General team info

Irish du Nord

Irish du Nord

Well-known member
Messages
3,415
Reaction score
3,065
CoachB said:
I was listening to the Andy and Ari on3 show, and Ari said an NFL scout that has been all around the country at fall camps told him that Notre Dame has far and away the most impressive roster of every place he has been. My own note: not sure all the places he has been.
Click to expand...
“Most impressive roster in the state of Indiana!”-Colts scout who hates traveling
 
N

NDFAN2008

Well-known member
Messages
7,330
Reaction score
5,655
CoachB said:
I was listening to the Andy and Ari on3 show, and Ari said an NFL scout that has been all around the country at fall camps told him that Notre Dame has far and away the most impressive roster of every place he has been. My own note: not sure all the places he has been.
Click to expand...
It will only get better with the 2026 and 2027 classes I think the 2027 class could be loaded. And a lot of our top NFL talent still has eligibility after this year
 
KPENN

KPENN

Well-known member
Staff member
Messages
13,016
Reaction score
11,338
CoachB said:
I was listening to the Andy and Ari on3 show, and Ari said an NFL scout that has been all around the country at fall camps told him that Notre Dame has far and away the most impressive roster of every place he has been. My own note: not sure all the places he has been.
Click to expand...
What episode?
 
L

LifelongFan

Well-known member
Messages
1,599
Reaction score
1,914
There are some positions where it's hard to get drafted and it's easy to fall out, but really I think the starters are all NFL quality at some level, outside of the guys I've never seen play. The defensive tackles are where my doubt is. Mills was a 5th and Cross wasn't drafted. These guys aren't as good as them.
 
Crazy Balki

Crazy Balki

Site Assigned Optimist
Messages
7,868
Reaction score
4,477
LifelongFan said:
There are some positions where it's hard to get drafted and it's easy to fall out, but really I think the starters are all NFL quality at some level, outside of the guys I've never seen play. The defensive tackles are where my doubt is. Mills was a 5th and Cross wasn't drafted. These guys aren't as good as them.
Click to expand...
Mills dropped to 5th, because he got hurt late in the season and was out for the combine.

Cross dropped because he's a 6'1 280 lb NT. There's only so many Aaron Donald's out there.

I also wouldn't put it past guys like Hinish or Onye to match or even exceed Mills and Cross, especially if the 2024 version is what we're gauging it off of. Cross was simply not his vintage self in 2024. He was too banged up all year, and Mills was very good, but oftentimes would go hot and cold.

I mean, are we seriously going to doubt a Hinish at this point? He was arguably our best DT in the CFP.
 
stlnd01

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Ndaccountant said:
Easy.
Start Tate. Bench Shark. Cut Floyd.

Tate was the most dynamic and could play RB if needed. Shark was an all around better receiver than Floyd too. Floyd was terrific, but the other two were better.
Click to expand...
Floyd was such a beast. It's easy to forget because of how his NFL career turned out but bubble screens where he ran over DBs was basically our entire offense in 2011. I'd put him ahead of Samardzija, who benefited from a MUCH better QB (and also great hair).
Tate ties Kyren Williams for favorite ND player of the 21st Century. Such a dawg.
 
greyhammer90

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
16,820
Reaction score
16,080
Floyd is pretty unquestionably the greatest WR in NDs history. Tate and Shark are more fan favorites for reasons I understand but Floyd's dominance is sort of undeniable.

Most recieving yards in ND history.
Most recieving TDs in ND history.
Most receptions in ND history.
Most 100 yard recieving games in ND history.
Plus a ton of single season records.

And, unlike Tate or Shark he spent a lot of his time as an upperclassmen being thrown to by Rees. Love Rees as a Loyal Son and gamer but he's not close to Clausen or Quinn as a passing QB.
 
A

ab2cmiller

Troublemaker in training
Messages
11,453
Reaction score
8,531
Tate
Floyd
Shark

It's all very close for me. All the career records for Floyd are meaningless as it relates to this order. Besides, there's a decent chance that if Tate came back for his Senior year he would hold some of those records.

Tate came in and had to spend virtually his entire Freshman season learning to play the WR position. Floyd came in as a Freshman college ready. What Tate did his Jr year at ND was crazy. Floyd had the better overall career, but the list isn't asking for that.

Who would I take into battle? While I believe Floyd and Tate were really close, I believe that Tate had surpassed Floyd as the top receiver when he left.

Floyd over Shark for many of the reasons that others have pointed out.

Others will rank them differently, and that's OK because they were all great.
 
ulukinatme

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2025!
Messages
31,509
Reaction score
17,369
IrishWayDomer said:
Did Floyd sleep with your husband?
Click to expand...

Dunno about @Ndaccountant, but pretty sure Floyd slept with my cousin :laugh: They were "good friends" and were supposed to go to a dance together, but had a falling out over his drinking and she went with Nate Montana instead. I've told this story before, but the night Floyd broke his collarbone against Michigan State he went out to dinner with my cousin and grandparents. My grandpa offered to pay for Floyd's meal, but he politely declined because it would have been a violation at the time.
 
Irish#1

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,577
Reaction score
20,026
greyhammer90 said:
Floyd is pretty unquestionably the greatest WR in NDs history. Tate and Shark are more fan favorites for reasons I understand but Floyd's dominance is sort of undeniable.

Most recieving yards in ND history.
Most recieving TDs in ND history.
Most receptions in ND history.
Most 100 yard recieving games in ND history.
Plus a ton of single season records.

And, unlike Tate or Shark he spent a lot of his time as an upperclassmen being thrown to by Rees. Love Rees as a Loyal Son and gamer but he's not close to Clausen or Quinn as a passing QB.
Click to expand...
Jack Snow, Tom Gatewood and Jim Seymour are feeling slighted! lol

Obviously they played in a different time, but Snow was an AA. Gatewood was also an AA and started all three seasons he was eligible (freshman weren't allowed to play back then) and set several school records. Seymour was a three time AA for ND and is considered on of the top 50 players at ND. All three played in the NFL.

Tate
Floyd
Shark
 
Last edited:
D

DomeFieldAdvantage

Well-known member
Messages
326
Reaction score
529
CoachB said:
I was listening to the Andy and Ari on3 show, and Ari said an NFL scout that has been all around the country at fall camps told him that Notre Dame has far and away the most impressive roster of every place he has been. My own note: not sure all the places he has been.
Click to expand...
Don't want to be too much of a buzzkill, but wasn't the same thing being said about FSU before last season?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top