Andy in Sactown
Can't wait 'til gameday.
- Messages
- 2,689
- Reaction score
- 327
Question... and i'm not trying to be a devil's advocate here... but why would you not count kids that go to lower schools? Talented kids go to small schools all of the time. Randy Moss, Deontay Greenberry, etc. Hell... there are tons of kids that end up on NFL rosters that don't even get rated coming out of high school like Ben Rothlisberger and Antonio Brown.
I guess I don't get why a 3 star going to Tulane or a 4 star going to Western Michigan should be taken out of the recruit pool. Especially when they were evaluated like the rest of them?
You do count every 5-star no matter where he goes. You just don't use top 1% of 3,000 as a basis for justifying a five star rating. The reality is that 5-stars tend to go to the best programs.
EDIT: They're not out of the recruit pool, it's that 1,000 or more (guestimate/example) 1 or 2 star and unranked guys highly dilute the 3,000. So the 1% is like, well, "lies, damn lies and statistics." Not how I judge 5-stars.
Last edited:
