A high scoring offense will absolutely help, but if they aren't consistently on those top QB prospects and other skill talent, they aren't coming to ND, particularly now that nil is a factor. The days of "ND recruits itself" for those skill positions were over 30 years ago.
It's my second biggest critique of Golden, next to the putrid red zone D. We simply haven't heard enough of him making an impact on the trail for difference makers. It was possible to an extent, due to the MF being a defensive guy and having established relationships with the '23 class, but certainly needs to improve.
Their names are Freeman, Coach DMC, Stuckey, and Bowden. Considering that it's very likely, whoever they hire, won't be here long term, we'd rather have the relationships connected to Freeman, Bowden, etc. It's precisely what they pitched Carr from the beginning.
The next phase of Freeman's evolution as HC is proving/convincing the prospects, their parents, coaches, etc. that he's the next Dabo, Saban, etc. He does that by bringing in a fresh OC that puts up impressive results right away. He's now the guy that hires the guy. It cements his place at the top of food chain of HC's. That is a bigger sell than a swaggy OC. If this next OC bombs on the field with a Heisman hopeful QB, it doesn't matter how much of a dawg on the trail the next OC is. It'll be an uphill battle trying to convince these young men that Freeman will be at ND long. Another 8-9 win regular season is not going to cut it with this group.