In addition to your points, DN, ND rock has a good point as an extension of the conversation.
ND football has evolved tremendously, (I am not saying either for the good or the bad,) but the amount of usage of a tight end as a receiver has plummeted, and the importance of an inline blocker has increased, significantly.
In part it has been because of the tremendous improvement in the wide receiver corps. Remember the days when we had one, at most two decent wide receivers? Remember all the conversations as recently as two years ago, when most were in agreement that we didn't have a receiver that could take the top off a defense? And most importantly, remember the first four years of the Kelly era when we didn't have a quarterback who could get the ball down field for physical or mental reasons?
All that has alone decreased the role of ND's tight ends, above and beyond the fact that capabilities, and experience of the tight ends has dropped off. Especially experience. In high school none of the current tight ends had to block. Troy Niklas, who was converted to tight end, not a natural like Rudolph, and Eifert, made tremendous progress. Remember he left the Irish with an extra year, where he could have been deadly!
And the coaches and experts have lamented the fact that teams could watch substitutions to see if Luatua was in (run), or Jones was in, (pass.) The fact that Jones did anything last year was a testimony to the player development from Booker and the rest of the staff, as well as his skill. The kid was obviously not ready to play D1, he wasn't strong enough, and had no experience doing what an ND tight end needs to do, (beyond catching the ball.)
I think Jones is great, and we have two other really good tight ends that are going to blossom this year.
Yup. Great points. See below...
Booker has had arguably more talent to work with at his position than anyone else in the country the last 6 years, yet we're steadily declining in TE production.
I really don't agree with the assessment of talent. He had three studs (Koyack, Niklas, and Jones), and a bunch of guys with good overall star rankings, but mostly borderline 4 stars. Koyack was a disappointment, Niklas was very good, Jones was a freshman. Smyth has been hurt a lot.
But the position has actually been pretty thin and unstable as far as a good mix of healthy veterans and underclassmen for years now. This is the first year its really stabilized in a while.
Here's how it looked:
Great
2005: Fasano was very productive his senior year (47/576/2); Carlson was a good back-up but didn't do much (ND: 477 yards per game total offense)
2006: Carlson was very productive in 2006 (47/634/4); Freeman was the good back-up (9/98/2) (ND: 398 yards per game total offense)
Pretty good, but shakey
2007: Carlson slipped off for reasons beyond his control: i.e., we sucked (40/372/3); Yeatman and Ragone were promising back-ups, but did little (ND: 242 yards per game total offense)
2008: Rudolph had a good rookie year (29/340/2), Yeatman did very little (2/6/0), Ragone began getting hurt (ND: 355 yards per game total offense)
2009: Rudolph has another good year (34/364/3), Bobby Burger was the back-up because of injuries and transfers (ND: 451 yards per game total offense)
The Eifert Years
2010: Rudolph has another pretty good year, but was injured alot (28/328/3); Eifert comes on the scene (27/352/2); Ragone alive. (ND: 379 yards per game total offense)
2011: Eifert is a madman (63/803/5); Ragone, Welch, and Koyack combine for 3 catches (ND: 413 yards per game total offense)
2012: Eifert is great (60/685/4); Niklas recruited (5/75/1); Koyack not showing much (3/39/0) (ND: 412 yards per game total offense)
Lately:
2013: Niklas is heir,
better stats than Rudolph and stays healthy (32/498/5); Koyack is a compliment (10/171/3) (ND: 405 yards per game total offense)
2014: Koyack (30/317/2); Smyth does almost nothing (ND: 445 yards per game total offense)
2015: Jones (13/190/0) Weishar, Smyth, and Hounshell (7/44/1) (
BUT ND:
466 yards per game total offense, the most since 2005, so we had lots of other weapons competing for the ball)