Finished FFXVI finally (100%) and here are my thoughts:
I give the story an 8.5/10. It's pretty predictable, but there is definitely some good charm to it. If I was reading a book about it, or watching a TV show, it would be that. I think the Sidequests are not fun at all, very boring, and add very little to the game's overall play and story. The ending of the game leaves a lot to the player's interpretation. These are my least favorite types of endings generally. But the way this one was done is particularly annoying. I am left with so many questions that don't get answered. Very unfortunate. I have to add here: I do love the main characters. They are all very likable and I never got tired of them. Even the villains are good IMO. Well done there.
Gameplay: 7/10. I think the combat is cool. As you gain more powers it was kinda fun to mix and match and figure out good builds. But there is definitely META to the game that makes most of the choices moot. Eventually, you are just trying to finish battles as quickly as possible and there is very little punishment if you use a particular set of skills over and over. It's very easy to dodge, maneuver, and find openings if you have played a Dark Souls game. I could easily beat bosses without taking a hit my 2nd time through the game (which you have to do to get the Ultima Weapon).
Overall: I got to go with 7.5/10. I wouldn't replay it again I don't think, but I'm not I played it. The biggest issue is this game is not a (J)RPG at all. There is no customization. Your choices don't change anything. Your party is stagnant. It's literally the same game every time. There is no way to approach things differently. And you can't really change the combat to be something different. It's a 1 and done. And honestly, if you are a FF fan, just leave it alone. It doesn't feel like FF at all, which is unfortunate.
I will be switching over to Baldurs Gate 3 with the wife, and maybe giving Starfield a chance in my (limited) spare time.
