Immigration

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
If you don't want to deport them and you don't want to detain them in American prisons, what do you want to do? Kill them? Send them to GTMO?

I will speak more slowly for you. I. want. to. deport. them. but. not. deport. them. and. then. allow. them. to. just. walk. back. across. the. border. and. into. the. US.

Is that clear enough for you?
 

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
Since Mexicans make up roughly half, lets go with 50 Mexicans a day, along a border than is around 2,000 miles. That's a 40:1 miles to person ratio, so forty miles of wall to keep out one farm laborer per day... absolutely hemorrhaging.

Here's the problem with this math.......... it assumes that only Mexicans are illegally crossing the US-Mexico border. And that's simply not true. And securing the border is not about keeping Mexicans in Mexico. It's about letting ONE terrorist cross undetected. We have an obligation to keep that from happening, as well as we reasonably can.
 

BobbyMac

Staff & Stuff
Staff member
Messages
33,950
Reaction score
9,294
Do this with criminals?? They'd be building a wall near the border. As in, they walk across a literal line in the sand and we don't have jurisdiction to apprehend them... Seems like a solid idea for a comedy scene.

You were referring to Mexican/Central American Double Illegals only, ok. I was referring to ALL illegal immigrants who get caught not breaking any other law. They are just crossing the border or overstaying their visas.

In your case, I'm building a Double Illegal Only prison/internment center in bum fvck Nevada and supplying them with exactly what an American would get in the average 3rd world prison. When they've served their time, they are deported. By the time they get deported, our new wall would be complete.
 

GoIrish41

Paterfamilius
Messages
9,929
Reaction score
2,120
I will speak more slowly for you. I. want. to. deport. them. but. not. deport. them. and. then. allow. them. to. just. walk. back. across. the. border. and. into. the. US.

Is that clear enough for you?

Oh, so you ARE talking about Mexicans after all.

My question is how do you do that?
 
Last edited:

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
Oh, so you ARE talking about Mexicans after all.

My question is how do you do that?

Don't be an asshole. I was answering his comment about walking across the border. If HE was speaking of Mexicans doing that, then yes, I guess I AM talking about Mexicans.

You secure the border as best you can. I don't have all of the answers for how. I would imagine that it would require a combination of wall, technology, and more boots on the ground. As I've previously said....... it won't keep EVERYONE out; but it will keep it from being too easy for them. And I'm sure that someone much smarter than me has some concrete answers for how to do it.
 

ickythump1225

New member
Messages
4,036
Reaction score
323
Oh you want to deport them to Mexico where they are then free to sneak back into the country? That...sounds like a worse idea.
OR we could secure the f**king border and not worry about them sneaking back in. Instead you'd rather leave the border porous and open.
 

Rizzophil

Well-known member
Messages
2,431
Reaction score
579
why do illegal immigrants get to pull social security? It's already totally broke
 

Legacy

New member
Messages
7,871
Reaction score
321
why do illegal immigrants get to pull social security? It's already totally broke

Who did you hear that from?

Fact Checker
Trump’s false claim that undocumented immigrants collect Social Security benefits


Unauthorized immigrants, who are not granted any deferred-action status, are not eligible to receive Social Security benefits or any other federal means-tested benefits. But they pay taxes and pay into the Social Security system.

Even though the majority of unauthorized immigrants can’t collect the benefits, they paid about $12 billion into the cash flow of the Social Security program in 2010, according to the Social Security actuary. (Some undocumented immigrants could theoretically collect benefits — illegally — if they’ve overstayed their visas or falsely obtained a Social Security number.) That means the U.S. government gets far more than it pays out when it comes to unauthorized immigrants.

Current law allows immigrants when they become legal to get credit for those taxes paid when they were illegal. Until then, they pay into the system but get none of the benefits except:

-- Emergency medical care (which includes emergency labor and delivery)
-- Emergency disaster relief that is provided for the short term and is not a cash payment
-- Limited immunizations and testing, and treatment of symptoms of communicable diseases
-- Certain community programs, such as soup kitchens or crisis counseling, as specified by the Attorney General
-- Limited housing or community development assistance to those already receiving it in 1996

The deferred action immigrants include Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents (DAPA).
DAPA and DACA grantees are considered lawfully present in the United States. They can apply for a Social Security number once they receive work permits. They earn Social Security and Medicare benefits through their payroll taxes — meaning they must be paying taxes. To collect the benefits, they must reach retirement age and must have worked for at least 10 years, according to the National Immigration Law Center.

DACA grantees will not yet reach retirement age if Clinton becomes president and serves two terms in office. DACA grantees must have been under 31 as of June 15, 2012, and meet several other criteria to be eligible. So if Clinton serves two terms and leaves office in 2025, the oldest DACA grantees would be 43.

Moreover, once people receive deferred-action status under DACA, they are considered lawfully present in the United States. So they would not be “illegal immigrants,” as the ad says. About 728,000 people have been granted DACA — 6 percent of the estimated undocumented immigrant population of 11 million.
 
Last edited:

Bluto

Well-known member
Messages
8,146
Reaction score
3,979
Clicked on this hoping to see that Vangorder had gotten caught up in an ICE raid. Oh well...
 

NDinL.A.

New member
Messages
8,121
Reaction score
1,734
OR we could secure the f**king border and not worry about them sneaking back in. Instead you'd rather leave the border porous and open.

You need to stop listening to Trump's blatant lies. NO ONE wants a porous border. Illegal immigration is actually significantly down from the 90's because of policies and money put towards securing the border. It absolutely could be better, but Trump's ridiculous fear-mongering has you guys believing that there is a revolving door at the borders. It's just not reality.
 
B

Buster Bluth

Guest
The problem is that they use twice the amount in government services.

How Much Does Illegal Immigration Cost You? - AMAC, Inc.

That writeup should make people's skin crawl. So obviously designed to be consumed by an "us against them" crowd of old people who think everyone who isn't them is a taker.

This one in particular made me lol.

Other households are net tax consumers: The benefits they receive exceed the taxes they pay. These households generate a “fiscal deficit” that must be financed by taxes from other households or by government borrowing.

Yeah, or many of the other streams of income for the federal government. Like consumption taxes, paid by everyone who consumes--even poor people. Or Social Secuirty taxes, paid by everyone with a job to be eligible to receive the benefit--even poor people. Or corporate taxes, paid by coprations and not households. Or property taxes, paid not only by households but various organizations too.

But don't bring up that context...it's either taking from my wallet or built on government debt! Durrrrrrrrrrrrr. Associarion of MATURE American Citizens my ass...

Means-tested welfare benefits. There are over 80 of these programs which, at a cost of nearly $900 billion per year, provide cash, food, housing, medical, and other services to roughly 100 million low-income Americans. Major programs include Medicaid, food stamps, the refundable Earned Income Tax Credit, public housing, Supplemental Security Income, and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families.

We could use a little more context here pointing out just how many of these programs go to the 50+ crowd this website is made for. That might destroy the narrative of "We spend sooo much money on welfare it's killing us!" pretty quickly though.

Newsflash for everyone: mainstream economists consider illegal immigration's impact to be roughly even when accounting for the impact on the economy/purchasing power and tax benefits paid to their American children--to clarify, even if you deported them all you'd still be paying all sorts of benefits to the Americans who are members of their families.
 
Last edited:

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
That writeup should make people's skin crawl. So obviously designed to be consumed by an "us against them" crowd of old people who think everyone who isn't them is a taker.

This one in particular made me lol.



Yeah, or many of the other streams of income for the federal government. Like consumption taxes, paid by everyone who consumes--even poor people. Or Social Secuirty taxes, paid by everyone with a job to be eligible to receive the benefit--even poor people. Or corporate taxes, paid by coprations and not households. Or property taxes, paid not only by households but various organizations too.

But don't bring up that context...it's either taking from my wallet or built on government debt! Durrrrrrrrrrrrr. Associarion of MATURE American Citizens my ass...



We could use a little more context here pointing out just how many of these programs go to the 50+ crowd this website is made for. That might destroy the narrative of "We spend sooo much money on welfare it's killing us!" pretty quickly though.

Newsflash for everyone: mainstream economists consider illegal immigration's impact to be roughly even when accounting for the impact on the economy/purchasing power and tax benefits paid to their American children--to clarify, even if you deported them all you'd still be paying all sorts of benefits to the Americans who are members of their families.

A lot of their conclusions were predicated on an amnesty making the vast majority of these illegals actual citizens, eligible for all the social welfare programs described. It's not the most honest article, but it's not as bad as you describe, either. As usual, the truth is somewhere in the middle.
 

phgreek

New member
Messages
6,956
Reaction score
433
A lot of their conclusions were predicated on an amnesty making the vast majority of these illegals actual citizens, eligible for all the social welfare programs described. It's not the most honest article, but it's not as bad as you describe, either. As usual, the truth is somewhere in the middle.

even if it is half right...claiming illegal immigration is a net positive is a joke. I've read estimates ranging from $80B in costs to $113B...fine cut the small number in half...$40B is what illegals cost this country...what numbers do they contribute...12.5 Billion, lets double that. Guess what, in a very conservative estimate they cost twice as much as they contribute...this line of discussion is mind numbing.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,995
Elsewhere...

Angela Merkel loses votes to far-right AfD party in home state election | Metro News

This is what happens when you push the agenda as hard as she did... you get a reaction. In this country, that reaction is "Trump" which is very sad. But when the "elites" and the "establishment" push crap the average citizen doesn't want they swing strongly in the opposite direction as a response and everyone loses.
 

Legacy

New member
Messages
7,871
Reaction score
321
Temporary worker statuses

Temporary worker statuses

Israel lives with the constant need for immigrants for their businesses to survive and with hostility from their neighbors. What if we establish a temporary worker program as they have done. Mexicans and other Latin Americans, in general, cross illegally for the economic benefits that work in our country provides. Many illegals who stay here understandably consider themselves as natives of their countries, but some are fleeing violence in their countries and do not wish to return. They are not skilled labor but do the manual we need, harvesting crops, construction, roofing, hotel work, .etc

What if we establish a similar system to Israel's, securing our much longer border, but also establishing places of work in the bordering states? We give work permits, bus them to places of employment, pay them half as much as American workers, give basic health care - clinics, preventive care like immunizations, etc. Perhaps housing.

American industries like clothing manufactures could move back to America near the border, have low wage workers, who pay taxes on their wages, say 10%. Those temp workers could move back and forth even daily, bused back to Mexico, which benefits from the income they earn.

Palestinians in Israel: Crossing Borders
Nearly 50,000 Palestinians officially work in Israel, while around 30,000 cross the border illegally every day from the West Bank to work. Israel does not make it easy


Israel eases entry criteria for West Bank Palestinians
Men over 55 can now enter Israel with no permit; married laborers 22 and above are eligible to apply
 
Last edited:

Legacy

New member
Messages
7,871
Reaction score
321
The Law Of Unintended Consequences: Georgia's Immigration Law Backfires

Lack of immigration reform threatens California farmers
Growers have difficulty fielding adequate crews to harvest crops; Washington has a shot this year at providing meaningful relief.


Bitter Harvest: U.S. Farmers Blame Billion-Dollar Losses on Immigration Laws

I'd rather eat foods grown here than from Mexico, Chile, Egypt, Asia etc.

Imported foods causing more disease
Foodborne disease from imported foods is on the rise, with more foods from more countries causing more outbreaks, the CDC says.

The most common culprits are fish and spices, particularly peppers, the CDC's Hannah Gould, PhD, said in a report to this week's International Conference on Emerging Infectious Diseases in Atlanta.

Almost half of the foods causing outbreaks -- 45% -- came from Asia.
Why the increase in foreign foodborne disease? It may not be that the food is any less safe. We're just importing more of it.
From 1998 to 2007, U.S. food imports grew from $41 billion to $78 billion. About 85% of the seafood Americans eat comes from outside the country. At some times of the year, 60% of U.S. fresh produce is imported.
 
Last edited:

BGIF

Varsity Club
Messages
43,946
Reaction score
2,922
Work on Calais wall to start this month, Britain says | Reuters


Work on building a wall in the northern French port of Calais to try to stop refugees and migrants from jumping aboard trucks bound for Britain will begin this month, according to British officials.

Immigration minister, Robert Goodwill, told lawmakers that security was being stepped up in Calais, home to the "Jungle" camp where thousands of migrants fleeing war and poverty in the Middle East and Africa hope to cross the English Channel to Britain.

"The security we're putting in in the ports is being stepped up with equipment," Goodwill said on Tuesday, referring to a 17 million pounds ($22.75 million) package of security measures agreed by Britain and France in March this year.

"We are going to start building this big new wall as part of the 17 million package that we are doing with the French ... We've done the fence and now we're doing the wall."

The wall, which is expected to be four meters (13 ft)high and be built along both sides of a 1-km (0.6 mile) stretch of the Rocade port approach road, should be completed by the end of this year.

($1 = 0.7472 pounds)
 
Last edited:

Polish Leppy 22

Well-known member
Messages
6,594
Reaction score
2,009
Elsewhere...

Angela Merkel loses votes to far-right AfD party in home state election | Metro News

This is what happens when you push the agenda as hard as she did... you get a reaction. In this country, that reaction is "Trump" which is very sad. But when the "elites" and the "establishment" push crap the average citizen doesn't want they swing strongly in the opposite direction as a response and everyone loses.

Yep, and the GOP spending way too much time pushing Jeb, and a ridiculous 17 people running that wasted time and resources.
 

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181
even if it is half right...claiming illegal immigration is a net positive is a joke. I've read estimates ranging from $80B in costs to $113B...fine cut the small number in half...$40B is what illegals cost this country...what numbers do they contribute...12.5 Billion, lets double that. Guess what, in a very conservative estimate they cost twice as much as they contribute...this line of discussion is mind numbing.

I'm just saying that the whole article is premised on an amnesty for the 11 million illegals living here right now. There is no amnesty at this point, but the article kind of gives the impression that the costs that they are referencing are happening right now. They aren't (all) happening right now, but they would under an amnesty.
 

phgreek

New member
Messages
6,956
Reaction score
433
I'm just saying that the whole article is premised on an amnesty for the 11 million illegals living here right now. There is no amnesty at this point, but the article kind of gives the impression that the costs that they are referencing are happening right now. They aren't (all) happening right now, but they would under an amnesty.

Understood...

The thing is, for people having families and picking fucking fruit or some other menial task...THEY CANNOT BE A NET POSITIVE... It costs more than the taxes on a fucking fruit pickers wages to educate his/her kids...not to mention myriad of medical and other services they receive but pay a pittance toward. So now we pay for them and the people whom we owe a duty to (citizens) who might do those jobs...JFC this discussion is infuriating. It cost me a thousand bucks per kid to go to PUBLIC school because of this shit. WTF is wrong with some of you people?

Is there a need for migrant workers...sure...its dumb to think the people who need jobs all live around massive farms, but the operative word is MIGRANT for fuck sakes...means go home, have your kids at home, educate your kids at home, and if you like it here, get in line to become a citizen...and if you develop a specialized skill that helps this nation, you might get to become a citizen sooner....if you are fleeing danger to your person, you might get to stay while you work to become a citizen. It is as good as it gets, so it is criminal to circumvent the system both literally and figuratively.

Just want to punch someone...swear to god!
 

GoIrish41

Paterfamilius
Messages
9,929
Reaction score
2,120
Understood...

The thing is, for people having families and picking fucking fruit or some other menial task...THEY CANNOT BE A NET POSITIVE... It costs more than the taxes on a fucking fruit pickers wages to educate his/her kids...not to mention myriad of medical and other services they receive but pay a pittance toward. So now we pay for them and the people whom we owe a duty to (citizens) who might do those jobs...JFC this discussion is infuriating. It cost me a thousand bucks per kid to go to PUBLIC school because of this shit. WTF is wrong with some of you people?

Is there a need for migrant workers...sure...its dumb to think the people who need jobs all live around massive farms, but the operative word is MIGRANT for fuck sakes...means go home, have your kids at home, educate your kids at home, and if you like it here, get in line to become a citizen...and if you develop a specialized skill that helps this nation, you might get to become a citizen sooner....if you are fleeing danger to your person, you might get to stay while you work to become a citizen. It is as good as it gets, so it is criminal to circumvent the system both literally and figuratively.

Just want to punch someone...swear to god!

Before you earn your internet tough guy championship belt, you may want to read this. ...
\
Is Illegal Immigration an Economic Burden to America? - Illegal Immigration Solutions - ProCon.org

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/17/m...grants-actually-hurt-the-us-economy.html?_r=0

https://www.americanprogress.org/is...02/08/52377/immigrants-are-makers-not-takers/

5 immigration myths debunked - Nov. 20, 2014
 
Last edited:

Legacy

New member
Messages
7,871
Reaction score
321
Understood...

The thing is, for people having families and picking fucking fruit or some other menial task...THEY CANNOT BE A NET POSITIVE... It costs more than the taxes on a fucking fruit pickers wages to educate his/her kids...not to mention myriad of medical and other services they receive but pay a pittance toward. So now we pay for them and the people whom we owe a duty to (citizens) who might do those jobs...JFC this discussion is infuriating. It cost me a thousand bucks per kid to go to PUBLIC school because of this shit. WTF is wrong with some of you people?

Is there a need for migrant workers...sure...its dumb to think the people who need jobs all live around massive farms, but the operative word is MIGRANT for fuck sakes...means go home, have your kids at home, educate your kids at home, and if you like it here, get in line to become a citizen...and if you develop a specialized skill that helps this nation, you might get to become a citizen sooner....if you are fleeing danger to your person, you might get to stay while you work to become a citizen. It is as good as it gets, so it is criminal to circumvent the system both literally and figuratively.

Just want to punch someone...swear to god!

There's nothing wrong in expressing an opinion on a message board. This issue has many aspects that individuals may view differently than another poster.

As with so much stagnation on issues, I blame this Congress, who acts like a little child who wants their way or no compromise instead, assigning an opposing side their last name as a touchstone for anger. "Gang of Eight" "Hillary" "Obama". Well, the establishment Republicans got that anger thrown in their faces.

We have a real need for immigration reform and have for decades. But maybe legislators are very similar to your "WTF is wrong with you people." As I posted, Georgia, Alabama and others lost a cumulative billion in crop losses with the strict immigration laws some people want. California Valley farmers want real immigration reform. We get 50% of our food grown there. Construction owners lose fifty percent of their applicants when they announce that they will do background checks or ask for SS ids, but love the labor.

I, too, am frustrated at the use of our institutions and the subsequent costs to us. Vote 'em all out that can't come up with laws on immigration, tax reform, inversions, military spending, infectious diseases, food from other countries etc. etc. But I can't vote in those states whose legislators who are obstructionists or hyperbolists.

We do have illegals setting up drug rings and gangs, health care that does not act like Mexico where you pay up front or else, parents who don't take their kids for immunizations or health care for fear of deportation, drivers licenses given without real identification, a subculture that does not have any interest in assimilation or reporting criminal activity to police.

Without immigration reform we have the status quo, which unacceptable for illegal immigration, an inflamed populace that wants to blame each other and is suffering, and simplified solutions.

I'll post another link which you can read - or not - about securing the border.

U.S. border officer: "Do you think a wall is gonna stop them?"
 
Last edited:

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
8,622
Reaction score
2,724
I find it hilarious the same folks that want to put coal miners out of work and promise high paying windmill jobs in return justify higher electricity costs to no end.... then in the next breath we can't possibly allow food costs to go up by screwing up the migrant workers for farmers. Collateral expenses of "global warming" are unbearable but the collateral damages of illegal immigrants are outlandishly overstated and worth the effort anyway. Give me a break. I'm with phgreek on this one.
 

kmoose

Banned
Messages
10,298
Reaction score
1,181

If you can't tell the difference between venting and being a tough guy.........

Maybe YOU should read the articles:

Harvard's George Borjas says the average American's wealth is increased by less than 1 percent because of illegal immigration.

So, despite your dire predictions of doom and gloom, the average American will lose less than 1% of their wealth, if all 11 million illegals are deported. Factor in even less of a loss when they are allowed to come back under more strictly controlled temporary work visas, and your shouting about ruining the economy look even MORE "chicken little-ish".
 

IrishBroker

New member
Messages
1,278
Reaction score
50
Hey, leftists should be happy to deport the illegal immigrants picking the fields (which I'd love to see what the actual breakdown of jobs they do)...

You could just move in with the unions and pay a decent wage.

Alsol, by advocating that we'd be destroying business by getting rid of "cheap labor", are you saying you support paying people a cheap wage?
 

IrishBroker

New member
Messages
1,278
Reaction score
50
I say, let them stay. And drive unions out with low wage workers in these low skill/education jobs. In fact, help them move upstate into union heavy states and give them grants to start their own businesses in competition with unions.

Then, anyone not born in America, or who is not made a citizen, from then on, isn't eligible for any public assistance. At all. And charge a 50% tax on all monies being sent back to Mexico via western union or the like (or any other country)

See how low illegal immigration drops at that point.

A wall will not solve the problem. Start destroying their economic prosperity, they'll stop coming.
 

GoIrish41

Paterfamilius
Messages
9,929
Reaction score
2,120
If you can't tell the difference between venting and being a tough guy.........

Maybe YOU should read the articles:



So, despite your dire predictions of doom and gloom, the average American will lose less than 1% of their wealth, if all 11 million illegals are deported. Factor in even less of a loss when they are allowed to come back under more strictly controlled temporary work visas, and your shouting about ruining the economy look even MORE "chicken little-ish".

The point is that they are not the drain on society that they are made out to be. In fact, the average American would be worse off than if they stayed, no matter how much worse off. We would not be better off as your argument goes. If you can say I'm not willing to pay more taxes to support them and it is disproven that you do, I can say I'm not willing to take a hit for sending them back to the despicable circumstances. Now that I'm making the same economic argument you were making, it is BS, but when you make it, it is sound. Weak sauce.

Keep reading. I posted four articles not just a sentence pulled out of one of them. And all of them agree that illegal immigrants is not costing Americans, but benefitting them.
 
Last edited:
Top