hit the books and retook tests. He never got approved by ND but he did qualify for an NCAA scholarship and was a 3 year starter at A&M.

Carson Palmer was told by ND Admissions to retake a course or a test as was WR David Terrell out of VA. Both balked. Palmer went to USC and Terrell went to Michigan. Terrell was an ND verbal before he docomitted because he was "dissed" but having to do "extra work" to get into ND. Palmer spoke publicly about the ND "slight" before one of the ND/USC games. Neither got admitted to ND but both made All-American on the field.

Walter Payton went ballistic when he was told his son had math deficiencies. If I remember correctly his son went to St. Viator's where Walter had sent him so he could get a solid college prep education. The problem was St Viator's has supplied a lot of students to ND over the years and Admissions was very familiar with the course offerings there as well as the quallity of work St Viator's students produced at ND. Hugh pedigree but not the right courses and correspoding grades. Bottom line, no admission. I think he ended up at Miami.

In '95 Holtz got LOI's from two students which had NOT been approved by ND Admissions. Holtz tried to finesse them passed Admissions. Admissions put their foot down and both were denied. There was no final senior year of high school do over, nor summer school option, nor test re-take. Holtz made some phone calls, one went to FSU and then Marshall after he got tossed out of FSU. He made All-American and All-Pro. The other had a stellar RB career at Miami and I believe was an AA.

Maurice Stovall had an 800 on his SATS for two parts. He's the lowest test score I recall in the past twenty some years being admitted to ND. There always appears to be a 17 or two and to their credit and to Admissions and the Tutorial Staff and Coaches most of them made it through. And SEC or Big 10 posters will send me PM's about ND's hypocritcal standards.

ND Admissions does not have hard and fast numbers for GPAs and Test Scores. They look at the student's HS performance and character and make a judgement call. "Many are called but few are chosen."

But at ND of those chosen ... almost everyone graduates with a meaningful degree that was earned in the classroom regardless of size, hometown, or family 1040.
 

irishfanjho15

Hello world
Messages
2,967
Reaction score
251
But at ND of those chosen ... almost everyone graduates with a meaningful degree that was earned in the classroom regardless of size, hometown, or family 1040.

And at the end of the day this is the difference between Notre Dame and Stanford vs. everyone else in D1.
 
Messages
666
Reaction score
84
Wizard's got it right, the NCAA only considers two of the three parts, Math and Verbal on the SATs.

1600 was a perfect score on the exam for Students and Athletes in Rice's day. 2400 is perfection for STUDENTS, not athletic scholarships, today. It's still 1600 when looking at an an NCAA Grant in Aid.

The sum of the Math and Verbal scores are used on the NCAA Sliding Scale so a 1600 is still the max test score for the NCAA whether today or 30 years ago.

A lot of recruits today report their three part score to the media. So a kid with a 1500 could be carrying a 300 on his math test and the public wouldn't be the wiser. It's not as easy to tell today from recruiting service reports.

And for whoever brought up re-centering, yes, the SAT scoring system has been reconfigured twice, I believe, since Tony took his exams. So let's give him another 50 points today. He would still be INELIGIBLE not just for ND but for an athletic scholarship at ANY FBS school just as he was in '86. Only the Prop 48 program is gone so Tony would be going JUCO or playing for a lower division school.

Tony worked very hard and has been commmended for his success but realize he came in through a window that has only existed for one ND recruiting class.

Paddy Mullen from MO was academically deficient and worked hard his Senior Year of HS after being told by ND that his GPA was too low and had to be raised although he was already eligible by NCAA standards. Paddy made the grades and was admitted. There are others that have done the same.

Aldo de la Garza was a Texas OL who wanted ND dearly. He also buckled down his Senior year hit the books and retook tests. He never got approved by ND but he did qualify for an NCAA scholarship and was a 3 year starter at A&M.

Carson Palmer was told by ND Admissions to retake a course or a test as was WR David Terrell out of VA. Both balked. Palmer went to USC and Terrell went to Michigan. Terrell was an ND verbal before he docomitted because he was "dissed" but having to do "extra work" to get into ND. Palmer spoke publicly about the ND "slight" before one of the ND/USC games. Neither got admitted to ND but both made All-American on the field.

Walter Payton went ballistic when he was told his son had math deficiencies. If I remember correctly his son went to St. Viator's where Walter had sent him so he could get a solid college prep education. The problem was St Viator's has supplied a lot of students to ND over the years and Admissions was very familiar with the course offerings there as well as the quallity of work St Viator's students produced at ND. Hugh pedigree but not the right courses and correspoding grades. Bottom line, no admission. I think he ended up at Miami.

In '95 Holtz got LOI's from two students which had NOT been approved by ND Admissions. Holtz tried to finesse them passed Admissions. Admissions put their foot down and both were denied. There was no final senior year of high school do over, nor summer school option, nor test re-take. Holtz made some phone calls, one went to FSU and then Marshall after he got tossed out of FSU. He made All-American and All-Pro. The other had a stellar RB career at Miami and I believe was an AA.

Maurice Stovall had an 800 on his SATS for two parts. He's the lowest test score I recall in the past twenty some years being admitted to ND. There always appears to be a 17 or two and to their credit and to Admissions and the Tutorial Staff and Coaches most of them made it through. And SEC or Big 10 posters will send me PM's about ND's hypocritcal standards.

ND Admissions does not have hard and fast numbers for GPAs and Test Scores. They look at the student's HS performance and character and make a judgement call. "Many are called but few are chosen."

But at ND of those chosen ... almost everyone graduates with a meaningful degree that was earned in the classroom regardless of size, hometown, or family 1040.

I cannot decide. Is this correspondence coming from a kindly Unitarian minister, or could it be Mister Rogers himself?
 

connor_in

Oh Yeeaah!!!
Messages
11,433
Reaction score
1,006
Wizard's got it right, the NCAA only considers two of the three parts, Math and Verbal on the SATs.

1600 was a perfect score on the exam for Students and Athletes in Rice's day. 2400 is perfection for STUDENTS, not athletic scholarships, today. It's still 1600 when looking at an an NCAA Grant in Aid.

The sum of the Math and Verbal scores are used on the NCAA Sliding Scale so a 1600 is still the max test score for the NCAA whether today or 30 years ago.

A lot of recruits today report their three part score to the media. So a kid with a 1500 could be carrying a 300 on his math test and the public wouldn't be the wiser. It's not as easy to tell today from recruiting service reports.

And for whoever brought up re-centering, yes, the SAT scoring system has been reconfigured twice, I believe, since Tony took his exams. So let's give him another 50 points today. He would still be INELIGIBLE not just for ND but for an athletic scholarship at ANY FBS school just as he was in '86. Only the Prop 48 program is gone so Tony would be going JUCO or playing for a lower division school.

Tony worked very hard and has been commmended for his success but realize he came in through a window that has only existed for one ND recruiting class.

Paddy Mullen from MO was academically deficient and worked hard his Senior Year of HS after being told by ND that his GPA was too low and had to be raised although he was already eligible by NCAA standards. Paddy made the grades and was admitted. There are others that have done the same.

Aldo de la Garza was a Texas OL who wanted ND dearly. He also buckled down his Senior year hit the books and retook tests. He never got approved by ND but he did qualify for an NCAA scholarship and was a 3 year starter at A&M.

Carson Palmer was told by ND Admissions to retake a course or a test as was WR David Terrell out of VA. Both balked. Palmer went to USC and Terrell went to Michigan. Terrell was an ND verbal before he docomitted because he was "dissed" but having to do "extra work" to get into ND. Palmer spoke publicly about the ND "slight" before one of the ND/USC games. Neither got admitted to ND but both made All-American on the field.

Walter Payton went ballistic when he was told his son had math deficiencies. If I remember correctly his son went to St. Viator's where Walter had sent him so he could get a solid college prep education. The problem was St Viator's has supplied a lot of students to ND over the years and Admissions was very familiar with the course offerings there as well as the quallity of work St Viator's students produced at ND. Hugh pedigree but not the right courses and correspoding grades. Bottom line, no admission. I think he ended up at Miami.

In '95 Holtz got LOI's from two students which had NOT been approved by ND Admissions. Holtz tried to finesse them passed Admissions. Admissions put their foot down and both were denied. There was no final senior year of high school do over, nor summer school option, nor test re-take. Holtz made some phone calls, one went to FSU and then Marshall after he got tossed out of FSU. He made All-American and All-Pro. The other had a stellar RB career at Miami and I believe was an AA.

Maurice Stovall had an 800 on his SATS for two parts. He's the lowest test score I recall in the past twenty some years being admitted to ND. There always appears to be a 17 or two and to their credit and to Admissions and the Tutorial Staff and Coaches most of them made it through. And SEC or Big 10 posters will send me PM's about ND's hypocritcal standards.

ND Admissions does not have hard and fast numbers for GPAs and Test Scores. They look at the student's HS performance and character and make a judgement call. "Many are called but few are chosen."

But at ND of those chosen ... almost everyone graduates with a meaningful degree that was earned in the classroom regardless of size, hometown, or family 1040.

Based on your use of BOLD...Math and Verbal balked? Why would they do that?
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,584
Reaction score
20,035
Splitting hairs? In a specious premise? The post I responded to note similarities like size, etc

Tony Rice was 6-1 190 pounds. Isiah McKenzie is 5-8 165 pounds

Neither the height nor weight is close to similar


They're both from the South. he noted.

Yeah, 700 miles apart the same distance as from South Bend IN to Montgomery AL.


One was a prime time QB with offers from everybody. The other is a 3 star WR/KR who's prime offers about a half dozen.

One comes from The Piedmont region near the mountains around elevation 800 in a town of 4000 and a medium family income of $24,000 (today) and a HS that graduates 200 students a year. The other lives at sea level just west of Ft Lauderdale in a city of 85,000 with a medium family income of $80,000 and a HS that has 2,700 students.

Both may been below the poverty line but one has advantages the other didn't know existed.


But their physical builds, hometown, school, and family 1040 don't have a single thing to do with whether they attend.

The irony is one was declared a NON QUALIFIER because he failed to pass the minimum requirements for an NCAA scholarship and for that reason got to attend ND under a one time program while the other is a QUALIFER for a NCAA scholarship BUT may not be admitted to ND and if he is may still chose to go elsewhere where he won't have to work as hard in the classroom as Tony Rice did. Tony Rice jumped at the chance to come to ND and worked his butt off in the classroom and on the field.

Under Prop 48 Rice could go to class and could study. That was mandated by the NCAA Prop 48 program. Not only could he not play as a freshman, he could not practice. Class to study hall. Study hall to class.

If you want to consider all of the intangibles that don't really matter (size, Height, speed, location they come from) then you are right. My point is this. None of those things matter, because admissions doesn't give a darn about those things. The only thing that matters to them is the kids academics and if they qualify for ND. Bottom line TR didn't and IM doesn't at this time from what we all know.

My hunch is if IM gets close, BK is going to go to bat for him and show admissions what IM did to try and become eligible and because he committed to doing the required work, he'll put in the effort in the classroom. If he is admitted, then both didn't meet ND standards but were admitted under different circumstances.
 
Last edited:

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,993
Just starting his OV today...

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" lang="en"><p>&#55356;&#57288;&#55357;&#56908; TOUCHDOWN <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=%23landed&src=hash">#landed</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=%23gators&src=hash">#gators</a></p>— Isaiah McKenzie (@JoyStick_izzy) <a href="https://twitter.com/JoyStick_izzy/statuses/424251114498715649">January 17, 2014</a></blockquote>
<script async src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Going to be an interesting weekend.
 

Brooklyn

Found vbPlaza
Messages
622
Reaction score
24
Really want this kid. Would be a gamechanger for our special teams. Hopefully he continues to work hard in the classroom and picks us.
 

irishog77

NOT SINBAD's NEPHEW
Messages
7,441
Reaction score
2,206
I'll be surprised if he makes it for his ND official. Hope he does....but betting against it.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,993
I'll be surprised if he makes it for his ND official. Hope he does....but betting against it.

Same. The way we make it through this one is if Derrell Scott is their primary target and the Gators land him... or otherwise don't show McKenzie enough "love." Ole Miss is... well, we all know what Ole Miss is.

His talents are such a dire need for this team, I really do hope this all works out.
 
K

koonja

Guest
Grey hammer I'm still waiting for your decision on my proposed bet!

Or are you yeller!
 

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
16,822
Reaction score
16,085
Proposal:

I do not have enough vbucks and I have a couple of looming bets, but I would do this.

I will bet you 100 million vbucks that he makes it to ND's campus for a visit, against your 50 million vbucks (keeping your requested ratio in tact). However, IFF he makes the visit AND he ultimately signs with ND over Florida, Ole Miss, etc., I get an additional 50 million from you.

So here's the scenarios:

1) He doesn't visit, commits elsewhere, 100 mill to you.
2) He doesn't visit, commits to ND, 100 mill to you.
2) He does visit but doesn't commit to ND, 50 million to me.
3) He does visit, commits to ND, 100 mill to me.

What say you?

Taken.
 
Top