IRISHDODGER
Blue Chip Recruit
- Messages
- 8,044
- Reaction score
- 6,110
Gotta wash the nachos off
ND's Talking Heads ... The good, bad & ugly
- Thread starter BobbyMac
- Start date
IRISHDODGER
Blue Chip Recruit
- Messages
- 8,044
- Reaction score
- 6,110
Does he ever leave Chicago? He claims to have sources but he’s got to have an inferiority complex when trying to bring credibility to The Independent when his co-host has access to a few practices & the pressers
irishnd31
Biggest Idiot On This Site
- Messages
- 6,208
- Reaction score
- 8,088
Some Irish Bloke
Five foot nothin', a hundred and nothin'
- Messages
- 6,346
- Reaction score
- 5,922
In picking CJ Carr, Marcus Freeman ended Notre Dame’s unexpected QB competition his way
The fact Carr winning the job registered as a surprise says something about both players who battled this month to be Notre Dame's next QB1.
www.nytimes.com
I do enjoy Pete's articles; I'm not a big pod guy and can't stand Fortuna so nothing to speak of there.
But this article also feels like "man, Freeman is really rolling the dice in picking Carr." like it wasn't a close competition.
I don't understand how they feel they can write that it became "Minchey's job to lose" (paraphrasing) with how little they saw in camp, unless they ran with the poor source of information and are still treating it like gospel. Saving face. I dunno, but it's pretty annoying.
He goes on to say that Freeman "deserves the benefit of the doubt" but there's definitely a ringing sense of "how the hell did this happen/we had it right" all over the beat.
FireJeffQuinn
Well-known member
- Messages
- 154
- Reaction score
- 265
I enjoy Pete's podcasts when he's on with O'Malley. Pete is more of a pessimist, and O'Malley is more of an optimist, but they both get along well, are similarly witty, and make good sparring partners for each other. Combining them on the II pod with Prister and Brice always makes for a great listen.In picking CJ Carr, Marcus Freeman ended Notre Dame’s unexpected QB competition his way
The fact Carr winning the job registered as a surprise says something about both players who battled this month to be Notre Dame's next QB1.
I do enjoy Pete's articles; I'm not a big pod guy and can't stand Fortuna so nothing to speak of there.
But this article also feels like "man, Freeman is really rolling the dice in picking Carr." like it wasn't a close competition.
I don't understand how they feel they can write that it became "Minchey's job to lose" (paraphrasing) with how little they saw in camp, unless they ran with the poor source of information and are still treating it like gospel. Saving face. I dunno, but it's pretty annoying.
He goes on to say that Freeman "deserves the benefit of the doubt" but there's definitely a ringing sense of "how the hell did this happen/we had it right" all over the beat.
Unfortunately, I can't say the same about Fortuna--especially in recent years.
zelezo vlk
Well-known member
- Messages
- 18,012
- Reaction score
- 5,053
Pete and Matt are too similar imo. When they bring on good guests, I think they do the best interviews of any of the major ND podcasts.
zelezo vlk
Well-known member
- Messages
- 18,012
- Reaction score
- 5,053
Stanford please hire Jason Garrett
Some of these reporters are insanely unprofessional. I liked Horka, but just listened to his drivel. He was saying that Minchey outplayed Carr so he was trying to imply there would be division in the locker room. We don't need that kind of garbage. There is no tangible evidence whatsoever that one QB outplayed the other. We don't know! Neither does he! To report like you know something and try to create discord among the team should have some of these people banned (If that is a thing, lol). We should be talking about how pumped we are for CJ and the Irish moving forward. Obviously you had one bad source. Deal with it. Don't try to create problems where there are none. It's cool to have a guess, but when your guess is wrong, don't pretend like you are right and the coaches are wrong. The arrogance that must entail is crazy!
dublinirish
Everestt Gholstonson
- Messages
- 27,326
- Reaction score
- 13,091
The consensus from most of the shitty beat guys now is that they feel like they got duped and their credibility is lost. they are probably waiting now for ND to lose so they can have their pissy revenge stories ready to go
FightingIrishLover7
All troll, no substance
- Messages
- 12,704
- Reaction score
- 7,516
who is saying that?
Huntr
24 Karat Shamrock
- Messages
- 7,503
- Reaction score
- 10,426
dublinirish
Everestt Gholstonson
- Messages
- 27,326
- Reaction score
- 13,091
Fortuna definitely. Listen to him on their latest pod
Dale
Well-known member
- Messages
- 16,115
- Reaction score
- 27,371
Did not get that vibe at all. The complete opposite
FightingIrishLover7
All troll, no substance
- Messages
- 12,704
- Reaction score
- 7,516
Yeah, I listened - and I didn't get that vibe at all. Fortuna was pretty genuine about the situation (albeit still complete uniformed like normal).
pumpdog20
Well-known member
- Messages
- 4,743
- Reaction score
- 3,154
Fortuna and Sampson were adamant that they had multiple sources telling them it was Minchey. "It's not like everyone is trying to deceive us." Maybe that quote isn't exactly verbatim, but that was the gist of what they were saying yesterday.
Fbolt
I've been around
- Messages
- 6,932
- Reaction score
- 2,254
II stated that they were getting info from multiple sources, although all 2nd and 3rd hand. All told, the beat as a whole had credible sources with a combined (approximately) 50 sources. The speculation and general rationalization from II and BG has been absurd.
Prister stating he left and others Freeman's presser with certainty (not exactly what he said) that Minchey was the starter. I mean, where did that even come froom? There was zero indicator other than the group think from their peers.
Brice stating players on the D were shocked and had told family that Minchey was the starter.
Incredible their complete lack of self awareness. Figure out how you got it wrong and seek a path forward to be better. Nope, coaches are banking on Carr's flashes is actually what they are saying. Wow.
Waiting for Freeman to stop his next presser and gnaw on these reporters.
It will be interesting to see what happens.
Have not heard any absurd comments from IB. People hate (like, a lot of hate) but he owned it and moved on.
Prister stating he left and others Freeman's presser with certainty (not exactly what he said) that Minchey was the starter. I mean, where did that even come froom? There was zero indicator other than the group think from their peers.
Brice stating players on the D were shocked and had told family that Minchey was the starter.
Incredible their complete lack of self awareness. Figure out how you got it wrong and seek a path forward to be better. Nope, coaches are banking on Carr's flashes is actually what they are saying. Wow.
Waiting for Freeman to stop his next presser and gnaw on these reporters.
It will be interesting to see what happens.
Have not heard any absurd comments from IB. People hate (like, a lot of hate) but he owned it and moved on.
100%
NDVirginia19
Rally
- Messages
- 4,444
- Reaction score
- 5,151
They’re all pissed because they spent the last week writing their “Kenny Minchey wins the job” articles that they just wasted their time. The group think is real, like nobody outside of that tight circle was really surprised by this,
IAIrish
The Dude Abides
- Messages
- 1,663
- Reaction score
- 2,067
This is where you see true journalists like Eric Hansen shine. I didn't have a rivals sub or an On3 one now, but he was one who stuck to his pick that Carr was going to be QB1, even after the Nakos report. And I'd be very surprised to see him report something not well sourced or create a false narrative.
You see it reflected in the way these coaches interact with him as well.
Veritate Duce Progredi
A man gotta have a code
- Messages
- 9,358
- Reaction score
- 5,352
I'm going to be the outlier here. I don't like the signaling going on. I think it's really bad to intimate there might be problems in the locker room, plantings seeds of doubt about erosion of the cultural fabric Freeman has worked so hard to create.
Having said that, this feels a bit like the 2016 election. Everyone based on the most recent data/signaling thought it was Kenny Minchey. They weren't ruling out Carr but he wasn't ever being described as winning over the last week. I think everyone was simply being fed incomplete information that skewed their thinking.
Carr is the QB and I hope he gives the reporters a lot of reasons to write glowing things about him.
Having said that, this feels a bit like the 2016 election. Everyone based on the most recent data/signaling thought it was Kenny Minchey. They weren't ruling out Carr but he wasn't ever being described as winning over the last week. I think everyone was simply being fed incomplete information that skewed their thinking.
Carr is the QB and I hope he gives the reporters a lot of reasons to write glowing things about him.
dublinirish
Everestt Gholstonson
- Messages
- 27,326
- Reaction score
- 13,091
Plus they all ended up looking like clueless idiots and their credibility took a hit. Them being scooped by folks on IE is a bad bad look for them all
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
NDVirginia19
Rally
- Messages
- 4,444
- Reaction score
- 5,151
Do the actual beat writers ever comment directly or dismiss reports here?
TorontoGold
Mr. Dumb Moron
- Messages
- 7,367
- Reaction score
- 5,716
I think it was in 2023? I saw Driskell commenting about IE and he encouraged his cult members to bring the names of people who shared his precious intel on here.
ColinKSU
Well-known member
- Messages
- 4,647
- Reaction score
- 6,163
He’s banned paid customers from the site over that. Deeply weird behavior.
- Messages
- 19,128
- Reaction score
- 11,077
