HH seems like a new man, so not sure if things have changed….
… but the old HH would start the Sophomore with the NFL-upside over the lower-ceiling upper-class man every time.
In fact, the main gripe with HH from his previous stint is that he seemed to focus on the latest stud he recruited and not really pay attention to or develop the backups. So basically, if you were a 4-5 star and recruited as an OT you were going to play (they may slide you in), if you were a 3-star or recruited as an OG you were not. (There we’re a couple exceptions.)
Now the reality is that the 4-5 star OTs are just better talent, so much of this is just life and sour grapes. If you are a good, but not great, P5 online recruit and want to play, ND is not the safe bet! However, HH sounded like a grumpy perfectionist, so it wouldn’t be shocking if he lacked some patience with the projects and less-talented kids.