SMU Postgame

IrishFanForever23

Well-known member
Messages
1,354
Reaction score
773
Carr has flirted with throwing some bad picks. If he would’ve thrown it deeper and to the outside, I think Gilbert has a huge play. Instead, he didn’t get enough on it and left it inside.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,644
If this was 42-21 instead 24-3 there would be far fewer complaints, even though I’d find that result more concerning
I'm glad someone else feels this way. If you tell me our final margin of victory, I would almost always take the lower offensive score if it meant the defense was holding the other team to less than a touchdown.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,644


Think this is important when we are talking about his “sloppiness”
Notre Dame apparel
Notre Dame apparel
Notre Dame apparel

He definitely seems to lose focus a bit in the 2H of blow outs, or games that are on their way to blow out territory. For the most part, in the playoffs that shouldn't be an issue. But I suppose, I wouldn't hate having to find out.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,815
Reaction score
1,633
Good: Traore, Sanders, Moore, O’Brien, KVA

Meh: Run game, 2H pass game, Christian Gray


On the natural Wake comparison, people really need to understand game script. Wake took over in SMU territory 3 times in the 1H. Credit WF for getting 4th down stops and turnovers but that played an extremely large factor in it getting out of hand. SMU - similar to the Purdue gameplan - also is a top tempo team in the country that completely abandoned that against us and shortened the 1H. Lashlee played not to get blown out. Against Wake he played to win. Throw in multiple drives starting within their own 10 and you have an entirely different game script.

Just felt like SMU was begging for Notre Dame to burry them, but they didn’t want to for some reason. The offense left a lot on the table, imo.
Denbrock and Carr left points on the table. Denbrock with his playcalling and Carr with his poor decisions and passing.
 

Dizzyphil

Well-known member
Messages
4,369
Reaction score
1,776
I guess I look at the whole 'package'... Not to say that there could have been another 7-17 more points scored... But the Irish won by 21. Held SMU to a FG. Beat the spread.

Posts a month ago from some were, 'a win is a win is a win'...

But now a win is different per se?

On to Syracuse boys!!!
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,815
Reaction score
1,633
O’Brian looked good at moments but not when he whiffed in the open field on his tackle to stop a first down. Talich would not have whiffed.

Why do we pass on 2nd & 1 or 3rd & 2?! Carr made lousy decisions in the second half throwing into double coverage when we have some guys wide open?! I remember sling camp 2025 and the feedback was he struggles to check down and take what is there. He does that all the time. He was made to look good by some great catches tonight. His attempts at running stunk. He had a first down just don’t dive. Results in a punt twice. We were able to run at will against him and get we let CJ throw downfield without success. CJ is not getting invited to NYC. He is running an offense full of weapons and protection. I think other QBs could have us at 10-1 or 11-0 frankly. Just like other OCs could have us certainly scoring more than 24 points tonight.
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,735
Reaction score
6,823
O’Brian looked good at moments but not when he whiffed in the open field on his tackle to stop a first down. Talich would not have whiffed.

Why do we pass on 2nd & 1 or 3rd & 2?! Carr made lousy decisions in the second half throwing into double coverage when we have some guys wide open?! I remember sling camp 2025 and the feedback was he struggles to check down and take what is there. He does that all the time. He was made to look good by some great catches tonight. His attempts at running stunk. He had a first down just don’t dive. Results in a punt twice. We were able to run at will against him and get we let CJ throw downfield without success. CJ is not getting invited to NYC. He is running an offense full of weapons and protection. I think other QBs could have us at 10-1 or 11-0 frankly. Just like other OCs could have us certainly scoring more than 24 points tonight.
Fair critique but all things considered, he played a helluva game. Led the team in tackles and looked good in pass coverage despite SMU picking on him after Talich went out. Best of all…kid is a freshman. I think he shows up big in the future
 

GTB

Active member
Messages
223
Reaction score
172
O’Brian looked good at moments but not when he whiffed in the open field on his tackle to stop a first down. Talich would not have whiffed.

Why do we pass on 2nd & 1 or 3rd & 2?! Carr made lousy decisions in the second half throwing into double coverage when we have some guys wide open?! I remember sling camp 2025 and the feedback was he struggles to check down and take what is there. He does that all the time. He was made to look good by some great catches tonight. His attempts at running stunk. He had a first down just don’t dive. Results in a punt twice. We were able to run at will against him and get we let CJ throw downfield without success. CJ is not getting invited to NYC. He is running an offense full of weapons and protection. I think other QBs could have us at 10-1 or 11-0 frankly. Just like other OCs could have us certainly scoring more than 24 points tonight.
need some more cheese for your whine?
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,702
Reaction score
1,576
O’Brian looked good at moments but not when he whiffed in the open field on his tackle to stop a first down. Talich would not have whiffed.

Why do we pass on 2nd & 1 or 3rd & 2?! Carr made lousy decisions in the second half throwing into double coverage when we have some guys wide open?! I remember sling camp 2025 and the feedback was he struggles to check down and take what is there. He does that all the time. He was made to look good by some great catches tonight. His attempts at running stunk. He had a first down just don’t dive. Results in a punt twice. We were able to run at will against him and get we let CJ throw downfield without success. CJ is not getting invited to NYC. He is running an offense full of weapons and protection. I think other QBs could have us at 10-1 or 11-0 frankly. Just like other OCs could have us certainly scoring more than 24 points tonight.
Joey flat out made the choice to avoid contact. Please God, do not let Joey anywhere near the field on any down that matters.
 

FDNYIrish1

Well-known member
Messages
3,165
Reaction score
5,547
Zero complaints. We are in a great era of Notre Dame football lads. CJ was a bit off tonight but so what. Still threw for over 3 bills. I’m still in awe of that defensive performance by Traore. That kid was an absolute beast making plays everywhere. It ok to nitpick but what a great time to be a fan. Keep this train rolling.
 

OrlaNDomer

Well-known member
Messages
794
Reaction score
744
Except that Bama's SoS actually stinks and they have zero quality wins + multiple losses.

Bama's ranked wins look worse every week. UK shouldn't be ranked (7-4). South Carolina shouldn't be ranked (6-5). LSU shouldn't be ranked (6-5). They will end the season 10-2 with zero ranked wins, but the committee will count Miss St as a big ranked win "because their star QB played that game" completely disregarding that even including that Miss St game as a ranked win it is still the ND resume of last year.
 

RudyVerse

Well-known member
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
3,268
Im not sure what you can do with Talich now down, but something has to be done about Schuler. He’s a total non factor. On the Sanders pick, they replayed it and the TE had 10 yards on Schuler just running a straight line. Kirby and others won’t miss this. It needs to be Tae, O’Brien, and maybe even someone else in playoffs when it matters. It sucks but he’s repeatedly the weakest link.
 

Veritate Duce Progredi

A man gotta have a code
Messages
9,557
Reaction score
5,742
Im not sure what you can do with Talich now down, but something has to be done about Schuler. He’s a total non factor. On the Sanders pick, they replayed it and the TE had 10 yards on Schuler just running a straight line. Kirby and others won’t miss this. It needs to be Tae, O’Brien, and maybe even someone else in playoffs when it matters. It sucks but he’s repeatedly the weakest link.
I'm going to wait for people with better understanding of what was happening but it looked like they had 'bracketed' that part of the field with the high safety and Shuler underneath. I think if the QB looks at the TE, the high safety breaks on him.

But I don't really know ball like some of you.
 

notredomer23

Staph Member
Messages
18,623
Reaction score
19,736
Im not sure what you can do with Talich now down, but something has to be done about Schuler. He’s a total non factor. On the Sanders pick, they replayed it and the TE had 10 yards on Schuler just running a straight line. Kirby and others won’t miss this. It needs to be Tae, O’Brien, and maybe even someone else in playoffs when it matters. It sucks but he’s repeatedly the weakest link.

He hasn’t been right since UNC. You gotta hope that 4 weeks off can fix whatever’s going on there
 

Green Mountains

Active member
Messages
252
Reaction score
228
Any word on the Talich injury? Watching, he looked at the back of his ankle like it was something weird with the heel of his shoe, then he realized it was not the shoe. That says Achilles to me.
 

Veritate Duce Progredi

A man gotta have a code
Messages
9,557
Reaction score
5,742
What does it take for Notre Dame to force a holding call? And how is ND among the least penalized teams but they always get penalized more at home (ACC refs?). I'm really done with ACC officiating, I think they are very, very bad at their jobs.

We had guys being thrown down, multiple times, way after the whistle and we didn't see a single flag. ND was most often on the receiving end. We had guys held and it was egregious and never called.

Meanwhile, Traore gets a horsecollar call that I think was an abuse of the rule. I don't care if a guy has a hold of the back, we've seen them say it's not a horsecollar if you don't pull down from the back of the shoulder pads. Traore just tossed this poor SOB into his sideline and they extend the drive.
 
Top