Did I say 10 on the dot or did I say close to it? Again, there are other variables to consider (oline, talent around them, injury history), but if they're going after a kid that averaged 5/6 yes a pop like Anderson did, there is a problem that doesn't take a genius rb coach to see.
To your Jadarian Price example, he was anointed as elite based on dmc's comments. The guy has had two big plays in his career from my perspective (usc kr td and the td run against a&m). He also has danced waaay too much this season and has been part of the problem this years offense has been wildly inconsistent. Those negative plays destroy drives as this current iteration isn't talented enough up front/ at qb to make up for it. And that fumble against Ville nearly cost the Irish the game.