'22 NJ QB Steven Angeli (Notre Dame Signee)

BoredIrish

BoredIrish

Well-known member
Messages
2,151
Reaction score
1,821
Realistically, QB #4 going forward will probably have to be an academic oriented GT or a PWO.
 
Veritate Duce Progredi

Veritate Duce Progredi

A man gotta have a code
Messages
9,358
Reaction score
5,352
NDdomer2 said:
marcus - we want 4 qbs on roster. brings one in and loses one and starts counting at practice wondering why there isnt 4.
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
B

bumpdaddy

Well-known member
Messages
431
Reaction score
1,020
NDdomer2 said:
i dont care what it really is but its just more bullshit from MF.
Click to expand...
So let's say MF doesn't bring a transfer in, Angeli wins the starting job and Minchey doesn't see a path to starting in the next couple of years and decides to transfer. We'd then have Angeli and Carr as our only 2 scholarship QBs and if one gets hurt ND is in a very tight spot for the rest of the season.

Or, if you prefer, let's say no transfer QB, Minchey wins the job, and Angeli definitely transfers because he got passed up by an underclassman. You're then left with just Minchey and Carr to start the season.

You prefer either of those 2 scenarios over bringing in a GT and giving ND the best shot at having at least 3 scholarship QBs for the '24 season?
 
NDdomer2

NDdomer2

Local Sports vBookie
Messages
17,050
Reaction score
3,875
bumpdaddy said:
So let's say MF doesn't bring a transfer in, Angeli wins the starting job and Minchey doesn't see a path to starting in the next couple of years and decides to transfer. We'd then have Angeli and Carr as our only 2 scholarship QBs and if one gets hurt ND is in a very tight spot for the rest of the season.

Or, if you prefer, let's say no transfer QB, Minchey wins the job, and Angeli definitely transfers because he got passed up by an underclassman. You're then left with just Minchey and Carr to start the season.

You prefer either of those 2 scenarios over bringing in a GT and giving ND the best shot at having at least 3 scholarship QBs for the '24 season?
Click to expand...
Sure man what if we get a GT who promptly gets hurt. Angeli balls, minchey transfers were at 2 then too. What iff car decides he doesn't want to play for a school with a bunch of unproven wrs, then Leonard chases the bag and we only have Angeli and minchey.

Want to keep going?

None of this changes from my point that the goal to be at 4 is kinda pointless when all options to get to four likely lead to not being at 4.
 
Irishman77

Irishman77

Well-known member
Messages
5,132
Reaction score
445
Luckylucci said:
Like I said about the truth and all.

CJ was offered by Tommy Rees in June of 2021 and visited Notre Dawn campus before Freeman called any shots.
Click to expand...
Wow! Tommy offered a 5 star qb that loved Notre dame so much even know his grandpa is a Michigan icon.

The MAC was blessed that year from Tommy boy not swooping in and robbing them for a change.
 
Last edited:
IAIrish

IAIrish

The Dude Abides
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
2,073
NDdomer2 said:
Sure man what if we get a GT who promptly gets hurt. Angeli balls, minchey transfers were at 2 then too. What iff car decides he doesn't want to play for a school with a bunch of unproven wrs, then Leonard chases the bag and we only have Angeli and minchey.

Want to keep going?

None of this changes from my point that the goal to be at 4 is kinda pointless when all options to get to four likely lead to not being at 4.
Click to expand...
Much of this will happen. Most will leave. It's a male soap opera fellas.

Are you ready for it? I know I'm here for it, Goddammit.
 
B

bumpdaddy

Well-known member
Messages
431
Reaction score
1,020
NDdomer2 said:
Sure man what if we get a GT who promptly gets hurt. Angeli balls, minchey transfers were at 2 then too. What iff car decides he doesn't want to play for a school with a bunch of unproven wrs, then Leonard chases the bag and we only have Angeli and minchey.

Want to keep going?

None of this changes from my point that the goal to be at 4 is kinda pointless when all options to get to four likely lead to not being at 4.
Click to expand...
The goal isn't to be at 4. I never tried to make that point. The hope is to be at 4 but that's not the goal. The goal is to give yourself the best chance to have at least 3. QBs transfer frequently. It's going to happen and that was true before the transfer portal.

The scenarios I gave you are likely scenarios or at least fall in the category of strong possibility. You threw out less likely scenarios. Could any of your scenarios happen? Sure, but a good coach doesn't just say, "Screw it, nothing is guaranteed so I'm just going to roll the dice and stick with what I have." A good coach makes a calculation based on what's most likely to happen and then does what's best for the team. Having a QB room with only 3 scholarship QBs heading into spring, all of whom have no starting experience, and accepting the strong possibility either Minchey or Angeli will transfer out depending on who wins the starting job (or both if Carr wins the job), is a great way to set yourself up for disaster.

If we had a deeper QB room already or at least a stud QB who is definitely ready to take over the team I'd agree with you, but I don't think we have either so MF would be negligent if he didn't pursue another GT QB.
 
ulukinatme

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2026!
Messages
31,523
Reaction score
17,404
Luckylucci said:
Like I said about the truth and all.

CJ was offered by Tommy Rees in June of 2021 and visited Notre Dame campus before Freeman called any shots.
Click to expand...

Don't bring facts to a fight with Irishman77, you're beating a man with no arms. Aside from bringing in Hartman, Minchey, and Carr in the span of a few months, Rees turned Milroe into a Heisman contender this year and he's coaching in the SEC Championship tomorrow with the opportunity to backdoor into the playoff if they win. They'll leapfrog OSU with a win, Oregon just lost, it would all depend on where Georgia would fall and what FSU's backup does against Louisville.
 
T-Boone

T-Boone

Well-known member
Messages
8,401
Reaction score
4,796
ulukinatme said:
Don't bring facts to a fight with Irishman77, you're beating a man with no arms. Aside from bringing in Hartman, Minchey, and Carr in the span of a few months, Rees turned Milroe into a Heisman contender this year and he's coaching in the SEC Championship tomorrow with the opportunity to backdoor into the playoff if they win. They'll leapfrog OSU with a win, Oregon just lost, it would all depend on where Georgia would fall and what FSU's backup does against Louisville.
Click to expand...
Why don’t you marry Rees ffs
 
irishandy

irishandy

Well-known member
Messages
4,340
Reaction score
1,962
Taking Riley is a risk to me especially with his injury. Plus is Riley 100% coming to ND??

Depending on position, players wise ND needs to believe in their players in house before it starts affecting recruiting.

With our schedule next year, Angeli should be able to handle.
 
R

Reaper97

Banned
Messages
3,109
Reaction score
4,226
Irishman77 said:
Wow! Tommy offered a 5 star qb that loved Notre dame so much even know his grandpa is a Michigan icon.

The MAC was blessed that year from Tommy boy not swooping in and robbing them for a change.
Click to expand...
You have literally never posted anything worth poop.
Not only did he offer him, he then recruited him, it’s not like he offered him & stopped.
The point was he offered before MF had any say.
Then Tommy recruited him & won him over the following year.
 
StPaul_Irish

StPaul_Irish

Resident Smart Ass
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3,119
Reaper97 said:
You have literally never posted anything worth poop.
Not only did he offer him, he then recruited him, it’s not like he offered him & stopped.
The point was he offered before MF had any say.
Then Tommy recruited him & won him over the following year.
Click to expand...

You think any of this happens w/o Freeman?

If you do, I have some ocean front Property in AZ for ya bud.
 
R

Reaper97

Banned
Messages
3,109
Reaction score
4,226
StPaul_Irish said:
You think any of this happens w/o Freeman?

If you do, I have some ocean front Property in AZ for ya bud.
Click to expand...
I lived in Arizona, so no thanks.

And Tommy didn’t offer Carr & recruit him because of Freeman.
Did you even read the conversation or just jump in?
The poster said Timmy only went after MAC level QBs, and Freeman made him go after P5 QB’s, which is false.
Another poster said that Timmy offered & recruited Carr before Freeman had any say, which is fact.

So yes, I do believe Tommy would offer & recruit Carr without Freeman having any say because IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED.
 
StPaul_Irish

StPaul_Irish

Resident Smart Ass
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3,119
Reaper97 said:
I lived in Arizona, so no thanks.

And Tommy didn’t offer Carr & recruit him because of Freeman.
Did you even read the conversation or just jump in?
The poster said Timmy only went after MAC level QBs, and Freeman made him go after P5 QB’s, which is false.
Another poster said that Timmy offered & recruited Carr before Freeman had any say, which is fact.

So yes, I do believe Tommy would offer & recruit Carr without Freeman having any say because IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED.
Click to expand...

I truly feel sorry for you. Whatever it is that makes you so angry, I hope you figure it out.
 
StPaul_Irish

StPaul_Irish

Resident Smart Ass
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3,119
Reaper97 said:
I lived in Arizona, so no thanks.

And Tommy didn’t offer Carr & recruit him because of Freeman.
Did you even read the conversation or just jump in?
The poster said Timmy only went after MAC level QBs, and Freeman made him go after P5 QB’s, which is false.
Another poster said that Timmy offered & recruited Carr before Freeman had any say, which is fact.

So yes, I do believe Tommy would offer & recruit Carr without Freeman having any say because IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED.
Click to expand...

I'll dumb this down for you..

Kelly doesn't close this.

CJ is still here. Tommy is not
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top