scUM Hater
Live to see scUM lose.
- Messages
- 2,438
- Reaction score
- 145
I understand being ticked about the Te'o coverage, but this isn't something that happens all the time at Bama. Since the summer of '08 when Saban cleaned out the riff-raff from the previous staff's players, these would be our first serious incidents, and it's getting plenty of coverage locally and nationally.
Looks like they used a stolen credit/debit card to commit theft and were in possession of an unlicensed gun when doing so. One of these guys (Calloway) was busted in '11 for misdemeanor possession. He's a goner for sure. Depending on the circumstances, the other three probably are also. I hate to see anybody be this stupid and waste the opportunity they had, but they made their choice. Now they'll suffer the consequences.
These are the first incidents? What were these?
Calloway arrested for weed.
Rolando hitting people with their car.
Jeremy Elder pulling a gun on a student and robbing them.
Jimmy Johns selling cocaine in the athletic parking lot.
Aaron Douglas arrested for DUI.
Mark Barron arrested for lying to police.
Alabama assistant coach arrested for pot.
Simeon Castille arrested on disorderly conduct.
Brandon Deaderick arrested for criminal mischief, resisting arrest, and giving the police a false name.
Brandon Fanney - disorderly conduct.
Roy Upchurch - diorderly conduct.
Courtney Upshaw arrested for domestic violence.
Nico Johnson arrested in high school for verbal harassment. (Dee Liner)
Or by "first incidents" were you referring to felony specific crimes?
Bingo. This helps Saban purge players! This is the blessing he's been waiting for!
Saw this in the comment section on yahoo and it made me spit out my juice lol
They were also charged with fraud.....for posing as students ha ha
Sorry for lengthy post.
In full disclosure...new poster here who did join during the Manti Teo saga. I commented then that however the story turned out, that ND was bigger than the episode, etc. I did not join to poke fun at ND...I tried to reassure ND posters that most folks with common sense understand that our programs will experience bad times but it does not define our programs...hopefully.
As to why Manti's story was covered so widely? My honest guess is due to his celebrity status as the ND leader and a Heisman candidate influenced the amount of coverage. Also, the story was so unusual it had people eager to find out what was going on. Yes, the recent Alabama arrests are much more serious than what happened with Manti.
Alabama's recent arrests involved no one of national celebrity. These kids were backups, not Heisman candidates...thereby not as appealing to casual readers. And as serious as these offenses are they are much more common in society than Manti's story...sad yes.
What story do we think would grab a non football fan's attention? If your job was to increase readers, traffic, etc. and they both happened on the same day, which would you lead with? Manti's story is obviously the bigger seller. Fair? Absolutely not.
I hope Manti goes on to a great NFL career and as much as I have been raised to dislike ND...I hope they stay at the top. College football is more entertaining with the ND's and Bama's playing for national championships.
As far the 4 from Alabama. I am confident they will never step foot on campus as a student or player again. I hope they are punished severly enough that they make better choices in the future. If that means jail time, good. And I say that after spending several years helping one of the players we are talking about. He never showed signs of this behavior growing up. I would have given him the keys to my house and told him to go get something for me and would have never worried about what he was doing. I have known him since he was in 4th grade. But this act is severe enough that even if it is a 1st time it must be dealt with harshly. I hope that the punishment will allow him to one day make another go at his dream of playing in the NFL. But if he is unable...he has only himself to blame.
Roll Tide and I hope we both meet in the national championship game again in the near future.
And I certainly think you have some valid points there. However, until the incident this week, Bama hasn't had any serious issues with players getting into trouble in almost 5 years. That's been my basic point in all of this: since shortly after his first season when Saban got rid of the problem players he'd inherited, we've had no serious incidents and only a small handful of minor ones until this week.
Not to open up another can of worms or start a fight, but during that time, ND's football team has had more total arrests and more arrests for serious crimes than we have until this week. And both schools are doing better than most other programs. Unfortunately, it happens everywhere.
Not even going to get into the issue of whether these guys belong on campus- I haven't seen their ACT/SAT scores or transcripts...
However, I wish there was some forgiveness/bend possible in the discipline. ND was able to forgive Michael Floyd three times for alcohol offenses- the last one was actually pretty terrible. But as a result, he went from what some would call a "punk" attitude to a moral as well as a football leader. Bama probably can't get away with that- too many arrests to risk looking soft/setting a precedent/different type of person (I'd argue that in general, the average alabama player needs more rules than the average ND player). So, sadly, these boys will be thrown out on their butts (deservedly, dont get me wrong) when a second chance could've been all the difference, whether they ever saw the field or not.
Amazing how fast this dropped off the ESPN.com front page.
Manti gets duped, ND gets dragged through the coals and Te'o is one of the most hated athletes in America.
Alabama's players are implicated in a PED scandal and beating students unconscious for fun and it's relatively no big deal.
Awesome.
Not even going to get into the issue of whether these guys belong on campus- I haven't seen their ACT/SAT scores or transcripts...
However, I wish there was some forgiveness/bend possible in the discipline. ND was able to forgive Michael Floyd three times for alcohol offenses- the last one was actually pretty terrible. But as a result, he went from what some would call a "punk" attitude to a moral as well as a football leader. Bama probably can't get away with that- too many arrests to risk looking soft/setting a precedent/different type of person (I'd argue that in general, the average alabama player needs more rules than the average ND player). So, sadly, these boys will be thrown out on their butts (deservedly, dont get me wrong) when a second chance could've been all the difference, whether they ever saw the field or not.
Are we trying to be tooooo nice here about this subject or what. The 'Mickey Mouse' stuff that has happened at Notre Dame is pale in comparison to this. Please dont tell me any different. Please dont insult my intelligence. This is pre thought/pre determined/ and absolutely wrong. Please dont throw it out there that the girl that took her life and the incredible accident with the student manager compare to this. Those were tradgedies of major proportions but not pre thought feelings of entitlement acts. I can guarantee you that kids like this do not get into Notre Dame. The backround check and research on the kid is just not there at some schools. Are you telling me that any coach cant see this coming with certain kids when he is recruiting them. If he cant then his common sense factor is ZERO. The time has come to see what the %$#@ is going on here-$$$$ for the conference $$$$ for the team. These guys are not college students they are hired football mercenaries to win football games. Lets stop pussy footing around here and just call it what it is.
Be careful of too much self-righteous claims of purity and lack of problems at ND or any other school. I'm not trying to slam ND, but you've had some serious issues also. Charges of sexual assault and even gang rape have been levied against players more than once in the past decade or so, players threatening and intimidating victims into silence, the school failing to adequately deal with the problem, and a fanbase more than happy to pretend it hasn't happened.
I can tell you what the perception of ND is outside your fanbase: a good school with better than average behavior from your athletes, but far from the lily white purity most of you claim and want to believe. Most people outside your fanbase think ND sweeps these issues under the rug, stonewalls the victims, covers its butt to protect its image and team, and claims nothing happened, and that your fanbase is all too willing to bury their heads in the sand, turn a blind eye, pretend none of it could ever happen at your school, and shout down anyone who says otherwise.
Not much. The girl liked Upshaw. They'd been out, but weren't seriously involved. They were at a party, but not as a couple, and Upshaw was talking to another girl. First girl didn't like that, got mad and slapped him unexpectedly and very hard, then ran. He had a few seconds of just instinctive anger & shock and grabbed her from behind and started to force her to the ground, but turned her loose first. She turned and swung at him again and he shoved her away. A cop saw all of it except the initial slap and arrested them both. It went to court and both admitted everything that happened, the cop's story jived with theirs, the girl's dad said it was just a stupid spat and the girl shouldn't have hit him, and Upshaw expressed sincere embarrassment and regret, so the judge sent them both to anger management classes and dismissed the case.
Be careful of too much self-righteous claims of purity and lack of problems at ND or any other school. I'm not trying to slam ND, but you've had some serious issues also. Charges of sexual assault and even gang rape have been levied against players more than once in the past decade or so, players threatening and intimidating victims into silence, the school failing to adequately deal with the problem, and a fanbase more than happy to pretend it hasn't happened.
I can tell you what the perception of ND is outside your fanbase: a good school with better than average behavior from your athletes, but far from the lily white purity most of you claim and want to believe. Most people outside your fanbase think ND sweeps these issues under the rug, stonewalls the victims, covers its butt to protect its image and team, and claims nothing happened, and that your fanbase is all too willing to bury their heads in the sand, turn a blind eye, pretend none of it could ever happen at your school, and shout down anyone who says otherwise.
Be careful of too much self-righteous claims of purity and lack of problems at ND or any other school. I'm not trying to slam ND, but you've had some serious issues also. Charges of sexual assault and even gang rape have been levied against players more than once in the past decade or so, players threatening and intimidating victims into silence, the school failing to adequately deal with the problem, and a fanbase more than happy to pretend it hasn't happened.
I can tell you what the perception of ND is outside your fanbase: a good school with better than average behavior from your athletes, but far from the lily white purity most of you claim and want to believe. Most people outside your fanbase think ND sweeps these issues under the rug, stonewalls the victims, covers its butt to protect its image and team, and claims nothing happened, and that your fanbase is all too willing to bury their heads in the sand, turn a blind eye, pretend none of it could ever happen at your school, and shout down anyone who says otherwise.
2 things. First, since when is a rational reaction to a girl slapping you in the face, grabbing her by the hair and forcing her to the ground. Then he shoved her away. Forget for a minute the obvious size and strength difference, but what kind of man has that initial reaction? A women slaps and pushes you and you say that's an instinctive reaction? Wrong.
To revisit the first point. What are the chances that intimidation led to the dismissal? My guess is there is a fairly good chance. You think a girl who gets into it w a football star and pursues it is going to be applauded as she walks down the street wherever this happened? I don't. No man of any character pulls a woman down by the hair then shoves her away. For those that disagree w the majority of this fan base, I say to them, don't waste your time here.
You're starting to go down a pretty heavy road here homeboy.
Take your ****ing medicine, you recruited goons... wish them gone from your program and move on. Take your "Yeah but you guys do it too" to an Alabama website where you can jerk each other off. Nobody's buying it here.
I'm not trying to deflect from what the Bama players did. No Bama fan condones their actions. This isn't an attempt to say, "Yeah, well ND does bad stuff too" to deflect from what the Bama players did. Nor is it any sort of attempt to smear ND. I'm pointing out that all the "At ND our players are saints and never do anything serious" stuff is BS. There is irrefutable evidence that when it's happened, other players have tried to intimidate and threaten the victims into remaining silent, and some very strong evidence that the spin machine has then smeard the victims to diminish their claims.
Your players have gotten in serious trouble. They have gotten arrested about as frequently as at other schools. There have been VERY serious charges levied against ND players and accusations by victims and the media that the school's taken less than adequate steps to address the issues and appears to have all too often been a lot more interested in protecting the players and the school's image than anything else. I don't hate ND and I genuinely am not trying to smear your school, but don't give me that holier than thou, self-righteous, our program is pure and all our players are choirboys routine either. You have a fine school with plenty of upstanding players, but pretending there haven't been some serious issues just like at other schools is just naive and a fantasy.
I'm not trying to deflect from what the Bama players did. No Bama fan condones their actions. This isn't an attempt to say, "Yeah, well ND does bad stuff too" to deflect from what the Bama players did. Nor is it any sort of attempt to smear ND. I'm pointing out that all the "At ND our players are saints and never do anything serious" stuff is BS. There is irrefutable evidence that when it's happened, other players have tried to intimidate and threaten the victims into remaining silent, and some very strong evidence that the spin machine has then smeard the victims to diminish their claims.
Your players have gotten in serious trouble. They have gotten arrested about as frequently as at other schools. There have been VERY serious charges levied against ND players and accusations by victims and the media that the school's taken less than adequate steps to address the issues and appears to have all too often been a lot more interested in protecting the players and the school's image than anything else. I don't hate ND and I genuinely am not trying to smear your school, but don't give me that holier than thou, self-righteous, our program is pure and all our players are choirboys routine either. You have a fine school with plenty of upstanding players, but pretending there haven't been some serious issues just like at other schools is just naive and a fantasy.
I'm not trying to deflect from what the Bama players did. No Bama fan condones their actions. This isn't an attempt to say, "Yeah, well ND does bad stuff too" to deflect from what the Bama players did. Nor is it any sort of attempt to smear ND. I'm pointing out that all the "At ND our players are saints and never do anything serious" stuff is BS. There is irrefutable evidence that when it's happened, other players have tried to intimidate and threaten the victims into remaining silent, and some very strong evidence that the spin machine has then smeard the victims to diminish their claims.
Your players have gotten in serious trouble. They have gotten arrested about as frequently as at other schools. There have been VERY serious charges levied against ND players and accusations by victims and the media that the school's taken less than adequate steps to address the issues and appears to have all too often been a lot more interested in protecting the players and the school's image than anything else. I don't hate ND and I genuinely am not trying to smear your school, but don't give me that holier than thou, self-righteous, our program is pure and all our players are choirboys routine either. You have a fine school with plenty of upstanding players, but pretending there haven't been some serious issues just like at other schools is just naive and a fantasy.
The first bold is an objective falsehood. This is exactly what you are doing. People attack Alabama and you say ND isn't pure either. What a joke! And what a logical fallacy: the old "your mother" fallacy.
The second bold -- please provide the irrefutable evidence of the "intimidation." I've never seen that. Seriously, I've heard that alleged in the anti-Catholic and anti-Notre Dame media and in fringe leftwing publications like The Nation, but I've never seen "irrefutable" evidence. On the second point, I am not saying you are wrong; I would just like to see it.
You're fighting a losing battle. Unless you have read every article, court transcript and spent time on campus talking to people I would suggest you drop this like a hot potato.
You have the same problems as every other school.