phgreek
New member
- Messages
- 6,956
- Reaction score
- 433
Totally agree, but the fact remains that Manti did embellish the story, and he allowed it to snowball. I am certainly not arguing that that makes him a bad guy. I love the guy. I just don't believe we're doing him any favors by making excuses for him or not admitting what level of responsibility he actually does have here. I really do feel terrible for him, but he also bears at least some responsibility for allowing the story to become as big as it is.
I understand there is likely some point where Manti lied. I think no one can assume he lied about any aspect of the said relationship until he knew it was a hoax. By that I mean we will never know what he/she/it told him, and if he was simply parroting that info.
When he knew...I still think that point in time is hard to determine. Lets assume anything after Jack verified w/ investigators the thing was a hoax. Any time before that...mmmm...I don't think you can say with certainty. So we are talking about roughly a two week period where it was clear this thing was a hoax...yes?
Even when he knew it was a hoax (in that two week period) I thought there was concern this thing would end with extortion, and they considered playing it out...how long did that decision take...what was it? I would say the extortion angle would certainly necessitate carying on the "story"...and if he "lied" he did so to further a criminal case...can't really judge a guy for that.
If they all decided to dump the extortion idea, were there other investigations happening which still necesitated carrying on the "story"...for instance, when SHTF from deadspin...accounts dropped, were recreated, copied...whats that do to viability as evidence...these guys Jack hired were likely computer forensic guys...did they keep going...did the Feds, or another private company retained by the Teos pick up the investigation...if so they'd all say keep it going...more evidence is better, and its easier to complete a computer subpeona, and all the forensic support to make it evidence if the account is still live...yes?
In the absence of Manti saying he just lied because he was freaked out, embarassed, looking out for the team...hard to say what motivated him to say what he said in that two week period...but I'm expecting we'll know from the man here real soon.
EDIT: well, and as far as saying he met her...I think he lied there...we all know why, or likely why. But hey if I can forgive a president for lying about a nobber, I can forgive a college student for claiming he met someone.
Last edited: