Can you imagine thinking TB is good?

Redbar

Well-known member
Messages
3,531
Reaction score
806
I’m more of the mindset that Buchner is a nice backup/ 3rd qb but I don’t think he has the height or accuracy to make for an elite P5 qb. He’ll have time to grow though.
Which data point are you basing this off? The first game, which was his first start, against a playoff team that should/could have beaten Georgia? The second game where he was running for his life because the Oline, the offensive coordinator, and his receivers were all trying to figure it out. Or this game where despite a couple of errant throws he accounted for 45 points +500 yards and a win against a game opponent, after coming off surgery and not playing for three months.
Seriously, this is such a lazy fan take and it says so much more about the posters than TB12. Don’t let me stop you guys tho, post on!
 

NDLincPark

New member
Messages
27
Reaction score
-53
Thank God Hartman is here. Hopefully Buchner transfers to QB a SWAC team, or compete for a backup spot in the MAC.

Had TB been the 2023 QB, there would have been an exodus of transfers and Carr probably would have rescinded.

Going into 2024 it should be open competition between Carr and Minchey to run this team for 3+ years and get into CFP contention (Winning it, not getting there)
 

Veritate Duce Progredi

A man gotta have a code
Messages
9,358
Reaction score
5,352
Thank God Hartman is here. Hopefully Buchner transfers to QB a SWAC team, or compete for a backup spot in the MAC.

Had TB been the 2023 QB, there would have been an exodus of transfers and Carr probably would have rescinded.

Going into 2024 it should be open competition between Carr and Minchey to run this team for 3+ years and get into CFP contention (Winning it, not getting there)
I got somethin for ya NDLP

 

NDLincPark

New member
Messages
27
Reaction score
-53
Thank God Hartman is here. Hopefully Buchner transfers to QB a SWAC team, or compete for a backup spot in the MAC.

Had TB been the 2023 QB, there would have been an exodus of transfers and Carr probably would have rescinded.

Going into 2024 it should be open competition between Carr and Minchey to run this team for 3+ years and get into CFP contention (Winning it, not getting there)

12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years
It's hard to refute something as nonsensical as Carr bailing because Buchner (in your view) sucks. If anything Buchner sucking would put Carr on the field faster. And Buchner transferring now would just leave us thin (again) in the QB room next season, which we don't need to repeat.

I don't see anyone arguing Buchner is "a heck of a QB" right now or that Hartman isn't a clear upgrade for '23. But also there's no reason to run the guy off. He has barely played. We'll see what Buchner turns out to be, and we have more talented guys coming in behind him now. The QB pipeline feels in the best shape it has in a long time. Enjoy it?
 

irishnd31

Biggest Idiot On This Site
Messages
6,208
Reaction score
8,088
12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years
tenor.gif
 

ND03

Value of ND degree may vary
Messages
135
Reaction score
130
12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years
Your post is just a bunch of ad hominem and aggressive opinions that are completely unsupported by anything other than your own delusions.

Enjoy your troll feed.
 

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,637
Reaction score
17,563
12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years

No time to engage with cunts. I enjoy your posts though. Keep ‘em coming!
 

NDLincPark

New member
Messages
27
Reaction score
-53
Most of you must not have watched shot-put tyler push the ball around the last few years. He throws the ball like a girl, and that is a fact.

Colossal miss on the recruiting side. Again, hopefully he transfers to like Ball State and he can be a good back-up there.

Having him here is pointless. Hartman is 1, and Angeli can not possibly be worse than TB
 

CanadalovesND

Well-known member
Messages
6,525
Reaction score
5,946
Most of you must not have watched shot-put tyler push the ball around the last few years. He throws the ball like a girl, and that is a fact.

Colossal miss on the recruiting side. Again, hopefully he transfers to like Ball State and he can be a good back-up there.

Having him here is pointless. Hartman is 1, and Angeli can not possibly be worse than TB

We all know is motion is weird.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,271
Reaction score
2,495
If we talking Bourbon, Weller is a nice affordable one. Probably 40-50 dollar range for a good sipper.

Was only $25 a bottle when I first got into good whiskey about 20 years ago. Could always find it at Total Wine. It's literally young Pappy, so it was a great wheater to always have on hand.

Now the price has doubled and it's on allocation, so you can't find a bottle without getting on a list first.

you just aged yourself big dog. Got a million questions for you but I wont clutter up a thread for those.


I want in!

Weller OWA is my favorite bourbon. I absolutely love the Full Proof. But at $300 a bottle, I haven't bought my own yet.
 

Jiggafini19Deux

Minister of Delayed Gratification
Messages
13,485
Reaction score
14,227
12 ppl downvote my post - but no one can refute it. I guess being rational and pragmatic around here is frowned on. Let's just pretend that ND is a CFB powerhouse and TB is a heck of a QB, and they haven't mangled the position over the last 15 years
It would actually be encouraged, but since you're not being either of those things, you're going to get downvoted for acting like a slapdick.

So don't act like a slapdick.
 

ND03

Value of ND degree may vary
Messages
135
Reaction score
130
Most of you must not have watched shot-put tyler push the ball around the last few years. He throws the ball like a girl, and that is a fact.

Colossal miss on the recruiting side. Again, hopefully he transfers to like Ball State and he can be a good back-up there.

Having him here is pointless. Hartman is 1, and Angeli can not possibly be worse than TB

We get it, Drew. He stole your girl. Cry about it elsewhere.
 

NDLincPark

New member
Messages
27
Reaction score
-53
Drew Pyne was a hilarious QB. Only ND would offer him at like age 14, and then have him progressively get worse each HS season, one after the other.

This team would win 3 games with noodle arm TB at the helm.
 

clashmore_mike

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
9,724
Reaction score
2,401
Drew Pyne was a hilarious QB. Only ND would offer him at like age 14, and then have him progressively get worse each HS season, one after the other.

This team would win 3 games with noodle arm TB at the helm.

You've hit your allotment of noodle arm TB references, and since you bring nothing else to the board, I don't see any point in you having posting rights.
 
Top