ND Coaching Search Megathread

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,116
Reaction score
27,373
Perhaps it's an indication of where ND wants to take it's offense moving forward.
This is the indication I think would be bizarre. If Tommy (or MF) just wants to incorporate some Air Raid concepts go visit Mumme or someone in the off-season I’m confident Tommy can pick up on it. But fully leaning into Air Raid would kind of fly in the face of TE and OL tradition. Gonna ask Harry to start recruiting certain OL and widen out his splits? Unlikely.
 

brewdog_14527

Well-known member
Messages
546
Reaction score
343
What about making Tommy Rees the TE coach, and bringing in a QB coach. Doubt it will happen, but you could use Chansey, Harry and maybe a GA. Again, doubt it would happen.
 

irishog77

NOT SINBAD's NEPHEW
Messages
7,441
Reaction score
2,206
This is the indication I think would be bizarre. If Tommy (or MF) just wants to incorporate some Air Raid concepts go visit Mumme or someone in the off-season I’m confident Tommy can pick up on it. But fully leaning into Air Raid would kind of fly in the face of TE and OL tradition. Gonna ask Harry to start recruiting certain OL and widen out his splits? Unlikely.
I think a staff could bring a TE coach with an Air Raid Offense background and it also not mean they are switching to an Air Raid Offense theirselves. A HC that prefers to run a 4-3 defense could hire a DL coach from a 3-4 system and it not mean they are changing their entire defensive philosophy.
 

Pops Freshenmeyer

Well-known member
Messages
5,112
Reaction score
2,457
This is the indication I think would be bizarre. If Tommy (or MF) just wants to incorporate some Air Raid concepts go visit Mumme or someone in the off-season I’m confident Tommy can pick up on it. But fully leaning into Air Raid would kind of fly in the face of TE and OL tradition. Gonna ask Harry to start recruiting certain OL and widen out his splits? Unlikely.
It also seems to me that the air raid shares a weakness with the triple option in that once opposing defenses focus in it loses effectiveness. Washington dominated Mike Leach's WSU teams and Jimmy Lake bragged about how they cracked the formula and WSU couldn't adjust.

So thanks but no thanks to the air raid if ND wants to take a swing at the top of CFB in bowl season.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,116
Reaction score
27,373
I think a staff could bring a TE coach with an Air Raid Offense background and it also not mean they are switching to an Air Raid Offense theirselves. A HC that prefers to run a 4-3 defense could hire a DL coach from a 3-4 system and it not mean they are changing their entire defensive philosophy.
True but what’s Parker’s advantage then? He’s not known as any huge plus developer or recruiter.
 

irishog77

NOT SINBAD's NEPHEW
Messages
7,441
Reaction score
2,206
What tight ends from 2012-16 did he screw up so badly?

Wasn't it Brian Kelly who said that they coached special teams collectively as a staff with Booker as coordinator? Notre Dame special teams have been icky even before Kelly.

Scott Booker was a punching bag for the fan base. Never got it then and I don't get it now. Glad he's in the League as a safety coach where hardly anyone even knows who he is.
1) I didn't criticize Booker. I merely pointed out your snarkiness for insinuating that he's clearly a good coach, ya know, because he's in the NFL. Even though his current position is entirely different than the one he had at ND.
2) A guy can be a bad coach in some respects, but good in others. There's a reason position coaches, coordinators, and head coaches get promoted, demoted, and reassigned all the time. Scott Booker coaching safeties in 2021 for the Titans does not mean he was necessarily a good ST or TE coach at ND.
 

StPaul_Irish

Resident Smart Ass
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3,119
Wow. They absolutely need to get this done if that's the case, provided there are no red flags and all of the money, etc. can be agreed upon. LFG.

I like Brewster for a lot of reasons, and they address a lot of the concerns of the board.

- Older/experienced
- Great recruiter
- Head coaching experience
- NFL experience
- TX, NC, FL SEC ties
 

Rogue219

Well-known member
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
1,080
1) I didn't criticize Booker. I merely pointed out your snarkiness for insinuating that he's clearly a good coach, ya know, because he's in the NFL. Even though his current position is entirely different than the one he had at ND.
2) A guy can be a bad coach in some respects, but good in others. There's a reason position coaches, coordinators, and head coaches get promoted, demoted, and reassigned all the time. Scott Booker coaching safeties in 2021 for the Titans does not mean he was necessarily a good ST or TE coach at ND.
1. Never said he's a good coach because he's in the NFL. I'm not saying he's a bad coach, though. He's coaching at the highest level after getting a start at ND where he was a young guy beginning his career.
2. I still don't know, after all these years, what it was he was so bad at with TE and ST.
 

Rogue219

Well-known member
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
1,080
I like Brewster for a lot of reasons, and they address a lot of the concerns of the board.

- Older/experienced
- Great recruiter
- Head coaching experience
- NFL experience
- TX, NC, FL SEC ties
His head coaching arc is one we've all seen before. 1-11 year one, then 7-6, 6-7 and fired at 1-6 in year four. That Year One to Year Two jump is pretty significant. I don't think those tend to happen by accident. Minnesota, at the time, was a hard place to win, but if you look at who followed him there you'll see things went pretty well. Jerry Kill won there and now PJ Fleck is winning there. Things didn't go well for Brewster at Minnesota, but he certainly left some kind of foundation for what came after.

Biggest thing he brings to the table is strengthening a strength. Notre Dame has had excellent tight ends going back to Anthony Fasano. If Brewster WANTS this job, he'd come in here with his recruiting talents and make a strong area even stronger. For a first time head coach like Marcus Freeman, strengthening a strength only fills some gaps to buy you time while you muscle up the other areas.

I think they need to do this. McCullough, Stuckey, Hiestand and Brewster is one hell of a room for Rees the other six days of the week.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,116
Reaction score
27,373
Sounds like Parker has serious steam. Hansen actually had it first yesterday and Loy hearing more today. Idk there are some hires that have some obvious doubts, this one would be my first head scratcher of the cycle.
 

NDohio

Well-known member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
3,060
I am really impressed with the quality of assistant coaches that are reaching out to MF and wanting to get on the Irish staff. Every position coach that has left since the bowl games has had an impressive line-up of candidates that want the job.
 

Pops Freshenmeyer

Well-known member
Messages
5,112
Reaction score
2,457
Sounds like Parker has serious steam. Hansen actually had it first yesterday and Loy hearing more today. Idk there are some hires that have some obvious doubts, this one would be my first head scratcher of the cycle.
I assume it's more focused on adding to the offensive staff as a whole than worrying about positional development, specifically.

He's a Co-OC of a P5 team so he seems overqualified in that sense.
 

SouthSideChiDomer

Well-known member
Messages
1,526
Reaction score
614
I assume it's more focused on adding to the offensive staff as a whole than worrying about positional development, specifically.

He's a Co-OC of a P5 team so he seems overqualified in that sense.
Eh, he also was just demoted and it seems fans wanted him gone. Just from tweets it also seems like Penn State fans were happy to see him go when he left PSU for WVU.
 

Huntr

24 Karat Shamrock
Messages
7,503
Reaction score
10,427
Parker, it is. He's good too, but would have loved to seen Brewster.
 

Rogue219

Well-known member
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
1,080
Parker and Freeman were at Purdue together according to the Wikipedia
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,116
Reaction score
27,373
Didn’t interview anyone else per Loy. Again scratching my head here. Tommy supposed to have full autonomy and we hired MF’s friend with no other interviews? I’m digging myself into a negative stance but just don’t get this one yet.
 

Rogue219

Well-known member
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
1,080
Eh, he also was just demoted and it seems fans wanted him gone. Just from tweets it also seems like Penn State fans were happy to see him go when he left PSU for WVU.

LOL. He was there for one season. Must have been pretty bad. They went 11-2 and the Broncos drafted KJ Hamler in the second round.
 

irish o'phile

Well-known member
Messages
1,132
Reaction score
303
He has a lot of experience with recruiting and the nuances of running a team. ND needs some people like that On staff. It’s hard to pin his strength in terms of regional recruiting. He’s been all over the place, but is from the South.
 

NDRock

Well-known member
Messages
7,489
Reaction score
5,448
Didn’t interview anyone else per Loy. Again scratching my head here. Tommy supposed to have full autonomy and we hired MF’s friend with no other interviews? I’m digging myself into a negative stance but just don’t get this one yet.
Seems crazy to give full autonomy to any of your coordinators regarding hiring. Maybe that seemed like a good idea to MF when he was a DC. He probably realized quickly that he’s the HC and these hirings will ultimately dictate his success/failure. That’s how I would feel anyway.

Of course, TR may be perfectly happy with the hiring. I’m sure at the very least he has input in the decisions.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,116
Reaction score
27,373
When you had someone with years of bonafide TE development and elite recruiting there for the taking, and you don’t even interview him Parker better be a hit because that feels like a tough known quantity to just call off
 

fightingirish26

Well-known member
Messages
3,906
Reaction score
1,916
Hiring a guy who was co-OC at WVU sounds intriguing.

But he has what, 2 years of TE experience?Definitely strange that he was the only interview.
 

benneboy

And I own every kind of classic car!
Messages
1,250
Reaction score
1,281
He has a lot of experience with recruiting and the nuances of running a team. ND needs some people like that On staff. It’s hard to pin his strength in terms of regional recruiting. He’s been all over the place, but is from the South.
Yeah, that all kinda sounds like a worse version of Brewster.
 
Top