Its not that black and white. We both know a kid can go to Michigan and get an excellent education if they want to. I don't want to get into all of this though, people are going to believe what they want to believe.
That's a good call. FWIW, this topic has been discussed ad nauseum on here. There are a couple undeniable facts though that might better explain what people are getting at:
1. Yes, you can absolutely get a good education at just about any top 50 school in the country. Exceptions to the rule (see: Myron Rolle) have proved that. But most football factory schools tend to encourage their athletes away from focusing on a valuable degree/education in order to instead focus on football. I'll give you three quick examples:
-Michigan football players being encouraged to enroll in worthless degree programs despite Michigan's strong academic reputation.
-As noted during in one of those exposes during the whole Cam Newton pay-for-play scandal, former Auburn players went on camera and spoke extensively on how coaches told them explicitly that football was their #1 priority and not academics.
-Cal's incredibly weak admissions standards and horrid graduation rate despite being a top 20 school.
The emphasis at all of these schools is keeping kids eligible. Only at a very select few schools do football players get pushed to get a valuable degree that will help them post-graduation in a career field. So... to re-quote what you're saying... "We both know a kid can go to Michigan and get an excellent education
if they want to." is completely true. But statistics show very clearly that if you put someone in an environment where education isn't priority it is highly unlikely that will happen.