'10 OH QB Andrew Hendrix (Notre Dame Signee)

Irishnuke

CFB Message Board Guy
Messages
8,239
Reaction score
3,950
Some of you guys are banking on watching youtube senior clips of Golson and the idea of it. Hendrix played big time against Stanford and played stellar against Air Force. Some of you wanted him starting the bowl game and if he would of won that bowl game it wouldn't even be a disucssion who the starter is moving forward. Everything i am hearing is the staff loves Golson and 100 percent of the fan base wants him to be the starter. Give me Hendrix or Golson. this spring will tell us a lot.

This is how I feel. I think Hendrix should be the starter next season. Apparently I'm the only one. I can't understand how our fanbase is already writing him off as a potential starter.
 

ThePiombino

The OG "TP"
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
6,245
This is how I feel. I think Hendrix should be the starter next season. Apparently I'm the only one. I can't understand how our fanbase is already writing him off as a potential starter.

You're hardly the only one. At this point, I think most people would be happy with either Hendrix or Golson. I know I would be. Without Floyd and until another WR can step up and be the man, we're going to need a QB who can extend plays with his feet and make things happen on the fly. ND is blessed to have 3 such players on the current roster.

Personally, I think GK should red-shirt this year, which leaves us with EG and AH. I just don't see a place for Tommy in this year's offense, not without a safety net a la Michael Floyd. AH has the luxury of an extra year in the system and some, albeit limited, game experience. If that means he is the better QB for it, then so be it! He SHOULD, at this point, be the better QB. If he's not, that hopefully means that EG is going to be at least as good as advertised and not that AH isn't what we had hoped at this point.
 
K

koonja

Guest
Referring the the post a few pages back about how Hendrix had better have the playbook down by now... He had better have it down by now. It's his 3rd year and he's a pre-med student I believe. I sure hope he can mentally digest the Xs and Os.
 
Last edited:

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,995
I think the funniest hypothetical to play is what if Hendrix was an EE?

If he was an EE he probably would've played after Crist went down and not Tommy. He wouldn't have redshirted. He may have even gotten the outright starting nod this year. And we would've won more games. So then you'd be looking at 2 more years of Hendrix... maybe but probably wouldn't have signed Golson... and then you'd be looking at ~3 year starter Gunner Kiel after that. Simple, huh?

But no, alas, Tommy was the EE and Hendrix was the regular signee. And now we have a choice between inexperience + talent from three different guys or experience + less talent from one guy. Luck of the Irish.
 

PANDFAN

Look Down
Messages
16,770
Reaction score
2,278
Referring the the post a few pages back about how Hendrix had better have the playbook down by now... He had better have it down by now. It's his 3rd year and he's a pre-med student I believe. I sure hope he can mentally digest the Xs and Os.

it's not the playbook! it is the presnap reads which he needs to be able to change play based on coverage...very very hard for a qb especially one who was more of a runner in high school...and w/ him being a pre-med student, possibly he isn't able to get into the film room like others...don't know, just speculating
 

NDhoosier

Well-known member
Messages
2,706
Reaction score
346
You're hardly the only one. At this point, I think most people would be happy with either Hendrix or Golson. I know I would be. Without Floyd and until another WR can step up and be the man, we're going to need a QB who can extend plays with his feet and make things happen on the fly. ND is blessed to have 3 such players on the current roster.

I think this is the general feeling on the Notre Dame fanbase. Golson is simply the unknown, so fans are hoping he surprises everyone and becomes a Denard Robinson type of player. Hendrix is a solid player who never had the full playbook at his disposal. He played great against a great defense in Stanford in his first "true" outing (Air Force game put no pressure on him). When a rookie QB comes in and plays that well against a GREAT defense in Stanford, that has to mean something.

However, fans look at Golson as a possible surprise and after fans witnessed the INT Hendrix threw in the FSU game, again with a limited playbook and never getting a feeling for the offense in that game. I will be happy with either Golson or Hendrix and I believe most ND fans feel the same way. Having said that, I do think Golson has a high CEILING than Hendrix, but I think Hendrix is more of a "sure-thing" as far as QBs who can manage the game, not turnover Tommy, but not a game-changer either.
 

NDdomer2

Local Sports vBookie
Messages
17,050
Reaction score
3,875
By Denard Robinson do you mean the ability to change the game in one play and extend drives with his feet? Because, I certainly don't want a track athlete that throws ducks as our qb(although from Golson's highlights and limited Spring game I don't think this is the case). I'd rather have Tommy if that's going to be the case.
 

NDhoosier

Well-known member
Messages
2,706
Reaction score
346
By Denard Robinson do you mean the ability to change the game in one play and extend drives with his feet? Because, I certainly don't want a track athlete that throws ducks as our qb(although from Golson's highlights and limited Spring game I don't think this is the case). I'd rather have Tommy if that's going to be the case.

Yes, Denard Robinson is simply a game-changer (when he leaves, people will see where Michigan truly stands in college football), but he cant pass very well. If Golson is comparable in speed and athletic ability, I would take him with the better arm over Robinson any day. However, even as ND fans, we cannot argue that Denard is a game-changing type of player... *going to wash my mouth out with soap*
 
M

Me2SouthBend

Guest
Good article from One Foot Down about Andrew "Voodoo Child" Hendrix as the starter for the upcoming year (his hope). Watching the video, I am reminded of just how much of a cow pasture that Stanford Stadium field was. Disgraceful.

"The Voodoo Child has also been extremely effective running the speed option, making all the correct reads and gaining huge chunks of yardage. In the three times Hendrix ran the speed option against Stanford, the Irish gained 37 yards (Credit goes to one of Burger's reviews for that one). And if Hendrix can increase his mobility and vision in the pocket, there's no reason to suspect that he cannot be a superstar for our beloved Irish."



Andrew Hendrix Should Start in 2012 - One Foot Down
 

eNDzone

Irish to the bone!
Messages
831
Reaction score
53
I still think Hendrix is the man. He had much better control of playing calling and running the O than an of the other QBs in the spring game. Still has the quick release and cannon he always had.
 

NDPhilly

Philly Torqued
Messages
16,444
Reaction score
16,737
Meh. He really needs to put more touch on the ball. He seems to not see linebackers to.
 

SoIll

Licensed to Ill
Messages
2,832
Reaction score
2,925
i think they both have the capabilities to lead this football team..In that video, he made alot of plays, and would have made at least 4-5 more first downs if Nike would be the NDs equipment sponsor. haha. They slipped so many damn times...
 

NDinFL

New member
Messages
2,946
Reaction score
278
This is how I feel. I think Hendrix should be the starter next season. Apparently I'm the only one. I can't understand how our fanbase is already writing him off as a potential starter.

You are not the only one my friend.

I've been on the Hendrix wagon for quite some time
 

arrowryan

Well-known member
Messages
14,719
Reaction score
8,920

95NDAlumNM

Banned
Messages
514
Reaction score
45
My only problem with Hendrix is that he thinks too much. He needs to relax and play instead of over thinking every situation. Golson on the other seems to just play and needs to think about what his responsibilities are a bit more. If you could take the best of both you would have an ideal QB.
 

frankygoes69

New member
Messages
658
Reaction score
22
Given the fact that Hendrix has not played that much, I think that he can be a baller given the opportunity. I'm with you in regards to EG but think that AH should get his snaps to prove himself as a full timer.

Oh and how was Spanish Market, Tomasitas, Atriscos, and Blue Corn? Take care and go Irish!
 

NDinFL

New member
Messages
2,946
Reaction score
278
My only problem with Hendrix is that he thinks too much. He needs to relax and play instead of over thinking every situation. Golson on the other seems to just play and needs to think about what his responsibilities are a bit more. If you could take the best of both you would have an ideal QB.

*insert wooly with the Gunner comments*
 

woolybug25

#1 Vineyard Vines Fan
Messages
17,677
Reaction score
3,018
You could say Hendrix is similar to Dan Lefevour to.

I have seen Lefevour play in person more than once, and I assure you that they are much different players. Lefevour threw much nicer balls and always was composed.



*insert wooly with the Gunner comments*

I don't think it would happen, but as I said before, I would be totally cool with us rolling with Gunner from the gates. The dude can ball.

My personal opinion is this, haters can hate...

1) Golson
2) Gunner
3) Hendrix
4) Rees
 
H

HereComeTheIrish

Guest
I have seen Lefevour play in person more than once, and I assure you that they are much different players. Lefevour threw much nicer balls and always was composed.





I don't think it would happen, but as I said before, I would be totally cool with us rolling with Gunner from the gates. The dude can ball.

My personal opinion is this, haters can hate...

1) Golson
2) Gunner
3) Hendrix
4) Rees

That's how I see it as well.
 

NDinFL

New member
Messages
2,946
Reaction score
278
I have seen Lefevour play in person more than once, and I assure you that they are much different players. Lefevour threw much nicer balls and always was composed.





I don't think it would happen, but as I said before, I would be totally cool with us rolling with Gunner from the gates. The dude can ball.

My personal opinion is this, haters can hate...

1) Golson
2) Gunner
3) Hendrix
4) Rees

Talent wise, I would agree.

I was just bustin chops El duderino
 

frankygoes69

New member
Messages
658
Reaction score
22
The question is this, how much playing time did Lefevour have under his belt at the time you witnessed him play? Again, I'm for EG as the starting QB and I think that he would crush it, however, I also think that starting AH agains Navy would be an eye opener to the ND's opponantes. Look what he did to the AF.

I know that EG would dominate but a two set QB system with AH and EG, providing EG actual playing time would be the most beneficial to the offense. JMHO.

GO Irish!
 

woolybug25

#1 Vineyard Vines Fan
Messages
17,677
Reaction score
3,018
The question is this, how much playing time did Lefevour have under his belt at the time you witnessed him play? Again, I'm for EG as the starting QB and I think that he would crush it, however, I also think that starting AH agains Navy would be an eye opener to the ND's opponantes. Look what he did to the AF.

I know that EG would dominate but a two set QB system with AH and EG, providing EG actual playing time would be the most beneficial to the offense. JMHO.

GO Irish!

The first time I saw him play was in the Motor City Bowl. He was a redshirt freshman and he was the MVP of the game...
 

Irishbounty28

Beastmode
Messages
1,122
Reaction score
280
I could see both Golson and Hendrix turning out to be really great players with experience during game action. I believe that whoever starts needs a pretty long leash, which would be more than the first half of the Navy game. It is probably pretty hard to play the position feeling that you are one turnover away from being pulled for someone else. I believe this was part of Hendrix's problem last year, as he more than likely never felt like Coach Kelly was 100% in his corner.

I would take Florida State as an example. I believe in the first half, when he took the field for his first series, he drove down the field to get into scoring range. I believe there was a change of possession shortly thereafter, and then Rees took the field the next series. Hendrix seemed to have something going on his initial drive, and was subsequently yanked for Rees. I still feel that if patience was taken with Hendrix he would have had a decently successful game.

The point is that constantly interchanging quarterbacks can sometimes be a detriment to the team. In a situation such as this it shows a lack of confidence in the quarterback, and without belief from those in charge it would be hard to expect great results. Ultimately, whoever wins the job coming out of fall camp needs to have total support from the staff. Let them take their lumps, but give them time to learn.
 

BGIF

Varsity Club
Messages
43,946
Reaction score
2,922
Al Lesar never knows what the hell he is talking about

15 years or so ago Lesar wrote fluff pieces about ND football, Holtz, and Davie. He eventually got re-assigned (when Wieneke and company came on board?) to other less challenging topics. When he came back to the ND beat he definitely came with a urine and vinegar attitude. I suspect he listens to Finebaum now to get in the mood before typing his articles.
 
Top