Everything Soccer

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
17,185
Reaction score
17,140
Disappointed but unsurprised. Hopefully the sport continues to grow. Our relative population and immigration numbers should continue to help in our lifetimes.
 

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,896
Reaction score
18,285
Garbage effort all around. Tillman, Balogun, Adams, and maybe Robinson I can say played to standard.

I get why Ream is getting crap for his play but simply put he is a product of a crappy system. The US shouldn’t be relying on a 40 year old MLS player who is a step too slow these days. I can’t fault him because it’s not from lack of effort, his days are past. But Richards? What the hell was that? I thought he was gonna be the real difference maker tonight.

Overall the moment was simply too big. This is the first time the US has ever had to deal with expectations and they clearly had no clue how to handle it.

And credit to Belgium. They took advantage of the US’s mistakes which were largely either self inflicted or a product of Tielmanns having a massive game.
 

IrishInOntario

Well-known member
Messages
1,103
Reaction score
1,799
No offense, but it may be growth for Canada, but it is not growth for us or Mexico. In fact, R16 exits are just standard fare for both of us. Mexico has never gotten beyond it and we've only done it once. Losing is one thing, but getting run off the field by Belgium is a huge setback. This is the worst loss for the US in a long, long time considering the relative expectations coming in and the fact we're at fucking home. Mexico at least put up a fight against a far superior opponent. Rolling over and dying to a mediocre UEFA team is the same old, same old. Maybe hold off on the Poch extension.

Although Mexico and USA have much better soccer history than Canada, I actually think that the continued growth of the sport in all three countries is crucial to upping our collective level of competitiveness against the Europeans. Players from three countries are critical to elevating the standard of MLS, both as an independent league and a feeder source for the big leagues in Europe. The more talent that we collectively produce in North America, the better the competition and, invevitably, the better the players.

So while I understand that both USA and Mexico have made it here before and it doesn't demonstrate growth at the micro level, at the macro level North America is producing better-and-better players every couple years and we're going to need to continue doing that if there is going to be any hope of catching the Euro / South American squads.
 
Last edited:

ACamp1900

Counting my ‘bet against ND’ winnings
Messages
49,207
Reaction score
11,569
Heavy touches on critical moments and upgrading the defense are the two glaring areas for improvement, and I thought that throughout the group stage, not just tonight
 

FOTY977

Well-known member
Messages
1,181
Reaction score
1,724
Although Mexico and USA have much better soccer history than Canada, I actually think that the continued growth of the sport in all three countries is crucial to upping our collective level of competitiveness against the Europeans. Players from three countries are critical to elevating the standard of MLS, both as an independent league and a feeder source for the big leagues in Europe. The more talent that we collectively produce in North America, the better the competition and, invevitably, the better the the player's we'll produce.

So while I understand that both USA and Mexico have made it here before and it does demonstrate growth at the micro level, at the macro level North America is producing better-and-better places every couple years and we're going to need to continue doing that if there is going to be any hope of catching the Euro / South American squads.
We also need to keep stopping pregnant women from boarding planes when their offspring may have athletic prominence
 

Sea Turtle

Slow and steady wins the race
Messages
5,696
Reaction score
3,513
6th
The most frustrating aspect of this is that Belgium is not the cream of the European crop. They will get their doors blown off by Spain probably like 4-0. This was the perfect R16 opponent and we fucking blew it.
It looked like Belgium was just that much better than us.

Our best athletes just don't play the game. Our second tier athletes don't even play it.

Soccer is literally the only thing the rest of the world has and it is treated like a religion. It's not even in our top 5 or 6 of sports.
 

TracyGraham

Well-known member
Messages
558
Reaction score
580
6th

It looked like Belgium was just that much better than us.

Our best athletes just don't play the game. Our second tier athletes don't even play it.

Soccer is literally the only thing the rest of the world has and it is treated like a religion. It's not even in our top 5 or 6 of sports.
Plus, at least where I grew up, the kids that played soccer didnt exactly have a killer mindset. No matter how talented or athletic our players are, they will continue to wilt under pressure. Iron sharpens iron and there wont be any iron sharpening when the game is played by kids that want to sit out the more physical sports.
 

MPClinton22

Well-known member
Messages
932
Reaction score
1,220
the math doesn’t add up when a country 1/25th can run roughshod over us though. I’d understand if we played a vastly superior team from a country of 60-70 mill à la England and France. But Belgium is a nation of 12 million people. I just can’t wrap my head around it.

And I understand other large nations aren’t any good at soccer either, but those are mainly nations without the resources the US has.
 

tirishman505

Well-known member
Messages
207
Reaction score
356
6th

It looked like Belgium was just that much better than us.

Our best athletes just don't play the game. Our second tier athletes don't even play it.

Soccer is literally the only thing the rest of the world has and it is treated like a religion. It's not even in our top 5 or 6 of sports.
I mean, neither is swimming but we dominate that sport internationally. With nearly a quarter of all youth sports participation in this country being soccer, it’s remarkable how little we’ve improved vs the rest of the world.
 

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
17,185
Reaction score
17,140
Idk I don’t think Belgium did much this game except play composed. The amount of awful touches and bad easy passes was absolutely insane for the US. Many not even under duress. I bet they get exposed by Spain.

Agree with this. I didn't watch that performance thinking Belgium was playing amazing. It felt like US was nervous/flat coming out and had regained some composure coming out of half, then our goalie lost his damn mind and the game was just away from us then.
 

Old Man Mike

Fast as Lightning!
Messages
9,238
Reaction score
6,955
It's not "math." It's when the kids begin acquiring their skills and how intensely the culture drives their desire from there.

A culture can produce elites in anything that it "facilitates" psychologically. My brother's two boys were national champion youth olympic weight-lifters. Not a coincidence that he was a national elite level coach who started them early. I'll bet Belgium et al start kids at least as early as we do and the culture makes them want to intensely put in the hours of foot skills years after years.
 

MPClinton22

Well-known member
Messages
932
Reaction score
1,220
It's not "math." It's when the kids begin acquiring their skills and how intensely the culture drives their desire from there.

A culture can produce elites in anything that it "facilitates" psychologically. My brother's two boys were national champion youth olympic weight-lifters. Not a coincidence that he was a national elite level coach who started them early. I'll bet Belgium et al start kids at least as early as we do and the culture makes them want to intensely put in the hours of foot skills years after years.
I get this for sure - I’m just saying the argument that the US has more prominent sports rings hollow for me. The US has the populace and the resources to be elite at all 4 major pro sports and soccer. They just choose not to, and blaming the presence of other sports is passing the buck. It’s a structural issue with how we train youth soccer, and has nothing to do with the prevalence of other sports in the country
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,528
Reaction score
10,495
6th

It looked like Belgium was just that much better than us.

Our best athletes just don't play the game. Our second tier athletes don't even play it.

Soccer is literally the only thing the rest of the world has and it is treated like a religion. It's not even in our top 5 or 6 of sports.
It's notable our two best players tonight, and perhaps this whole tournament - Balugan and Tillman - grew up in other countries. Not just as military brats but were raised there by parents from those countries and came up playing in their soccer programs. Dest, too. Probably a few other of our guys.

It is also notable that if those guys were good enough to play for their home countries’ national teams, they probably would. Instead they play for us.
 

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,896
Reaction score
18,285
I’m sure it varies region to region but nationwide soccer is at worst the 4th most popular sport now by pretty much every metric, whether it’s youth participation, professional attendance, tv ratings, etc. The infrastructure for the US to be good at soccer really wasn’t in place until Klinsmann overhauled the system 14 years ago, and Polish Irishman and Jigga have elaborated on their experiences with the problems that are still present. They’re getting there and the talent continues to get better and catch up, and the gap is closing but it’s still a gap.
 

Sea Turtle

Slow and steady wins the race
Messages
5,696
Reaction score
3,513
I mean, neither is swimming but we dominate that sport internationally. With nearly a quarter of all youth sports participation in this country being soccer, it’s remarkable how little we’ve improved vs the rest of the world.
True but swimming isn't really a professional sport. It's a true Olympic sport.

To be fair, it HAS surpassed tennis and boxing. These are two sports that the US used to dominate and is now largely ignored. But the big 4, golf and even auto racing are substantially bigger.

At least our hockey program seems to be among the best now. I'm sure everyone on this forum can agree that this is a great thing.
 

Sea Turtle

Slow and steady wins the race
Messages
5,696
Reaction score
3,513
I’m sure it varies region to region but nationwide soccer is at worst the 4th most popular sport now by pretty much every metric, whether it’s youth participation, professional attendance, tv ratings, etc. The infrastructure for the US to be good at soccer really wasn’t in place until Klinsmann overhauled the system 14 years ago, and Polish Irishman and Jigga have elaborated on their experiences with the problems that are still present. They’re getting there and the talent continues to get better and catch up, and the gap is closing but it’s still a gap.
Do you think it's bigger than lacrosse? Particularly on the east coast?
 

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,896
Reaction score
18,285
Do you think it's bigger than lacrosse? Particularly on the east coast?

100%. Just my opinion, but lax is confined to more affluent communities which is also where soccer tends to over index compared to football and basketball. No disrespect to the lax folk here as I’ve grown to really enjoy it
 
Last edited:

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
17,519
Reaction score
30,284
It looked like Belgium was just that much better than us.

Our best athletes just don't play the game. Our second tier athletes don't even play it.

Soccer is literally the only thing the rest of the world has and it is treated like a religion. It's not even in our top 5 or 6 of sports.

I don’t think realize how talented this team is compared to even a decade ago. 9 of those players start/play heavily on European clubs, some major European clubs. The exceptions, Ream and Freese. The US is filled with extremely talented players now, some by happy circumstance, and soccer is absolutely a Top 5 at worst sport in this country. In terms of participation it’s Top 3. It sounds bad, but they really at their core just had a bad day today. Lot of that mental. Belgium is probably the better team, but there aren’t 16 more talented countries in soccer in the world. The problem is there are probably 8 for sure. And that’s what they keep bumping against.
 
Last edited:
Top