'25 FL RB Justin Thurman (Kansas Verbal)

J

JamIrish

Well-known member
Messages
534
Reaction score
804
This.... all this! Deland McCullough is a star and 2025 is off to a great start. Thurman is going to be a big riser in the rankings
 
Irish4life

Irish4life

Well-known member
Messages
2,887
Reaction score
3,674
Says a lot about RB recruiting that a 4 star RB with good track times feels like a gimme.
 
Luckylucci

Luckylucci

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
27,769
Reaction score
10,145
Awesome, I love adding that type of speed to the offense and team in general. Seems like a great fit also.
 
Luckylucci

Luckylucci

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
27,769
Reaction score
10,145
And, I realize this is part of the Freeman hype era but nobody finds it odd that we're placing so much significance on these recruiting wins?

From purely a recruiting win perspective I do find it odd that this comes off as such a "huge" win. He's rated by 247 as a 90, the composite a 90.3, and ranked #279 in the country. For perspective, the top 3 backs in Taylor's last 3 classes were all rated/ranked higher. These are good wins, no doubt. But this isn't some type of elite recruiting we didn't have before. In fact, the last 3 RB's McCullough has received commitments from, are all ranked lower than the last 3 Taylor had.
 
IRISHMAN

IRISHMAN

Well-known member
Messages
1,245
Reaction score
175
good pickup for ND, now all ND has to do is try to hold onto him for 1.5 years.
 
N

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,633
Reaction score
17,557
Luckylucci said:
And, I realize this is part of the Freeman hype era but nobody finds it odd that we're placing so much significance on these recruiting wins?

From purely a recruiting win perspective I do find it odd that this comes off as such a "huge" win. He's rated by 247 as a 90, the composite a 90.3, and ranked #279 in the country. For perspective, the top 3 backs in Taylor's last 3 classes were all rated/ranked higher. These are good wins, no doubt. But this isn't some type of elite recruiting we didn't have before. In fact, the last 3 RB's McCullough has received commitments from, are all ranked lower than the last 3 Taylor had.
Click to expand...

I see your point, but I don't think it needs to be a Taylor verses McCullough debate or that McCullough is getting too much hype. Both are excellent coaches. It has more to do with the fact that 2016-2019 was some of the worst RB recruiting we've seen. ND got incredibly lucky that Kyren Williams and to a lesser extent Tony Jones panned out or else they would have had a 4 year stretch of some awful RB recruiting with some cycles (I think 2017) not even taking one.
 
Last edited:
A

arrowryan

Well-known member
Messages
14,714
Reaction score
8,915
Luckylucci said:
And, I realize this is part of the Freeman hype era but nobody finds it odd that we're placing so much significance on these recruiting wins?

From purely a recruiting win perspective I do find it odd that this comes off as such a "huge" win. He's rated by 247 as a 90, the composite a 90.3, and ranked #279 in the country. For perspective, the top 3 backs in Taylor's last 3 classes were all rated/ranked higher. These are good wins, no doubt. But this isn't some type of elite recruiting we didn't have before. In fact, the last 3 RB's McCullough has received commitments from, are all ranked lower than the last 3 Taylor had.
Click to expand...

Because I watch his film and think to myself that there’s no way there are 20 running backs in the ‘25 class better than him. So, once again, 247 has a Notre Dame commit under ranked.

His explosiveness through the line and his size seem borderline elite, for someone who’s only going to be a junior in high school.
 
Crazy Balki

Crazy Balki

Site Assigned Optimist
Messages
7,868
Reaction score
4,477
Luckylucci said:
And, I realize this is part of the Freeman hype era but nobody finds it odd that we're placing so much significance on these recruiting wins?

From purely a recruiting win perspective I do find it odd that this comes off as such a "huge" win. He's rated by 247 as a 90, the composite a 90.3, and ranked #279 in the country. For perspective, the top 3 backs in Taylor's last 3 classes were all rated/ranked higher. These are good wins, no doubt. But this isn't some type of elite recruiting we didn't have before. In fact, the last 3 RB's McCullough has received commitments from, are all ranked lower than the last 3 Taylor had.
Click to expand...
Taylor's prospects were scouted and evaluated by Barton Simmons, who is competent and has some semblance of an understanding of how to scout, and can provide something resembling an unbiased perspective.

McCullough's prospects were scouted and evaluated by Andrew Ivins, who has about as much scouting experience as I have and has a 24/7 raging hate boner for ND.
 
J

JamIrish

Well-known member
Messages
534
Reaction score
804
Luckylucci said:
And, I realize this is part of the Freeman hype era but nobody finds it odd that we're placing so much significance on these recruiting wins?

From purely a recruiting win perspective I do find it odd that this comes off as such a "huge" win. He's rated by 247 as a 90, the composite a 90.3, and ranked #279 in the country. For perspective, the top 3 backs in Taylor's last 3 classes were all rated/ranked higher. These are good wins, no doubt. But this isn't some type of elite recruiting we didn't have before. In fact, the last 3 RB's McCullough has received commitments from, are all ranked lower than the last 3 Taylor had.
Click to expand...

The way I see it, there's a pretty good parallel between Taylor and McCullough as far as RB types and rankings.

Taylor-Tyree. McCullough- Thurman
Taylor- Estime. McCullough- Young
Taylor- Price. McCullough- Love
Taylor- Diggs. McCullough- Payne or Williams

Taylor- Tyree 96.8. McCullough- Love 96.34
Price 92.07. Young 92.83
Estime 91.48. Williams 91.2
Diggs 88.15. Payne 90.36
 
Luckylucci

Luckylucci

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
27,769
Reaction score
10,145
Finding talent and recruiting wins are two very different things. Both important to be a good recruiter but still very different. Kyren Williams and Tony Jones are good examples of that.

You all make high quality subjective statements. Which the same was said for them. His rating/ranking relative to others and his offer list are objective.

At this moment in time, it feels like we're searching for every reason to over inflate recruiting wins for subjective reasons. That's fine. I hate to be a debbie downer but honestly, it takes away from the truly huge recruiting wins when landing a solid 4 star back gets our RB coach a statue.
 
NDohio

NDohio

Well-known member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
3,060
Luckylucci said:
Finding talent and recruiting wins are two very different things. Both important to be a good recruiter but still very different. Kyren Williams and Tony Jones are good examples of that.

You all make high quality subjective statements. Which the same was said for them. His rating/ranking relative to others and his offer list are objective.

At this moment in time, it feels like we're searching for every reason to over inflate recruiting wins for subjective reasons. That's fine. I hate to be a debbie downer but honestly, it takes away from the truly huge recruiting wins when landing a solid 4 star back gets our RB coach a statue.
Click to expand...
This doesn't seem to be a new situation though. I think this board has always over-inflated recruiting wins. That's part of the charm of IE.
 
Luckylucci

Luckylucci

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
27,769
Reaction score
10,145
Love the fit. Love that they identified him early. Love his upside.

Considering his ranking and offer list, this doesn't move the needle as far as recruiting victories goes. That's all.
 
NDPhilly

NDPhilly

Philly Torqued
Messages
16,441
Reaction score
16,721
Any time we beat out SEC powers for a kid from the South is a recruiting win worth celebrating. Lucci is right tho, if the kid was from Illinois and had offers from Michigan, PSU, Wisconsin, Iowa, etc… he’d just be another low 4 star. Nothing wrong with that, they are always going to make up the bulk of a good class.
 
bobbyok1

bobbyok1

Dominates Wiffle Ball
Messages
1,447
Reaction score
1,287
So, watching his film he seems to have good "vision." Often finds the lanes and even the crevices. I will say I was not blown away by his ability to break tackles. Seemed slow in his transitions/cuts, in other words, he didn't seem "quick" in his moves. Also seemed to run pretty much straight up, with very little lowering of the shoulder.

Not sure I see this kid as elite, but am glad to have him on board nonetheless. Hopefully, I will eat my words years from now and he will be a stud RB for us.
 
Armyirish47

Armyirish47

Well-known member
Messages
1,437
Reaction score
1,082
I think he was saying it's odd that the difference between the #3 RB and the #21 RB is 1 ranking point.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top