Irish4life
Well-known member
- Messages
- 2,887
- Reaction score
- 3,674
Pyne is playing with a ton of confidence. Love to see it. Had a couple of straight up incredible throws tonight.
Pyne balling and making reads! Can't remember the last time we had a QB go through progression past 2 reads. BQ or Jim Claussen? Great game 5'9" pimpin Pyne!
He is pretty great in the pocket. Who would have thought that after his first half against Cal.
Agreed. After the season you still bring in the best grad transfer possible and let them battle it out.I like the kid. But he doesn't have the ceiling ND needs.
I’d love to have a grad transfer but most will want assurances of starting.Agreed. After the season you still bring in the best grad transfer possible and let them battle it out.
Then find someone who's willing to come in and compete for the job.I’d love to have a grad transfer but most will want assurances of starting.
I'm outraged at how much tolerance and near-praise this shrimp Pyne is getting.
You only have to look at his height to realize that he stinks. Clear from the beginning.
Bench him. Fire Rees.
... should have won by 50.
... life sucks.
I agree. I just think it’s gonna be difficult to find a starter quality QB that doesn’t want the job basically handed to him.Then find someone who's willing to come in and compete for the job.
With a few exceptions - like some multi-year P5 starter with legit NFL prospects who's just stuck on a lousy team - grad transfer QBs usually aren't THAT good. There's a reason they're transferring. Don't just hand them the job, especially when we have two start-able QBs already in the room.
We need a transfer but we also need to have a wide open three-way competition in the spring.
CJ Carr should be our backup when he enrolls.Isn't this the most ND story line though? We've watched the season's starter get hurt or get benched, only for the backup come in and surprise the doubters, 4-6x in the last decade?
Crist/Rees
Golson/Rees
Golson/Zaire
Zaire/Kizer
Wimbush/Book
Buchner/Pyne
It's almost bizarre at this point.
Isn't this the most ND story line though? We've watched the season's starter get hurt or get benched, only for the backup come in and surprise the doubters, 4-6x in the last decade?
Crist/Rees
Golson/Rees
Golson/Zaire
Zaire/Kizer
Wimbush/Book
Buchner/Pyne
It's almost bizarre at this point.
You might be on to something here...and then send a patsy in as a starter and call QB Power runs every play until the inevitable. An acceptable sacrifice?CJ Carr should be our backup when he enrolls.

Sure, but, also starts with the line lolIt all starts with what you've got between the ears.
May need to exorcise the qb room. Maybe some bad juju in getting named the starter.Isn't this the most ND story line though? We've watched the season's starter get hurt or get benched, only for the backup come in and surprise the doubters, 4-6x in the last decade?
Crist/Rees
Golson/Rees
Golson/Zaire
Zaire/Kizer
Wimbush/Book
Buchner/Pyne
It's almost bizarre at this point.
just a reminder tho that we had a coach that could do this and deemed it not good enough.Tommy knows how to call this kind of offense. He wants an accurate QB that is going to convert the opportunities that are there. I keep thinking back to that walk in TD that Diggs had against UNC on the throw back and how easy/effortless that was... Buchner honestly might've thrown that ball 5 feet over his head, etc.
Pyne might not have the arm talent to beat a "Georgia" but he's more than good enough to beat 80%+ of CFB teams and he allows the players around him to make plays.
That can work this year, but to get past the BK ceiling, more will be needed. I am concerned though that Pyne is going to be QB for 2023 too. Not saying TB is the better option either. But ND should still be shopping transfer portal for QB talent.Tommy knows how to call this kind of offense. He wants an accurate QB that is going to convert the opportunities that are there. I keep thinking back to that walk in TD that Diggs had against UNC on the throw back and how easy/effortless that was... Buchner honestly might've thrown that ball 5 feet over his head, etc.
Pyne might not have the arm talent to beat a "Georgia" but he's more than good enough to beat 80%+ of CFB teams and he allows the players around him to make plays.