Agreed, Rhode. I think there needs to be a hybrid system where a kid can sign with a youth program and get paid and still retain eligibility for college. I know NCAA hockey and baseball have sort of hybrid models, and then there is the outright Olympic model which allows athletes compensation.
I don't know enough about soccer to know what the current regulations are with professional affiliated youth programs (i.e. what Harrison Shipp came through with the Chicago Fire, much less a European affiliated program with the likes of EPL, Serie A, etc.
Hold on though, one thing I brought up in post #2280 is that the big issue IMO is that soccer ISN'T a scholarship sport in the traditional sense... it's an equivalency sport. So for a full team of soccer players there aren't enough scholarships to go around.
As such, middle and upper middle class kids are the ones excelling in tennis/soccer/lacrosse/golf/etc. because the superior athletes coming from poor backgrounds are basically forced to chase basketball/football for that full scholarship that will allow them to go to college.
If soccer started offering completely full rides AND worked out something allowed kids to sign with/get paid by professionally affiliated youth programs at a young age, you'd see a drastic increase in the amount of superior athletes who give soccer a longer look.