Are you saying Loy feels that Bilals indecision between Michigan and Notre Dame centers on academic workload as well?
I wondered the same thing; inquiring minds want to know.
I think there is a situation of polar opposites in recruiting, if I have ever seen one.
After three years of observing a little about recruiting, and life, and how ND works, I have come to two indisputable conclusions : These kids are real human beings as flawed as all of the rest of us; and, things rarely appear to these seventeen, and eighteen year olds as clear as they do to us older guys.
And there is one more thing. Many of these kids don't have the same background as us. I know there are kids and families who show up as recruits for tours that have never traveled further than their teams farthest athletic contest. I have seen kids and talked to family at recruiting events from the south, that have had to borrow clothing warm enough to tour north of the Mason-Dixie line in October. And there are kids that are not only going to be the first family member to go to college, but even the first to complete high school.
Especially when it comes to the south, (SEC states), the education (public in particular) can be very suspect. Not talking about the Woodbury Academy, Eagle Christian, or St Thomas Aquinas's of the world. Talking about the down-home, back-woods public education. Some of these states hold so many top instate prospects, because they cannot qualify for out of state schools, with basic standards. For any UNC that gets called to carpet for exploiting illiterate kids, there is a primary and secondary school (or many) behind it.
Also, one out of twenty students qualifies for some kind of special help indicating a level of nuanced learning. I would like to see the actual ratio with gifted athletic boys. I bet it is higher. So, from culture, to educational experience, to family influence, to ability, there are many private considerations, hopes and fears among these kids that influence decisions in ways we cannot understand. And then there is money . . .