Breaking (Lawsuit Against ND)

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,004
Representing a kid suing your alma mater in the town you work in is indeed a ballsy move.

That's the one thing that concerns me. This guy presumably is working on a contingency fee basis so he must think there's a good chance of a settlement, at a minimum.

Lawyer's are money Hungary asshats. They don't care about anything other then money.

I am indeed a money hungry asshat but I would never ever assist someone in suing ND. This guy is a tool.
 

NDohio

Well-known member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
3,060
Lawyer's are money Hungary asshats. They don't care about anything other then money.

Come on. There are good people that become lawyers and bad people that become lawyers. Let's not insult all lawyers because there a some Saul Goodmans out there.
 

NDinTEXAS

Member
Messages
363
Reaction score
11
maxresdefault1.jpg


Sounds like a good host to me
 

woolybug25

#1 Vineyard Vines Fan
Messages
17,677
Reaction score
3,018
Lawsuit against ND.


BREAKING: Sexual harassment at center of lawsuit against Notre Dame, employee | Local - WSBT.com

I know the attorney involved and there are many athletes named.

Couple things:

1) You mentioned that you know one of the lawyers. If that is Peter J. Agostino, please let him know that we all think he's a dikfaced Judas, and to please never step foot on campus again.

2) Next time you start a thread, can you please be a little bit more specific than, "Breaking".
 

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
Representing a kid suing your alma mater in the town you work in is indeed a ballsy move.

If he wasn't already on ND's sh!tlist, he is now. Have to believe there will be serious professional repercussions for filing such a frivolous lawsuit against the most powerful corporate entity in South Bend.

Yes, and they're unemployed.

Why do you think there are so many attorneys posting here?
 

pkt77242

IPA Man
Messages
10,805
Reaction score
719
If he wasn't already on ND's sh!tlist, he is now. Have to believe there will be serious professional repercussions for filing such a frivolous lawsuit against the most powerful corporate entity in South Bend.



Why do you think there are so many attorneys posting here?

Because money hungry asshats have lots of downtime waiting for the next ambulance with the "victim" in it.
 

NDgradstudent

Banned
Messages
2,414
Reaction score
165
If he wasn't already on ND's sh!tlist, he is now. Have to believe there will be serious professional repercussions for filing such a frivolous lawsuit against the most powerful corporate entity in South Bend.

Don't be so sure.

First of all, if the woman was fired, then some of the allegations are probably true. If it was simply frivolous, I assume ND would not have fired her.

Furthermore, he'd have to be pretty hungry for money/attention to file a wholly frivolous lawsuit against ND, for the reasons you cite. Alums always say that they are doing this sort of thing out of "love of their alma mater" anyway. And there are enough alums who believe that ND has gone astray in some way to sympathize with that.

Finally, many lawyers, like journalists, see themselves as fighting "the system." What they would regard as his "speaking truth to power" could earn him some respect. Is that dubious? In most cases, yes. But it is a big part of what lawyers tell themselves about legal practice.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,995
Nobody wants this going to trial. They won't win at trial. But ND sure as hell doesn't want this woman or the entire team up there getting deposed. Needs to get settled for a reasonable sum and move on.
 

NDgradstudent

Banned
Messages
2,414
Reaction score
165
According to a new article in the SBT, ND fired her last month:

SOUTH BEND — The University of Notre Dame last month fired a female employee who worked as an academic coach amid allegations she pressured a male student into having sex with her daughter.[...]

After completing an internal review of the employee and her daughter's interactions with the male student, Notre Dame concluded that the employee's behavior violated its values and its sexual and discriminatory harassment policy, and fired her, according to a copy of a letter provided by, the South Bend-based law firm representing the male student.[...]

The woman employee was an academic coach who worked for Notre Dame's First Year of Studies program, and she started in that job in August 2014, attorney Peter Agostino said Monday.

Notre Dame's First Year of Studies Program website on Friday said that the program in fall 2014 started a pilot program that provided new students access to an academic coach and listed contact information for a woman employee. On Monday, that page link was no longer available.[...]

The woman allegedly provided lodging, transportation, hotel rooms and condoms for the encounters, pressuring the student to continue the relationship and threatening him when he tried to end it. The sexual encounters he was pressured into created a racially hostile environment, causing him to suffer academically and emotionally, according to the suit.

When the student first sought to end the encounters, the suit claims, the woman convinced him he needed mental counseling. The student was counseled by a Notre Dame employee who was a "friend and confidant" of the defendant and who sought to medicate the student to keep him passive, the suit claims.

The stress of the "hostile sexual environment and degradation" was furthered exacerbated by the woman pressuring the student to convert to Catholicism, according to the suit.

The student claims he brought the situation to the attention of Notre Dame officials a few weeks ago, but the university has "failed to act to remedy the situation," the suit says.

The woman doesn't know much about Catholicism, whatever else she did.
 

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
Don't be so sure.

First of all, if the woman was fired, then some of the allegations are probably true. If it was simply frivolous, I assume ND would not have fired her.

It's frivolous because the odds of ND actually being held liable for any of this through respondeat superior is nearly nil. He's looking to shake the University down for a quick settlement, of which he'll get to pocket 30%.

Furthermore, he'd have to be pretty hungry for money/attention to file a wholly frivolous lawsuit against ND, for the reasons you cite. Alums always say that they are doing this sort of thing out of "love of their alma mater" anyway. And there are enough alums who believe that ND has gone astray in some way to sympathize with that.

If he has evidence that ND "knew or should have known" about what was going on, it isn't obvious from his Complaint.

Finally, many lawyers, like journalists, see themselves as fighting "the system." What they would regard as his "speaking truth to power" could earn him some respect. Is that dubious? In most cases, yes. But it is a big part of what lawyers tell themselves about legal practice.

Even laypersons who read that ridiculous Complaint can tell that "justice" isn't at issue here. The only people who are going to hold Agostino in higher regard for having done this are those who were already prejudiced ND to begin with.
 

Voltaire

Active member
Messages
211
Reaction score
72
This is like some distorted real life version of Amy Poehler's "cool mom" character from Mean Girls.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
One of the partners in the firm won't have season tickets next year.

Lots of Crusaders at that firm. Me makes sad by dat.


Jeez fellas... I throw you a bone 3 days ago and you are just getting up in arms about it now?

I come here to eat, not cook!
 

NDgradstudent

Banned
Messages
2,414
Reaction score
165
I won't name the woman employee in question, but the SBT article I linked to earlier in this thread basically tells you how to find it.
 

JD Irish

Well-known member
Messages
735
Reaction score
266
Based on the complaint, would seem like ND could easily have a solid affirmative defense. Every allegation is intentional conduct by the employee, clearly outside the scope of employment. It's borderline frivolous.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,599
Reaction score
20,062
"the woman convinced him he needed mental counseling. "

He probably does need counseling. How many red blooded guys are gonna turn away some free snatch at that age?
 

phgreek

New member
Messages
6,956
Reaction score
433
...Hmmmm

Kid gets an ACADEMIC scholarship to Notre Dame....and then finds himself in need of an Academic Coach. Who here finds that out of character for a kid who can get an ACADEMIC scholly to ND?

Would love to know what his grades have looked like, and the status of the scholly.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
...Hmmmm

Kid gets an ACADEMIC scholarship to Notre Dame....and then finds himself in need of an Academic Coach. Who here finds that out of character for a kid who can get an ACADEMIC scholly to ND?

Would love to know what his grades have looked like, and the status of the scholly.

Just because you get accepted to a great school, that makes you immune to falling behind the pack and needing assistance?
 

loomis41973

Banned
Messages
4,055
Reaction score
203
This shit is bizzare...even dailymail with a story about it.

ND doing its usual terrible job with PR.
 

T Town Tommy

Alabama Bag Man
Messages
6,278
Reaction score
2,768
IE lawyers..

Would Notre Dame take it to court to try and get a dismissal and then settle if it's not thrown out? Just seems to me the school acted appropriately once the complaint was raised. I don't see any grounds for the lawsuit since the mom acted outside her scope of duties and was terminated once the school was made aware of her activities.
 

irishnd31

Biggest Idiot On This Site
Messages
6,208
Reaction score
8,088
Where was all this easy ass when I was in school? Hell I'd have $100 in dinner,a movie, and a case of Natty Ice just to get have a coin flips shot at snagging tail.
 
Top