It will show you mechanics, arm strength, etc. but it doesn't tell you anything about how they will develop in the NFL. Think Brady Quinn or Jimmy Clausen. Epic pro days, busts when they got to the league.
"The house that Johnny Built"... are you f'ing kidding me. What a huge douche.
BINGO!!!
And hey, guess what you will do in the NFL, play with players you have never played with before!!
You are giving this pro day idea
waaaay too much credit.
There are just as many busts, probably moreso, than elite QBs that come out of their pro days.
Honestly, look at the SB WINNING QBS of the last decade.
How many of them had EPIC PRO DAYS
and are elite QBs?
One, maybe two, the Manning brothers?
Peyton Manning (#1 overall), 1-2 SB record
Eli Manning (#4 pick), 2-0 SB record
Outside of those two though, none of these guys fit that category.
Drew Brees (2nd Rd), 1-0 SB record
Tom Brady (3rd Rd), 3-2 SB record
Aaron Rodgers (#24), 1-1 SB record
Ben Roethlisberger (#11 overall), 2-1 SB record
Russell Wilson (2nd Round), 1-0 SB Record
I guess it depends on when you start you decade, but that is a record of 11-6 in the SB and I would say that the large majority of them never had a pro day or needed one in order to get drafted. Sure the Pats got a steal in Brady, but the idea still stands that they never had a pro day, all are SB winners and I would say everyone except Wilson is already on track for a HOF bust right now.
All of them , not named Eli or Peyton, MADE their case for being drafted as high as they were AT THE COMBINE THROWING TO A BUNCH OF NEW RECEIVERS. The idea that you do not want them to try and throw to brand new receivers because you want them to look good is ENTIRELY proving the point that pro days are agent-driven exercises.
The ONLY reason they show up in droves is because that may be their one chance to see a QB perform in person, NOT because they plan on gleaning a lot of new information. They are probably there just to see if their suspicions are true...and I think that the trademark issue is entirely in line with what Zimmer was referring to with JFF.
You want to spend a first round pick on a guy who will represent your team well both on and off the field. Do you honestly think that JFF would be that guy?