Bogs,
I can't see ND assisting him in filing a petition and the NCAA would never award a 6th year under these circumstances.
You can't use an academic issue as reason to petition. It has to be season ending injury (or non football related illness / injury from a car accident, etc.) Besides physical injury / illness, having to leave school to care for an ailing family member and or take care of siblings as the result of the death of a parent / guardian is grounds for petition.
I was awarded a 6th year based on knee injury and the deaths of my parents.
.
NDC, a chara,
First, my condolences, even at this late date.
Second, I was musing if with his first redshirt year being due to medical reasons if that was enough for the extension.
It makes perfect sense to me that if one year missed is due to loss of eligibility, the granting of a sixth year would be contrary to the original intent of withdrawing eligibility.
But after all, this is the NCAA, and I would put nothing irrational past them! Sorry, but yes, I am that jaded. Thanks for the verification!
Beir bua agus beannacht,
Bogs
PS. : About this pushing Bryant thing. I bet he has been "pushed" all his life and look how that has worked out. Above and beyond everything, I think this kid needs to sit down, and think some things through. Then he needs to make a couple (or more decisions.)
At this point I must say, that history and common sense are not in his favor; he has to be clear that his way isn't getting him what he really wants. He has to get off of his own ego train, and that is incredibly hard for anyone, let alone someone with these kind of maturity issues, (assuming that is all it is.) So the locus has to be from inside. The outside is only a minor influence, that looks like support for someone that wants to effect changes within themselves. My two cents.