I think we may be in a scenario where we're asking ourselves "What came first, the chicken or the egg?" Does the elite QB come before success, or must we have success before the elite QB comes? We've struck out on a program changing QB for awhile. We've had plenty of talent come in, but for whatever reason they either didn't pan out or the other pieces weren't in place at the time. Alabama and Ohio State figured out how to win the big games without the stud QB first, then they started bringing in the big talent which set them up for continued success.
Other programs have figured out how to win the big bowls without a program changing QB, I feel like we've got to quit fumbling on those stages so we can prove our worth. Expecting the very best QBs to come to South Bend without proof we can win the big bowls just seems folly. You're asking 16-18 year olds with real NFL aspirations and ability to take a chance at ruining their careers if things don't pan out here, when most are probably going to find an established QB breeder like Oklahoma, Alabama, Ohio State, etc.