The Phoenix Police Union (PLEA) historically resists all forms of oversight, accountability for its officers' actions, and reforms that would change the current status quo. That brings them in direct conflict with Phoenix's Police Chiefs and Mayors and has even put them on the wrong side of state Republican leaders calling for reform. They've had psych evals on hiring, some methods of oversight that have failed to change the "bad apples" behavior whether excessive use of force or racism in spite of anti-bias training. Now the state's Republican leadership, which has dominated state politics, is calling for reform of the Phoenix police.
Arizona attorney general calls for police reform
(Fox10 from AP, June 4)
In reaction to the incident involving Dravon Ames and his family who were called because one of their little girls may have taken a doll from a store leading to the police drawing their guns on the unarmed family and threatening to "cap" the father, one of the lead attorneys for the family is former state Republican Attorney General, Tom Horne. Horne was defeated in the Rep primary by Brnovich. The Ames family is suing Phoenix for $10 million.
Phoenix police ended 2018 with its record number of 44 officer involved shootings, leading the nation. Comparatively, in New York City, which has a population of about 7 million more people than Phoenix, police only fired at people 23 times that year. After reforms instituted by the Chief, in 2019 that was brought down to 15 in 2019.
Democrats also want all police officers to wear body cameras, the creation of a statewide database of police officer disciplinary records so “bad apple” officers can’t jump from agency to agency, and removal of lawsuit immunity for officers found to have acted unlawfully. Democrats have also called on the US DOJ to investigate the PD for civil rights violations.
Republican AG Brnovich also wants all police shootings or excessive use of force allegations to be investigated by an outside agency as California and New York currently do.
A Timeline of the Phoenix Police Department's Worst Misconduct Scandals (Phoenix New Times, June 10, 2019)
The Arizona Republic found that over five years, hundreds of officers have been permitted to wipe out more than 600 acts of wrongdoing. The PD has been criticized for allowing officers to purge disciplinary measures from their records.
One would expect the Phoenix PD Union to oppose these bipartisan measures at city and state levels. Federal action from the Trump DOJ is only an outside hope. Perhaps the "good apples" in the PD would work with Dem and Rep leaderships to effect reasonable and effective changes that would rid the Department of those who commit these acts and post racist comments on social media.