INDIANAPOLIS — Watching the way Pete Werner effortlessly completes a Mickey Marotti-prescribed workout, it’s not hard to see what Ohio State likes about the 4-star linebacker.
A top-300 prospect, Werner hails from one of Indiana’s top high school programs, Indianapolis Cathedral, and possesses the athleticism and versatility that could allow him to play multiple positions at the next level.
In high school, the quarterback-turned cornerback-turned safety-turned linebacker with an NFL pedigree spends his springs as a part of Cathedral’s 4×400 track relay team, which recently qualified for a state championship appearance.
It’s not yet clear which position the 6-foot-3, 220-pound signee will be best suited for in his career with the Buckeyes, but it’s apparent the pieces are there. And whether it be Darron Lee or Sam Hubbard, Urban Meyer has had a habit of molding players who possess such promise.
“Right now I’m pretty locked into linebacker,” Werner told Land of 10 during a recent visit to Cathedral. “But I’m willing to play whatever’s best for the team.”
Werner’s recruitment, however, wasn’t as simple as Ohio State identifying him as a perfect fit for its program. The Buckeyes had plenty to prove in their pursuit of Indiana’s second-ranked player — and it wasn’t with the pitch they’ve become accustomed to selling on the recruiting trail.
All A’s
The standard that Greg and Nancy Werner set for Pete, his older sister Ellen, older brother Dan and younger brother Tom wasn’t one that needed to be directed, so much as it was inherently implied: The four Werner kids would receive all A’s on their report cards, no exceptions.
“Academics were always very important to me,” says Greg. “That was always instilled in our children. I don’t know that we had a lot to say about it. They just knew that was the way it was.”
Whether it was in card games or while playing in the backyard, the four Werner children were competitive, but close. Academics, however, always came first, which manifested itself in Ellen recently graduating from DePauw and Dan receiving a football scholarship to attend Harvard.
For Greg, an inductee into the DePauw Athletics Hall of Fame who spent the 1989 NFL season as a tight end with the New York Jets, athletics served as a means for his kids to attend the best colleges they possibly could.
“That’s what we did with my oldest son,” says Greg, who now runs his own orthodontics practice. “He was a very good student, but probably not good enough to get into Harvard just on his own merits because it’s essentially impossible to get in there. We started to do that with Pete, too, but then the doors started opening up. Essentially when it was all said and done, he could have gone to any school he wanted to.”
Greg had long known that his middle son was especially gifted athletically.
When he had coached Pete’s youth football team, he once witnessed his third-grade son punctuate a long touchdown run with a front flip. On the defensive side of the ball, he routinely made other kids cry with his hard hits, only to help pick them up afterward.
“At a young age, he was the best player at every position on the field,” Greg says.
That wouldn’t change as Pete got older.
Original plans
After two successful seasons on the varsity team at Indiana’s Mount Vernon High School, Werner transferred to Cathedral, but a broken ankle prevented him from practicing much prior to the start of his junior season. After Werner missed the Irish’s season opener and saw only limited action against perennial power Cincinnati Moeller in Week 2, Cathedral head coach Rick Streiff converted his newest linebacker into a backside safety while preparing for Mishawaka High School and its option offense.
From there, it didn’t take long for Streiff to realize he had a special player on his hands.
“It was like, ‘OK, man, there’s a guy here,’ ” Streiff remembers thinking. “He basically played that spot the rest of the year. We put him on an island at times, he’d play some man coverage. In space, this kid was special.”
As Werner earned all-state honors, the offers began to pour in. From October 2015 to February 2016, he received more than 20 scholarship offers from Division I programs.
Despite the widespread attention, Werner limited his interest to a specific set of schools, prioritizing academics as much as athletics. In a February 2016 interview with the Indianapolis Star, he even indicated that he would commit to Stanford on the spot, should the Cardinal offer him a scholarship.
“That was back when I wasn’t very good at interviews,” he jokes now.
The offer from Stanford eventually came, but it was too late. On March 21 last year, Werner committed to Notre Dame.
With nearly 10 months to go until signing day, the 4-star prospect considered his recruitment over, even canceling a planned visit to one of the bigger schools to have offered him: Ohio State.
“My original plan was to never de-commit because I thought that was bad,” Werner says. “But I say some things I will not do and I wind up doing them.”
‘There’s a lot of life left after football’
Werner visited Notre Dame three times in the first seven weeks of the 2016 season, but it wasn’t the start of the Fighting Irish’s disappointing 4-8 campaign that soured him on a future in South Bend. Rather, he said, it was the negative energy that emanated from the program’s players during his visits that caused him to consider looking elsewhere.
“I was on a visit and stayed with the players and they didn’t have good things to say about the program,” he said. “I’m a freshman and they’re juniors and seniors. Going into a program, am I going to go there for four years and not like what I’m doing?”
All the while, Ohio State had not only stayed in touch with Werner, who played more of a linebacker role as a senior at Cathedral, but increased its efforts. Despite pleading from his mom and sister to stick to his commitment, Werner agreed to visit Columbus for the Buckeyes’ regular-season finale vs. Michigan.
“My mom hated the idea of de-committing,” Werner says. “She wasn’t even going to go on the (Ohio State) visit because she didn’t like it at all.”
Nancy, however, relented, and in the locker room after Ohio State’s double-overtime, College Football Playoff-clinching victory, the Werners were approached by an older man who complimented Pete on his Patagonia jacket, before joking that he had a version with a different logo on it.
Pete Werner on his visit at Ohio State with his brother Dan (Werner family photo).
“Who was that?” Werner asked his parents.
He was embarrassed to realize it was Phil Knight, the co-founder and chairman emeritus of Nike.
That moment, however, stuck with Werner as he weighed the academic merits of Ohio State. Ohio State is a good school, but it doesn’t possess the same academic reputation of a Notre Dame, Stanford, California-Berkley or Northwestern. And thanks largely to his father’s experience, Werner had more than a path to the NFL in mind when it came to choosing a school.
“I was fortunate enough to play in the NFL. But because of injury and circumstance, my career was cut short after only a season,” Greg Werner says. “There’s a lot of life left after football.”
But as Pete considered his desired major — commercial real estate — he became impressed by Ohio State’s Fisher College of Business, which U.S. News & World Report ranks as a top-20 undergraduate program. Factor in the culture Meyer has cultivated with programs such as Real Life Wednesdays and Werner was confident the Buckeyes indeed had the bigger picture in mind.
If they didn’t, Werner says he wouldn’t have committed to Ohio State, which he did on Dec. 11, 2016 — two weeks after de-committing from the Fighting Irish.
“If they did not do that academically, I wouldn’t have looked at it,” Werner said of OSU. “I’m not just going to commit to a school because they have a good football program. It’s more than that.”
When Werner officially faxed in his letter of intent on National Signing Day, it was to a school he may not have initially seriously considered, but one that wound up being a perfect fit.
For the Buckeyes, the feeling was mutual.
“He will flourish in their culture as I’ve seen it as an outsider looking in, and knowing what I know a little bit on the inside,” said Streiff, who also coached current Buckeyes receiver Terry McLaurin at Cathedral. “He thrives on the competition and he thrives on that mindset of, ‘Let’s roll our sleeves up and go to work.’ ”
Indianapolis Cathedral head coach Rick Streiff : “He has an elite mindset without the ‘5-star, look-at-me’ attitude. ‘What do you need me to do?’ He played on our special teams and our kickoff team all season long. He was by far our leading tackler on our kickoff team. Absolutely, by far. I could see him doing all that stuff (at Ohio State). He’ll do all the dirty work. ‘Just tell me what you need me to do.’
On what Ohio State saw in Werner: “The tenacity to play the game, his ability to run, his ability to fit into the culture and do the things to compete. Just all those things.”