2026 Transfer Portal - General

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
17,633
Reaction score
17,557


Wisconsin got their guy for the opener it looks like…

I’d say that’s a pretty lackluster pick up from just stat watching given the level of competition. 247 has him as the 19th ranked transfer QB
 

NDPhilly

Philly Torqued
Messages
16,441
Reaction score
16,721
Joseph is going to have some undoubtedly annoying scrambles against us. He can scoot.

That being said, he has been under 60% completion percentage both years as a starter.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,544
Reaction score
28,990
I think the bigger thing for me is that there needs to be consequences. Enforceable salary cap is the likely answer, along with the openness to multiyear contracts.

CFB was always the AAA farm system to the NFL. But with MLB, the players are under control of one organization. What is happening is that the top tier of CFB is the defacto organization and is pillaging less financially meaningful teams, call it AA, and those schools in return are going after the A teams, etc.

I believe in the fairness of both teams and individual. If a player wants to move from MAC starter to Big 12 starter, all for it. So long as the understanding was that he was free to do so contractually.

As a ND fan, this is churn that really doesnt impact them other than the freshman that wants paid more is willing to bet on himself at a lower school and be called back up later. Honestly dime a dozen.

But those kids are not likely to turn into a NFL prospect. But enabled by a perpetual free agent system and greed (player, schools, media, etc.) This player can end up at 3 different schools thinking that a few hundred thousand in the bank is their insurance policy. But once out of that system, they realize they were they pawn and the immense benefits that come with being a scholarship athlete at one school was squandered.

We need fairness in the system, looking out for the young athletes. We think paying them solves it, but I think that is creating different problems that in sum total, may not be worth it for the players.
Personally, I think that people are deluding themselves into thinking there will ever be any sort of truly "enforceable" salary cap. Even if they introduce an (artificially low) salary cap, the SEC will just try to cheat to get around it like they did for two decades with the NCAA. How can you possibly police 100+ schools? 4x the size of the NFL without any professional or enforcement apparatus in place to support it.

The answer, IMO, is not about turning college sports into minor league professional sports. It's about restricting transfer madness, limiting eligibility to stop the 6-year and 7-year player crap, etc. Basketball is WAY worse than football right now, for what it's worth. You've got NBA drafted players and international players acting as mercenaries. You've got a ridiculous squeeze on high school players where it is orders of magnitude harder for a good American HS player to earn a scholarship.

Rules need to:
1. Not allow any transfers for college players until they have spent two years in residence at the school where they sign. This will add stability at all levels.
2. Allow one penalty-free transfer for players 3 years or more out from HS.
3. Cap eligibility at 5 years NO EXCEPTIONS.
4. Massively increase direct revenue sharing cap, if you're poor that's not anyone's problem but yours.
5. Across all sports institute a rule that makes you have a 90%+ American roster (10% or less international) and only allow a max transfer ratio of 25% without a waiver.

There are so many ways to encourage stability that have nothing to do with treating players as junior NBA/NFL.
 

Ndaccountant

Old Hoss
Messages
8,370
Reaction score
5,771
Personally, I think that people are deluding themselves into thinking there will ever be any sort of truly "enforceable" salary cap. Even if they introduce an (artificially low) salary cap, the SEC will just try to cheat to get around it like they did for two decades with the NCAA. How can you possibly police 100+ schools? 4x the size of the NFL without any professional or enforcement apparatus in place to support it.

The answer, IMO, is not about turning college sports into minor league professional sports. It's about restricting transfer madness, limiting eligibility to stop the 6-year and 7-year player crap, etc. Basketball is WAY worse than football right now, for what it's worth. You've got NBA drafted players and international players acting as mercenaries. You've got a ridiculous squeeze on high school players where it is orders of magnitude harder for a good American HS player to earn a scholarship.

Rules need to:
1. Not allow any transfers for college players until they have spent two years in residence at the school where they sign. This will add stability at all levels.
2. Allow one penalty-free transfer for players 3 years or more out from HS.
3. Cap eligibility at 5 years NO EXCEPTIONS.
4. Massively increase direct revenue sharing cap, if you're poor that's not anyone's problem but yours.
5. Across all sports institute a rule that makes you have a 90%+ American roster (10% or less international) and only allow a max transfer ratio of 25% without a waiver.

There are so many ways to encourage stability that have nothing to do with treating players as junior NBA/NFL.
Teeth can come from a centralized governing body. Agree that under current construct, it would likely not work. However, if there was a centralized governing body that actually could enforce it, it would work. BTW, I dont pretend it would solve everything. Even with caps, certain franchises in professional sports are preferred for marketing opportunities. But it would at least create stability.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,443
Reaction score
1,374
How much of these transfers are about playing time and how much are really about da chedda? At least thousands of guys acknowledging they will never make money in the pros so are going for their money grab now. How many of these man child’s will wind up broke without a
Degree or in jail in 5 years? Definitely more than those who have a pro career. This flat out Wild West money grab led by agents is ruining the sport. I suppose putting boundaries limiting opportunities would be challenged in court so we will never get out beautiful game back. Will have to see what espn decides to do.
 

NDRock

Well-known member
Messages
7,489
Reaction score
5,448
Its why this version of cfb needs to be blown up. Pay people, no problem from me. But this game of musical chairs isnt good for anything except bank accounts.
Agree. These coaches need to honor the contracts they sign. Ridiculous.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
This is the main reason I'm ok with the players having free rein. Why can the coaches do what they please and the players be locked in?

A coach leaving can decimate the program.
Especially now that they can bring all the good players with them.
 

Rocketman84

Well-known member
Messages
2,425
Reaction score
1,203
Jaylen Mbakwe in the Portal after his freshman year at Alabama where he played DB before switching to WR. 100% yes please on that kid's upside, regardless of what side of the ball he wants to play on. ND recruited him out of high school, I'd be curious to see if they're interested in circling back for another look... 3 years of eligibility remaining. Was the composite #12 player nationally coming out of high school last year.
We can dream....seems like these type of players gravitate towards O$U
 

IrishinSyria

In truth lies victory
Messages
6,042
Reaction score
1,920
Personally, I think that people are deluding themselves into thinking there will ever be any sort of truly "enforceable" salary cap. Even if they introduce an (artificially low) salary cap, the SEC will just try to cheat to get around it like they did for two decades with the NCAA. How can you possibly police 100+ schools? 4x the size of the NFL without any professional or enforcement apparatus in place to support it.

The answer, IMO, is not about turning college sports into minor league professional sports. It's about restricting transfer madness, limiting eligibility to stop the 6-year and 7-year player crap, etc. Basketball is WAY worse than football right now, for what it's worth. You've got NBA drafted players and international players acting as mercenaries. You've got a ridiculous squeeze on high school players where it is orders of magnitude harder for a good American HS player to earn a scholarship.

Rules need to:
1. Not allow any transfers for college players until they have spent two years in residence at the school where they sign. This will add stability at all levels.
2. Allow one penalty-free transfer for players 3 years or more out from HS.
3. Cap eligibility at 5 years NO EXCEPTIONS.
4. Massively increase direct revenue sharing cap, if you're poor that's not anyone's problem but yours.
5. Across all sports institute a rule that makes you have a 90%+ American roster (10% or less international) and only allow a max transfer ratio of 25% without a waiver.

There are so many ways to encourage stability that have nothing to do with treating players as junior NBA/NFL.
Mostly agreement / minor quibbles with you up until 5, but hell no to that one. If international kids are better so be it, nothing wrong with going D3 or ending your athletic career if you’re not up to it.
 

IrishinSyria

In truth lies victory
Messages
6,042
Reaction score
1,920
Maybe it makes sense specifically for basketball where international players are essentially professionals but in hockey, for example, I can’t think of a single legit reason we wouldn’t want Canadian kids to be able to play.
 

jprue24

Well-known member
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
3,244
How much of these transfers are about playing time and how much are really about da chedda? At least thousands of guys acknowledging they will never make money in the pros so are going for their money grab now. How many of these man child’s will wind up broke without a
Degree or in jail in 5 years?
Definitely more than those who have a pro career. This flat out Wild West money grab led by agents is ruining the sport. I suppose putting boundaries limiting opportunities would be challenged in court so we will never get out beautiful game back. Will have to see what espn decides to do.
This point is one of the more disingenuous bullshit arguments I've seen come out of NIL/TP. Don't infantilize these young men. These are adults with agency and are responsible for their own life choices.
Who cares if they end up without a degree and broke? I know you don't really and are only using this to make a point. I'm not even going to get into you just throwing "jail" on the wall. It's disingenuous (again) to act as if an unordinary amount of ex-college athletes end up in jail.
 

arndtjc

Dee Snutzs
Messages
1,275
Reaction score
2,340


This kid is really good, a gigantic shocker around Huskerland as they were fully expecting him to be back. Would love to see ND get in on this one
 
Messages
47
Reaction score
49
Is he a DT?

Defensive Lineman:

2025 (Sophomore) Keona Davis has played in every game this season with 11 starts. He has recorded 30 tackles with 3.5 TFLs, 1.5 sacks and one pass breakup. Twenty-six of Davis' 30 tackles came in Big Ten play. Davis had three tackles against Cincinnati in the season opener.
 
Top