Pre-Malik Zaire wasn't too impressive. Since then however has been pretty damn good, although not sure yet on Book but we shall see...
Well let's be fair...
Kelly's first class he was locked in on Bubba Starling, who would've been a star at QB, but went the baseball route and never played a minute of anything collegiate. He originally had a lot of reason to believe that he'd play football and sign with ND. He settled for Golson, who was very competent.
Golson was so competent that #1 QB and 2012 signee Gunner Kiel transferred immediately after seeing Golson take ND to a national championship game. Kiel has certainly not sucked at Cinci, but has had some problems.
Then it goes Zaire, Kizer, Wimbush. All three seem like great signees.
If every other position featured 3 out of 5 players being varying levels of elite, 1 player being very competent but with some limitations and off-the-field issues, and 1 player being good but transferring for PT.... well, let's just say we wouldn't have problems at safety LOL