‘23 TN QB Kenny Minchey (Notre Dame Signee)

[Jiggafini19Deux]

Promise him 2nd and less than 4 packages in the second and third quarter so he can never leave.

QB2 at ND is far greater than QB1 for Narduzzi. That's right. I said it.

 

[sfk324]

Promise him 2nd and less than 4 packages in the second and third quarter so he can never leave.

QB2 at ND is far greater than QB1 for Narduzzi. That's right. I said it.

I wonder if Phil J feels this way.

 

[317Irish]

I wonder if Phil J feels this way.

P Jurk was just grateful for every opportunity he had. Notre Dame man candidate?

 

[irishnd31]

Move him to WR…

 

[rikkitikki08]

That was maybe the greatest bump in the history of this site, perfect troll job

 

[Irishnuke]

 

[stlnd01]

That was maybe the greatest bump in the history of this site, perfect troll job

I was being sincere! You people need to grow a pair. But also someone should celebrate Kenny's perseverance in his own thread!

 

[Me2SouthBend]

That was maybe the greatest bump in the history of this site, perfect troll job

I don’t know, some Jabroni bumped Carrs’ thread yesterday. Trollolol

 

[Sea Turtle]

Love this guy. Even if he is the backup, I hope they create packages for him.

 

[Dale]

I was being sincere! You people need to grow a pair. But also someone should celebrate Kenny's perseverance in his own thread!

More so it does not seem we are out of the woods here completely yet

 

[stlnd01]

More so it does not seem we are out of the woods here completely yet

Sorry, I don't do the pay site rumor mills. Is Kenny transferring a real concern? That would be a mistake, for him.

 

[CoachB]

Has it been stated anywhere that Carr won the job?

 

[Dale]

Ok:

- Meeting with Minchey today (NIL, and role moving forward)

- ND is willing to bump his compensation fairly significantly.

- He would prefer to stay, but NIL needs to be in order, and he would like to discuss the concept of packages designed specifically for him, even if he never starts.

- If Minchey were to leave, ND has already looked at potential portal candidates, and back-channeled.

The above ^

Sorry, I don't do the pay site rumor mills. Is Kenny transferring a real concern? That would be a mistake, for him.

 

[jprue24]

What a fucking asshole. Asking for a pay raise when he hasn't done shit on the field...

 

[FDNYIrish1]

Raise his NIL. Agree to a goal line package. Wait till fall to tell him it’s at TE

 

[MacIrish75]

@stlnd01 to the fellas:

 

[TorontoGold]

What a fucking asshole. Asking for a pay raise when he hasn't done shit on the field...

Wow, NIL is supposed to be for McDonalds meals, and he has the audacity? I will absolutely stop following the sport, anyways back to a college football forum!

 

[FightingIrishLover7]

This bump reminds me of the bump the Titanic gave the iceberg

 

[NDPhilly]

Kenny is mobile but idk if he’s mobile enough to have a dedicated package.

 

[T-Boone]

I reckon if a dude sticks with his initial school right through he should get an extra year of eligibility so you'd get 5 years of elibility and 6 years to use them.

 

[IRISHbluehen]

I reckon if a dude sticks with his initial school right through he should get an extra year of eligibility so you'd get 5 years of elibility and 6 years to use them.

Ya know, a rule where transferring costs you a year of eligibility on the back end rather than having to sit out might be pretty interesting.

 

[NorthDakota]

I reckon if a dude sticks with his initial school right through he should get an extra year of eligibility so you'd get 5 years of elibility and 6 years to use them.

I want fewer super seniors and super duper seniors. I don't want to incentivize them to take up roster spots. I want them to get a job and become adults.

 

[Some Irish Bloke]

I wonder if Phil J feels this way.

Well he ended up like TE 9 at Pitt so he might not admit it, but we all know he agrees.

 

[Jiggafini19Deux]

If he's QB2, he should demand more NIL money. He's automatically the most popular player on the roster at that point.

 

[Rizzophil]

Anyone know how his apt with the staff went?

 

[stpeteirish]

I want fewer super seniors and super duper seniors. I don't want to incentivize them to take up roster spots. I want them to get a job and become adults.

Why? Unless you have a job where you are supposed to hire athletes who cares?

 

[NorthDakota]

Why? Unless you have a job where you are supposed to hire athletes who cares?

You don't think it's weird when guys are coming back for a sixth year?

 

[T-Boone]

You don't think it's weird when guys are coming back for a sixth year?

Except maybe what Pyne is doing I can’t think of any examples of when it being done makes me feel that way. Btelho, Crawford eg weee good.

 

[greyhammer90]

Why? Unless you have a job where you are supposed to hire athletes who cares?

It's the rub of semi-pro vs student athlete. College ball was supposed to be a means to get a degree for free in exchange for your work as an athlete. The goal for 99% of them was to get that degree and then move on with your life. Now the incentives are reversed where it's a genuine financial opportunity for many of them and everyone wants to stick around as long as they can. Most who stick around for longer are not pursuing an advanced degree, they are just treading water and making money. I don't begrudge any individual for wanting to make money, but there is a societal question of whether the system should be incentivizing people to tread water in college. But even if you think "the market sets a worker's value so they are simply staying where they have the most value" there's also the simple fact that for every super senior at Notre Dame, there's one less freshman coming in. So this isn't "Hooray, more people are making more money." It's a zero sum game.

 

[NorthDakota]

It's the rub of semi-pro vs student athlete. College ball was supposed to be a means to get a degree for free in exchange for your work as an athlete. The goal for 99% of them was to get that degree and then move on with your life. Now the incentives are reversed where it's a genuine financial opportunity for many of them and everyone wants to stick around as long as they can. Most who stick around for longer are not pursuing an advanced degree, they are just treading water and making money. I don't begrudge any individual for wanting to make money, but there is a societal question of whether the system should be incentivizing people to tread water in college. But even if you think "the market sets a worker's value so they are simply staying where they have the most value" there's also the simple fact that for every super senior at Notre Dame, there's one less freshman coming in. So this isn't "Hooray, more people are making more money." It's a zero sum game.

This sums up my thoughts well.