Kelly NFL Rumors

Status
Not open for further replies.

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
Your incorrect, over-use of the comma drives me nuts, lol.

Don't, over, comma, when, not, necessary.

You're............

Are you saying that the Gamecocks were not 25-22 in the 4 seasons before Spurrier got there?
 
C

Cackalacky

Guest
See Tony Rice and Everett Golson........

Huh? Tony rice was in the late 1980s and only made it in because of prop48. Jeff Burris is really the only guy I know that was a true ND man from SC. There was also Gary Gray. How that happened I have no idea. Chris Brown? Good kid from a rough/poor city. I have said this before but I wish we could get the kids from Orangeburg, Dorman, Northwestern, Byrnes, AC Flora, Myrtle Beach but it's just not gonna happen on a regular basis. If I had my druthers Dorman would be the pipeline to start but it is in the middle of Bob Jones country and these kids are not going to a private catholic school.

The Charleston/Summerville area is the most likely place to get ND kids because of the historical Catholic presence but they are 1-3A schools/ private schools with very weak competition and not so great academics.
 
Last edited:

Whiskeyjack

Mittens Margaritas Ante Porcos
Staff member
Messages
20,894
Reaction score
8,126
So the question is, what will be your stance if we get the traditional 9-4, or 8-5 season next year?

We're probably much closer on this than you'd think. For this season, all things considered, I'd be genuinely happy with 10-3. 9-4 would be OK, 8-5 a disappointment, and 7-6 an unmitigated disaster.

Next season, I'm not quite feeling "playoffs or bust", but anything less than a major bowl win would be disappointing. That would be a historic first for ND; winning a BCS-caliber bowl in the modern era.
 

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
Huh? Tony rice was in the late 1980s and only made it in because of prop48.

I included Rice because you mentioned that S. Carolina high school football had some good talent years in the 80s. I didn't see any mention of gpas. I was just making reference to your statement about kids from S. Cackalacky wanting to go to a Catholic school in the Midwest. Deveron Harper and Lance Legree are a couple of others, who came from S. Carolina and played at ND.
 
C

Cackalacky

Guest
I included Rice because you mentioned that S. Carolina high school football had some good talent years in the 80s. I didn't see any mention of gpas. I was just making reference to your statement about kids from S. Cackalacky wanting to go to a Catholic school in the Midwest. Deveron Harper and Lance Legree are a couple of others, who came from S. Carolina and played at ND.

Gotcha. I forgot about Lance Legree. Was he from Georgetown I think? Anyway you kinda support my point. Pretty slim as far as a state goes. Although they have have all been good to great for ND.

I have posted on this at depth but ND is just not going to get the non-catholic kids from rural SC and outside of Charleston and the metro Charlotte area. It is an academic and a religious issue at the core. And coming full circle Spurrier has been able to keep these kids in State. I think Carlos Dunlap and AJ Green are the last two big fish to leave the state.
 
Last edited:

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
Gotcha. I forgot about Lance Legree. Was he from Georgetown I think? Anyway you kinda support my point. Pretty slim as far as a state goes. Although they have have all been good to great for ND.

I have posted on this at depth but ND is just not going to get the non-catholic kids from rural SC and outside of Charleston and the metro Charlotte area. It is an academic and a religious issue at the core. And coming full circle Spurrier has been able to keep these kids in State. I think Carlos Dunlap and AJ Green are the last two big fish to leave the state.

Lamont Bryant was from Georgetown, and graduated the year before Legree. Legree was from St Stephen. Actually, wouldn't Golson be the last big fish to leave the state?
 
C

Cackalacky

Guest
Lamont Bryant was from Georgetown, and graduated the year before Legree. Legree was from St Stephen. Actually, wouldn't Golson be the last big fish to leave the state?

Not really. He was a low three star I believe and was committed to UNc. I dont even know how much the OBc was trying to get him. Plus they had Garcia, Shaw and then Thompson in the fold. Hell even Mason Rudolph, Worley, Jacob Park have all left but they were not on the level of Clowney, Lattimore, Aj Green or Dunlap.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Not really. He was a low three star I believe and was committed to UNc. I dont even know how much the OBc was trying to get him. Plus they had Garcia, Shaw and then Thompson in the fold. Hell even Mason Rudolph, Worley, Jacob Park have all left but they were not on the level of Clowney, Lattimore, Aj Green or Dunlap.

247 had Golson as a four-star, #7 ranked QB in the country. He also won the state high school championship.
Everett Golson

But maybe OBC knew Golson fumbles too much and can't throw over the middle? ;)
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,044
Reaction score
6,110
Lamont Bryant was from Georgetown, and graduated the year before Legree. Legree was from St Stephen. Actually, wouldn't Golson be the last big fish to leave the state?

Wasn't Gary Gray from South Carolina. I know Spurrier wanted him pretty bad. I believe he was a 5-star in some services but no worse than a 4-star.
 

irishog77

NOT SINBAD's NEPHEW
Messages
7,441
Reaction score
2,206
They were over .500, for the four year period before Spurrier took over. They weren't great, maybe not even really good, but they weren't anything near terrible, either.

The 3 years before Spurrier got there, they were 16-19, including 2 seasons out of 3 with losing records. I can also pick out a 3 year stretch in the 1920's when they were 10 games OVER .500.

None of this changes the fact that they have, in their history of football, been a dog program. Now, with Spurrier, they are anything but that. You choosing 4 specific years to attempt to demonstrate otherwise doesn't change any of that.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,995
The 3 years before Spurrier got there, they were 16-19, including 2 seasons out of 3 with losing records. I can also pick out a 3 year stretch in the 1920's when they were 10 games OVER .500.

None of this changes the fact that they have, in their history of football, been a dog program. Now, with Spurrier, they are anything but that. You choosing 4 specific years to attempt to demonstrate otherwise doesn't change any of that.

Exactly. South Carolina was as irrelevant as Vanderbilt or Kentucky pre-Spurrier. With Spurrier, they're a perennially ranked team with a number of marquee wins. Guy can coach his ass off.
 

ND NYC

New member
Messages
3,571
Reaction score
209
my fellow ND fans...one request:
can we please stop talking about steve f-ing spurrier---dude is probably the biggest ND hater there ever was, and in his smug, good ole boy way so proud of it to boot.

truly cant stand the man...and tbqh have been hoping to play him in a bowl this year ever since the debacle in the desert so we can once again wipe that smirk off his OBC face.

thank you for your consideration
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
my fellow ND fans...one request:
can we please stop talking about steve f-ing spurrier---dude is probably the biggest ND hater there ever was, and in his smug, good ole boy way so proud of it to boot.

Tis true there is no point in discussing Steve Spurrier in a thread about the future - real or imagined - of Brian Kelly at Notre Dame, as Spurrier is never coming to Notre Dame. But, if not him, what else would we talk about in a thread about the future of Brian Kelly at Notre Dame?
 

eNDzone

Irish to the bone!
Messages
831
Reaction score
53
We're probably much closer on this than you'd think. For this season, all things considered, I'd be genuinely happy with 10-3. 9-4 would be OK, 8-5 a disappointment, and 7-6 an unmitigated disaster.

Next season, I'm not quite feeling "playoffs or bust", but anything less than a major bowl win would be disappointing. That would be a historic first for ND; winning a BCS-caliber bowl in the modern era.

What are the bowl games called now? Do they even have a name?
 

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
The 3 years before Spurrier got there, they were 16-19, including 2 seasons out of 3 with losing records. I can also pick out a 3 year stretch in the 1920's when they were 10 games OVER .500.

None of this changes the fact that they have, in their history of football, been a dog program. Now, with Spurrier, they are anything but that. You choosing 4 specific years to attempt to demonstrate otherwise doesn't change any of that.

I didn't just randomly pick 4 years. I picked the 4 years just before Spurrier got there, to refute the idea that the Gamecock program was horrible. I was not trying to say that they were good, or strong, or anything else, other than Holtz had the turnaround started. Spurrier may have shepherded the steepest point of the curve, but he did not take over a program that was horrible. There was a foundation there for success.
 

NDohio

Well-known member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
3,060
Gotcha. I forgot about Lance Legree. Was he from Georgetown I think? Anyway you kinda support my point. Pretty slim as far as a state goes. Although they have have all been good to great for ND.

I have posted on this at depth but ND is just not going to get the non-catholic kids from rural SC and outside of Charleston and the metro Charlotte area. It is an academic and a religious issue at the core. And coming full circle Spurrier has been able to keep these kids in State. I think Carlos Dunlap and AJ Green are the last two big fish to leave the state.

What are your thoughts on the Greenville area? I would think the area would be more open to a Catholic education - with BMW located in Greenville, there seem to be a lot of non-natives there.. There is some pretty good football being played up there as well.
 

NCND

New member
Messages
1,416
Reaction score
44
What are the bowl games called now? Do they even have a name?

"New year's six "Are all tier one Major Bowls.. Rose and Sugar are the semi's this yr. Cotton, Peach, Orange, Fiesta are the others. All six games will be played on NYE / NYD.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,591
Reaction score
20,046
SC was terribad before he came. And on top, has one of the worst markets for high school football. Not as bad as Indiana and Illinois but definitely the worst in the SEC behind Kentucky.

Now dont get me wrong, Spurrier is a jackleg and my most disliked coach...even more than Les Miles. The guy doesnt know when to shut his mouth and his arrogance is just too much. Watching him lose is sickeningly enjoyable.

But keep in mind he took over from Lou Holtz who couldnt make it work at SC and I like to think that Lou was one of the best.

Not to side track the thread, but Indiana HS football has been rated some of the best in recent years. The MIC conference (Indy area) has been rated one of the top five conferences the last two years.

Back on track, I think Spurrier has done a very good job at South Carolina. It's not one of the elite programs in the country, yet he's found a way to be pretty competitive in the SEC. Does he have his moments? I say yes, but that's due to him not being loaded top to bottom like some of the elite programs.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,591
Reaction score
20,046
Huh? Tony rice was in the late 1980s and only made it in because of prop48. Jeff Burris is really the only guy I know that was a true ND man from SC. There was also Gary Gray. How that happened I have no idea. Chris Brown? Good kid from a rough/poor city. I have said this before but I wish we could get the kids from Orangeburg, Dorman, Northwestern, Byrnes, AC Flora, Myrtle Beach but it's just not gonna happen on a regular basis. If I had my druthers Dorman would be the pipeline to start but it is in the middle of Bob Jones country and these kids are not going to a private catholic school.

The Charleston/Summerville area is the most likely place to get ND kids because of the historical Catholic presence but they are 1-3A schools/ private schools with very weak competition and not so great academics.

All these years I thought he was from Muncie, Indiana. lol
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,591
Reaction score
20,046
"New year's six "Are all tier one Major Bowls.. Rose and Sugar are the semi's this yr. Cotton, Peach, Orange, Fiesta are the others. All six games will be played on NYE / NYD.

I remember when the Fiesta was a second tier bowl along with the Peach. Back then the Cotton was one of the four premier bowls (Rose, Orange, Cotton & Sugar). They lost some luster when they didn't keep pace financially with the others and the Fiesta found some money. Looks like the Peach and Cotton have found some financial backing to be included in that group.
 

NCND

New member
Messages
1,416
Reaction score
44
I remember when the Fiesta was a second tier bowl along with the Peach. Back then the Cotton was one of the four premier bowls (Rose, Orange, Cotton & Sugar). They lost some luster when they didn't keep pace financially with the others and the Fiesta found some money. Looks like the Peach and Cotton have found some financial backing to be included in that group.

Cowboy Stadium and Tradition is what brought the Cotton Bowl back.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Cowboy Stadium and Tradition is what brought the Cotton Bowl back.

Jerry Jones needing wanting to monetize that monstrosity he built is what brought the Cotton Bowl back.
And the Peach is in Atlanta, right? At the Georgia Dome? That town loves it some college football.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top