Domina Nostra
Well-known member
- Messages
- 6,251
- Reaction score
- 1,388
IMO, there are only so many kids who can step in and compete for starting time immediately. Kids develop over time, and it is not silly to hope for a real shift in maturity and ability from seniors. Even if they are limited athletically, they are a known quantity and provide stability. Goodman is fast and tall and pretty strong. He is not a throw away. He just needs to get his act together. Also, there was zero chance he was going to push Floyd, so his minutes were always going to be slim. Think Robby Parris holding onto that Clausen throw against USC when the safety basically broke his ribs. Seniors turn things around.
This is not a knock on anyone (or even a slight knock). Golden Tate was incompetent and ran exactly one route ("GO!") as a freshman. Daniels, who will be a stud if and when he focuses 100%, did not play last year. (As he implied, it was hard for him to give 100% knowing, for a fact, that there was no chance he was going to play. Some very competitive people are like that.) Granted, Floyd was here, so it is going to be easier this year.
Greenberry appears to be good enough to step right in and compete, but he will have so much to learn. Ferguson and Brown do not (my opinion). Brown probably needs to get stronger, though he has the speed and the skills to be a game-changer eventualy. Ferguson needs to get more consistent, though he has the athleticism to be a red zone nightmare. I think they can play in limited roles this year, but you can't game plan around them.
Agholor and Neal were on the Greenberry level, and might have justified bumping Goodman. But we don't look like we are going to get either, so Goodman becomes a much easier call.
Payton makes the call harder because he is so mature and technically sound. We'll see.
This is not a knock on anyone (or even a slight knock). Golden Tate was incompetent and ran exactly one route ("GO!") as a freshman. Daniels, who will be a stud if and when he focuses 100%, did not play last year. (As he implied, it was hard for him to give 100% knowing, for a fact, that there was no chance he was going to play. Some very competitive people are like that.) Granted, Floyd was here, so it is going to be easier this year.
Greenberry appears to be good enough to step right in and compete, but he will have so much to learn. Ferguson and Brown do not (my opinion). Brown probably needs to get stronger, though he has the speed and the skills to be a game-changer eventualy. Ferguson needs to get more consistent, though he has the athleticism to be a red zone nightmare. I think they can play in limited roles this year, but you can't game plan around them.
Agholor and Neal were on the Greenberry level, and might have justified bumping Goodman. But we don't look like we are going to get either, so Goodman becomes a much easier call.
Payton makes the call harder because he is so mature and technically sound. We'll see.
Last edited: