Do you mean Abilene Christian? Or is Albany Christian a high school?
guys Alford landed totally sucked or didn't last at ND. Was passing on Elijah Holyfield in '16 dumb? Yeah, probably, but I also don't think for a second it was his call to do that. CJ Holmes was not chopped liver in '17. Not a ton of RB offers... he was the #19 composite RB and an early take, not a scramble. We predictably whiffed on the 5
types like we always will.Kind of sad/interesting considering we passed on Elijah Holyfield, Markese Stepp was given "no go" by ND... and a lot of those other guys listed had ND offers.
I didn't listen to podcast, so maybe I'm misinterpreting the point being made. But here's the part of the narrative that is sort of bogus... Autry Denson is not a "bad" recruiter, and he doesn't just recruit his position group. He absolutely killed it in Florida when he was first hired, and was lauded by many of the same "insiders" for his recruiting prowess.
Neither McIntosh or Jones were highly rated, but many of the highguys Alford landed totally sucked or didn't last at ND. Was passing on Elijah Holyfield in '16 dumb? Yeah, probably, but I also don't think for a second it was his call to do that. CJ Holmes was not chopped liver in '17. Not a ton of RB offers... he was the #19 composite RB and an early take, not a scramble. We predictably whiffed on the 5
types like we always will.
The only "bad" class was last year. That was unacceptable RB recruiting for how good our running game was. It starts with taking Stepp and then not letting him through admissions... is that's Denson's fault? A little, because it was known from the beginning that his academics weren't great. Again, very few offers were put out at the position... so it's not like there were big whiffs on guys we *should* get. Then fast forward to this year, and this "Denson is a bad recruiter" narrative is coming from the fact that we're apparently getting beat head-to-head for guys we really want.
But at the end of the day, you can't say "Denson is a bad recruiter" unless you intentionally ignore the overall results in Florida. It's lazy analysis by II. And a RB coach should always be evaluated on production... well, two out of three years he's gotten elite production out of players and can clearly coach the position.
And holding him responsible for "his guys" getting into trouble is truly one of the dumbest hot takes I've ever heard.
Goddamn that list pisses me off, actually.
I know we all have high hopes for guys like Tony Jones Jr and Jahmir Smith as guys that were undervalued and can come to ND and outplay their rankings... but with the track-record of success with our OL over the past four years, both on the field and in the draft, there's no reason that we shouldn't be landing a sure-fire difference maker in each class at RB.
It doesn't all fall on Denson, like LAX said. But it's alarming that the staff, as a whole, can't convince a true blue-chip runner to come play behind all the studs that have been recruited for the OL.
Goddamn that list pisses me off, actually.
I know we all have high hopes for guys like Tony Jones Jr and Jahmir Smith as guys that were undervalued and can come to ND and outplay their rankings... but with the track-record of success with our OL over the past four years, both on the field and in the draft, there's no reason that we shouldn't be landing a sure-fire difference maker in each class at RB.
It doesn't all fall on Denson, like LAX said. But it's alarming that the staff, as a whole, can't convince a true blue-chip runner to come play behind all the studs that have been recruited for the OL.
Kind of sad/interesting considering we passed on Elijah Holyfield, Markese Stepp was given "no go" by ND... and a lot of those other guys listed had ND offers.
I didn't listen to podcast, so maybe I'm misinterpreting the point being made. But here's the part of the narrative that is sort of bogus... Autry Denson is not a "bad" recruiter, and he doesn't just recruit his position group. He absolutely killed it in Florida when he was first hired, and was lauded by many of the same "insiders" for his recruiting prowess.
Neither McIntosh or Jones were highly rated, but many of the highguys Alford landed totally sucked or didn't last at ND. Was passing on Elijah Holyfield in '16 dumb? Yeah, probably, but I also don't think for a second it was his call to do that. CJ Holmes was not chopped liver in '17. Not a ton of RB offers... he was the #19 composite RB and an early take, not a scramble. We predictably whiffed on the 5
types like we always will.
The only "bad" class was last year. That was unacceptable RB recruiting for how good our running game was. It starts with taking Stepp and then not letting him through admissions... is that's Denson's fault? A little, because it was known from the beginning that his academics weren't great. Again, very few offers were put out at the position... so it's not like there were big whiffs on guys we *should* get. Then fast forward to this year, and this "Denson is a bad recruiter" narrative is coming from the fact that we're apparently getting beat head-to-head for guys we really want.
But at the end of the day, you can't say "Denson is a bad recruiter" unless you intentionally ignore the overall results in Florida. It's lazy analysis by II. And a RB coach should always be evaluated on production... well, two out of three years he's gotten elite production out of players and can clearly coach the position.
And holding him responsible for "his guys" getting into trouble is truly one of the dumbest hot takes I've ever heard.
While, I'm not surprised by the orders, they mentioned that Denson has quite simply struggled and can't have half of his position group getting into trouble (add Dexter Williams with potential suspension). Here's a look at his recruiting since he's arrived on campus.
.8926 3* Tony Jones Jr.
.8524 3* Deon McIntosh - Dismissed
.9079 4* CJ Holmes - Dismissed
.8721 3* Jahmir Smith
.8456 3* C'Bo Flemister
So I ask once again...........why is Chip Long Elite?
All great points there. I think without Denson, ND isn't getting Kevin Austin to come to South Bend. I think he is a good recruiter, but not an amazing one that we saw with Tony Alford. And while I agree with you that guys getting in trouble is not all his fault, I do think there is some fault that falls on his shoulders because he stands up on that podium year after year on signing day and mentions they are looking for a great specific fit for ND at RB and how he's looking for Notre Dame men, but then has several RB's getting in trouble while on campus. Bottom line, I don't think the getting in trouble narrative is way too important because Tony Alford had problems with ND RB's getting into trouble, but what is the problem is the lack of talent influx into the position.
And holding him responsible for "his guys" getting into trouble is truly one of the dumbest hot takes I've ever heard.
N'Keal Harry - Arizona State stud WR, kept Cole Kmet in the class after his recruiter left, Braden Lenzy, helped with Drew Pyne, George Takacs, helped with Lawrence Keys III, Kalen Ballage - Arizona State RB just got drafted, Tommy Tremble, and helped with Andrew Kristofic. That's not a bad resume. I'm just reporting what I heard the II Podcast giving him in terms of the Elite grade as a recruiter.
Why is that?
I certainly wouldn’t put it all on Denson. There’s a lot of factors, chiefly the actions of the players themselves.
But you don’t think a position coach has any responsibility for the culture of his position group and keeping his players eligible to play? Even if all you hold a coach responsible for is production, we’ve potentially lost three out of four returning running backs to disciplinary issues. That will make it harder to produce, and has to fall at least somewhat on the position coach.
Yes, fvck Denson. How can he let his players get suspended? How is it not his fault? Why didn't he administer a psychological battery on his recruits to better predict those who were likely to make a bad decision? He could've then followed them around between classes and at night to make sure no bad shit was going on.
ALL HIS FAULT!
Why is that?
I certainly wouldn’t put it all on Denson. There’s a lot of factors, chiefly the actions of the players themselves.
But you don’t think a position coach has any responsibility for the culture of his position group and keeping his players eligible to play? Even if all you hold a coach responsible for is production, we’ve potentially lost three out of four returning running backs to disciplinary issues. That will make it harder to produce, and has to fall at least somewhat on the position coach.
“Culture of his position group”... is actually great, as it pertains to football. Most coaches in his shoes would not get the production out of the RBs he has while also keeping the “depth” pieces engaged and not transferring. It is borderline shocking that he has kept Dexter Williams on the roster and bought in.
He can’t be held accountable for players smoking weed, shop lifting, or getting a hooker at a bowl game. That’s their choices. The only thing you can hold him responsible for is recruiting these players in the first place.
Maaaan how did I forget this lmao
Maaaan how did I miss that?
Seriously, have we fallen so far that we once were dating porn stars, now we're paying for hookers?
Now that I'm thinking back on it, I thought we had already discussed it on here but maybe that was just in mod forum. Deon McIntosh had a lot of small transgressions and the last straw was at the bowl game (allegedly) getting caught with a hooker.
is that mod forum where the truth about what Davonte did is stored also?
It's the mod forum where all of Koon's aliases are listed
is that mod forum where the truth about what Davonte did is stored also?