Couple of Things

TheTurningPoint

New member
Messages
2,883
Reaction score
662
QB - Everett Golson is going to have a coming out party all season long, Lord willing. He is getting the fellas in the right sets and making adjustments pre-snap. He is oozing confidence, and just the way he carries himself, one can tell that is a confident young man. Golson is embracing the leadership role for not just the offense, but the entire team. That is truly what ND has been missing since Clausen left, a QB that will get the team to follow him. Coach Martin was going to install a series of hand signals pre snap, but decided to wait until Fall Camp....Golson took it upon himself to get with his guys, and installed it himself. Blew away the staff when they rolled it out. Rees is still looking like Rees. Kid has peaked, but is wise. Knows the offense, and where to go with the all. He just cant make all the throws and obviously is limited athletically, but is still a good option for a series or limited plays if Golson gets banged up, or loses his helmet lol. Hendrix, actually looks very well. I truly think the light has come on for the young man, but may be a year or two too late. I would feel confident with him running things, if Golson did get hurt for a extended period of time. Zaire def looks like a college qb, a little bigger than expected. Still somewhat of a slow release, and doesnt have his release points down yet, but thats expected for a EE freshman. He seems to know what they have given him playbook wise fairly well. From looking at Zaire and Gunner, Zaire is a little ahead of where Gunner was at this point last year. He looks comfortable out there, and plays with confidence. Just needs to understand he cant learn it all in 3 months, and get himself ahead of other QBs in his class.

RB - GA3 looks and plays like the GA3 that showed up in the spring game last year. He looks like a college RB and the weight is def helping his game. He has enough power to accelerate out of his cuts and is running inside the tackles with a lot of confidence. Still is a little light on his feet, but theres few perfect backs. If he keeps adding good weight, I think he will put himself on the map this year. Few kids at this level have that speed, and size. He still needs a little work on his ball skills in the pass game. He is more than able to catch in the flats, but he struggled when he was trying to get in the seam. Cam McDaniel is a more than serviceable back, and I think ND can win their fair of games if he was the starter. He's a back that does everything good, and nothing great. I was very impressed with him running up inside the tackles. A couple plays it looked like a 2-3 yard gain, then all of sudden the pile was 8-10 yards down the field. He plays the ball in the air better than GA3, but does struggle to get depth on routes. He's a kid that will excel in the screen game, get him in space with some blocker, and he will use his vision and agility to get the ball up the field. Will Mahone looks like he does have a little way to go. He seems light on his feet and doesnt run with as much confidence as the other two yet. Mahone def looks the part of a college rb, just needs to keep getting his lower body stronger. He moves really well, but just needs to run harder and keep his legs moving.

WR - Davaris looks like a future All American. He is going hard each rep and does many things with ease. He has improved getting himself in position to make plays on 50-50 balls and with his athleticism, I see him winning most of those come fall. He has really improved his all around game and isnt thinking too much out there. Fine tuning his route running, getting stronger, and run game are going to be keys for him. TJ, is just Mr. Reliable. I didnt see anything too glaring from him where he really improved. He is just a jack of all trades, and I think he can be one of Golsons "go to" guys. In my opinion he needs to stay outside where he can work the sideline and use his deceptive speed. The NFL game suits him as a slot more than Kellys offense and I think ND prefers him outside. Chris Brown looks the part of a college WR, and that kid just looks fast in everything. You can really tell he has worked hard at coming in and out of his breaks to use that speed to his advantage. His ball skills have been at a high level coming out of high school, and a couple times he got deep, he made the catch look effortless. If he can get to 200 by fall, I think that would be huge for him. He was in limited reps and i supect he wont get a ton in the spring game, but he looks night and day compared to last fall. Onwualu looks like a JR in college and I would be absolutely shocked if he didnt get major reps come fall. He was working inside and outside, struggled a little getting off press, but he is getting used to the college game. Once he starts using his body and strength to get off the line, he will be well on his way. I think he is similiar to Golden Tate, where he has such a strong lower body and plays like a rb. I dont think he has top end speed like Golden, but he is going to break his fair share of tackles. Robinson, literally catches everything. When people say a Wr has soft hands, Corey Robinson has soft hands. He really knows how to play the fade/jump ball with his size, and I was impressed with his speed for his size. As of April 2013, he is a kid that is going to play outside the numbers, and redzone situations. I cant see him running a route inside numbers bc he does lack the speed/strength to get the into the seam right now. This kid has the potential to be really special and set some records by the time he leaves. As of right now, I really do see him getting a chance to play early but like I said in situational work. CJ Prosise may have been the surprise of practice for me. He has some serious wheels and is a big *** kid. He gets off the line very well for someone that has played slot for the time he has, and works inside the numbers well. He needs to work on improving his catching bc on 2 plays I saw, he had smoked the db, but let them fall right through his hands. On one play, Golson was rolling right and running out of real estate, Prosise found the soft spot and out ran Russell about 60yards to the house. Russell was keeping up with Stills, Lee, Woods last year, so you know the speed he has. Fine tuning all the little things and getting good work in during 7-on-7s are going to be huge for him. Daniel Smith still looks to be a better blocker than route runner. Id love for the light to come on bc he has the abilities to be a threat, but right now he is just a hell of a run blocker.

TE - Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU. He really gets in and out of his breaks well, and uses his body well to get depth. Hands are better than I thought, and I mean thats just a large human playing TE. Blocking looked improved and if he gets that down, the sky is the limit. A little different TE than Eifert, where he is more of a bruiser and not quite as athletic, but I think he can be just as productive. Koyack looked night and day compared to last fall. He was playing with confidence, and playing physical. He may not be the thread Welch, Niklas are in the pass game, but he is more than capable of making plays. He just needs to continue to work on the run game and becoming more physical. Welch has a hell of a set of hands on him. I didnt see him in the run game too much so I cant really tell you one way or anther on that. He does seem to be a little hesistant and not trusting his knee 100% yet, but he is def able to play. Heuerman. Kid has a motor lol. He needs work in the weight room and the run game. But he is at a position where he is getting compared to Eifert/Niklas as a early enrollee. A year with Longo will make him into a different kid physically this time next year. He catches well, and routes looked good. He plays physical and with a chip on his shoulder and I think he will have no problem at ND over his career.

Oline - As whole, I will bet the house this line is better than last year. They are physical and just look damn intimidating. Nick Martin is going to make a name for himself, and if Prosise wasnt the surprise of the offense, it'd be Nick. He was holding his own vs Nix and def isnt backing down from a dogfight. He did pancake Nix in the 11-on-11 session, then the next play Nix absolutely destroyed him, but Martin just stood up to him and went about his business the next play. From a good source, Martin is already playing at a level better than Cave. Experience and mentally, I am sure he isn't there yet, but his athleticism is going to be able to take the Oline to higher levels. Zach Martin and Chris Watt were Zach Martin and Chris Watt. Physical, reliable, leading, I mean theres not really much that needs to be said there. Hanratty is going to be the weak link of the Oline, but if you look at the Oline its really a compliment to how good the Oline is. I think that RG will be more productive than last year and he plays hard and physical. Fine tuning himself for the fall is the biggest emphasis for him. Being able to deal with fatigue and the course of the season is key for him as well, as he hasnt gotten live reps yet. Lombard looks great physically and has gotten stronger. He seems a step quicker too, whether that is work with Longo, or just experience and confidence. Like Kelly said in his presser, if the right side can play each week, this team will soar to new heights in the run game. Ronnie Stanley is a massive human. He looked pretty damn good in the reps he got.


DBOYZ

Dline - Im not sure what I can say here other than I'd love to see a better starting Dline. Nix has really filled out his upper body and looks like a new IrishChocolate. He looks like a Vince Wolfork clone out there. Tuitt looked good and I mean its Tuitt lol. Day has def put time in with Longo and he has filled out. Springmann was working inside and outside and if he keeps getting stronger then he can really fill in inside when he is there. Jarron Jones looks the part for damn sure. He struggled when it wasnt a goalline situation, but in goalline he filled the gap and held his ground. I think he will get spot PT this year in short yardage but just will continue to mature physically and get stronger to play his position. Utupo looked actually pretty good setting the edge. He lacks a little size (well i guess depends on what team you are on) but was holding his own. Stockon is def undersized, but his motor has come on so the effort is there. I dont think theres a lot of depth there right now, but I will be curious to see the development of the kids that come in once summer rolls around. Losing Hounshell hurts bc thats a big athletic kid that fills space well.

LB- Grace has command of his defense. I hesistate to say this, but he may fit the defense better than Manti. Manti is obviously one of the better LBs to play at ND and Grace hasnt taken a snap. But this kid sideline to sideline is unreal. He is going to be better in pass co and he plays the run well. He is going to play in space better than Manti just bc he is more athletic and just has good senses in the pass game. I dont think he will ever have 7INTs in a season but I dont think he will get smoked on wheel routes. Literally the sky is the limit for him and he just needs to keep progressing. Carlo is Carlo. Fox didnt take live reps. Shembo is an absolute hoss. Pass rush is still his best trait but he obviously can set the edge. I really can't believe he played DOG lol. Shembo has a bright future. Ishaq looks comfortable out there and looks like he has put some good work in weight room too. His drops were good and he is playing aggressive. He absolutely destroyed Mahone on a pass to the flats. Just his reaction to the play was the great thing about the play. Pass was thrown and as soon as Mahone caught it, Ishaq decleated him 2 yards in the backfield. Spond had limited reps but again you know what you are getting with him. Someone that holds the edge, smart player. Councell was the surprise on D. The light has come on and you cant teach his size. He was setting the edge, and attacking. Between Spond and Councell we have pair that can really play DOG at a high level, and thats not including a certain LB from Fort Wayne. Moore looks better than last year, but still just has mental lapses. I think he may get some PT this year, but I think that might also depend on how ready Deeb is. Joe Schmidt looked ok, but ND just has some elite athletes at LB.

DBs- Bennett didnt have pads on, but was def being a leader. Lo looked good before he was shut down. He has really changed his body and looks more than capable of playing. His height is still going to cause concerns bc he isnt Bennett Jackson athletically. Russell has packed on some lbs and hasnt lost a step. He has def improved his back pedal and just needs to continue getting out of his breaks. Its just awesome to think of how well he played, yet how much he has to learn and grow. Jalen Brown is by far the biggest cb on the roster. He did some good things in pass coverage and has really improved there over the course of his time. I think he can get some PT this year but I dont see him starting without injuries infront of him. Def plays physical but just lacks a little foot speed. Josh Atkinson struggled a lot. The speed is there, but I think he size hurts him. He plays with a motor and gives 110% but he just struggles with the bigger WRs. Farley is the vocal leader of the secondary...reminded me of Motta moving him into the right positions last year, but he was moving Shumate and LBs around. He has come a long way in 8months. Still a smaller safety but is a smart player. Shumate was impressive. All over the field. Plays the ball really well, and is killer in the run game. I think his OLB from high school come into play in the run game. Ill be curious to see how he does in play action situations, but if he can be disciplined he has a very high ceiling. Eilar Hardy looks like the kid that was on his high school film. He just moves smooth and literally looks like he is gliding out there at times. Getting him reps in live situations will go a long way for him and getting his feet back under himself in live reps. Collinsworth looks a little like where Eilar was last year, just trying to get his football legs back. It will be interesting to see if he can get back to the point he was at before his injury bc that does add some great depth back there between him, hardy, farley, shumate. John Turner looks like a OLB but just looks somewhat lost in the coverages. Athletic kid for sure, and I can def see him getting some SpTeams reps this year. It will be fun to watch Redfield and behind closed doors they do have a timeline for him whether they admit it or not. Shumate/Redfield back there would be a scary combo. Thats size and athleticism ND hasnt seen for quite sometime. I think this year you may see ND get aggressive in the secondary. They have the athletes and exp to do so and thats the next step in taking the defense to the next level.

SpTeams - Daly is going to be a staple at LS for the next 4 years and is reliable as hell. Brindza looked good on FGs. I did not get a chance to see Punt. Carlisle, Prosise, and TJ were fielding punts.

Notes...Amir is on a athletic/speed/agility level by himself on the team. The kid is elusive as Theo, but with top end speed. If he can stay healthy, that is a bigtime playmaker waiting to explode. Between Chris Brown and Davaris there are going to be a lot of shots downfield Golson can take. I think that ND is on the verge of becoming deadly weapon on offense. Kids coming in June add a new level of athlete and game breaking ability.

Holla.
 

NDWorld247

New member
Messages
2,474
Reaction score
302
That's all you got?

Thanks for the update. What about Romeo? Will he waste another year of eligibility on special teams this year?
 

ryno 24

Well-known member
Messages
2,419
Reaction score
100
thanks for the update tp and what position will carlisle come back at rb or slot or both? I know he can flex, but what primary position?
 

CanadalovesND

Well-known member
Messages
6,525
Reaction score
5,946
That's all you got?

Thanks for the update. What about Romeo? Will he waste another year of eligibility on special teams this year?

Seems like Romeo is just stuck behind a lot of talented players. Shembo and Ishaq at CAT, Spond and Councell at DOG, soon Jaylon will enter the mix too. He'll probably play a bit more, he's really added some great muscle to his frame, is almost 260 pounds now. After Shembo departs, you'll see a lot more Okwara on the field, but for now, most likely ST and mop up duty, splashed in a few game snaps here and there
 

Redbar

Well-known member
Messages
3,531
Reaction score
806
Appreciate your insight. One personal point of intrigue for me: I love Farley, young man came in unproven and raw, switched positions and never let his team down, played hurt, could have found any number of excuses to fail against some of college football's scariest dudes, never did. He is "next man in" will always respect and admire him for that. He will be difficult to uproot. At the same time, damm, Max Redfield is the kind of athlete that we have not seen in a while and he and Shumate back there, I agree, is probably the future plan. One of the great things about sport though is that a smart, tough, talent like Farley can rise to all occasions and will force even a talent like Max to be great if he is able to unseat him. That will be an interesting storyline through this next season and beyond. Curious to see how long Farley can hold him off.
 
B

Buster Bluth

Guest
What about Romeo? Will he waste another year of eligibility on special teams this year?

I wish that dude could go on a Mormon mission or something and come back an absolute monstermanfreak of nature.
 

Fbolt

I've been around
Messages
6,932
Reaction score
2,251
Great post-excellent insight. Much appreciated TP!
 

BGIF

Varsity Club
Messages
43,946
Reaction score
2,922
A Couple Of Things On A Couple Of Things

A Couple Of Things On A Couple Of Things

Overall an extremely encouraging report, thanks for the extensive update.

Despite the graduation losses, ND sounds as good if not better than last year. There may not be an Eifert nor Te'o caliber individual on either side of the ball but the report sounds like ND is deeper and more experienced across the entire Offense AND Defense than last season.


QB
Sounds great for the #1 QB. IF Golson can hit the back corners of the End Zone to use ND's height advantage, The Irish will average at least 7 more ppg than last season.

The description of the #2's (plural) confuses me. Understand Rees has reached his plateau but don't understand why he would only be good for a couple plays, limited series, lost helmet. For a lost helmet, anyone of the three could run in and take a snap. Rees's plateau 2 years ago is still better than Hendrix on field performance. IF the light has indeed come on for Hendrix and he is playing to his long proclaimed potential, then I'd expect him to be named #2. Zaire despite his athleticism doesn't sound at this point like a viable #2 this season. Being "as good" as the guy who just transferred was last year isn't a ringing endorsement. I'll get excited when I hear he's moved ahead of Hendrix and.or Rees.

OLine
IF N. Martin is ahead of Cave's level of play the O is going to roll.

Red Zone
Last year ND moved the ball between the 20's but scored too few Red Zone TD's to put games away. ND has had a repeated pass catcher height advantage under Kelly but have not been able to consistently take advantage of it. Regardless of QB it was not a well thrown pass nor did receivers, WRs or TEs, use their bodies effectively to screen out defenders. Niklas and Robinson should "own" the End Zone Corners. Post it in the Visitor's locker room, "We're going for 6 in the corners. Stop us if you can."

EZ Multiple sets, 3 TEs run play action into the line, rollout Golson to flip to either one of the TE's on a delay or run it in behind two of those big bodies who NOW can block. Split out Robinson behind Niklas, hit Robinson or pump fake to him and hit Niklas who skipped the block and went straight to the corner. Put Brown out there for the same play. After it's been shown to work and the defense spreads out to double up on the big guys, then you run it behind Zach and Chris. If we don't concede the back corners like we did last year, the running game has to be more effective.

DBs
Hopefully their experience and depth will allow Diaco to less predictable.
 

EuropeanDomer

New member
Messages
931
Reaction score
32
Thanks for the update but i do not like what i read at all. Everybody is x1000 times better, faster, stronger.. I'm sure you're right but i think we need to be more realistic.

From what i saw a few months ago:

Golson: Still looks bad with his reads and progressions. Of course now he has more experience and he will be more polished, but he has a lot to prove.

GAII: I think everybody here saw a good athlete, but a bad running back who had no carries at the end of the season. Now from what i read, he is a tremendous RB.

Davaris Daniels: Another inconsistent player who is now an future AA. Yes, he has nice potencial but he has to prove a lot.

Troy Niklas: "Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU" I doubt it, we are talking about Carlson, Fasano, Rudolph.. elite tight ends.

Nick Martin: He is already playing at a level better than Cave. C'mon, he does not played a snap in his career as a starter.

Jarrett Grace: He never saw the field in two years and now he fits the D better than Manti and he is going better in pass co.

Like every season, there will be players who step up in his game and others will be a disappointment. I love the potential of this group of players but i think this is exaggerated.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,265
Reaction score
2,489
Thanks for the update but i do not like what i read at all. Everybody is x1000 times better, faster, stronger.. I'm sure you're right but i think we need to be more realistic.

From what i saw a few months ago:

Golson: Still looks bad with his reads and progressions. Of course now he has more experience and he will be more polished, but he has a lot to prove.

GAII: I think everybody here saw a good athlete, but a bad running back who had no carries at the end of the season. Now from what i read, he is a tremendous RB.

Davaris Daniels: Another inconsistent player who is now an future AA. Yes, he has nice potencial but he has to prove a lot.

Troy Niklas: "Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU" I doubt it, we are talking about Carlson, Fasano, Rudolph.. elite tight ends.

Nick Martin: He is already playing at a level better than Cave. C'mon, he does not played a snap in his career as a starter.

Jarrett Grace: He never saw the field in two years and now he fits the D better than Manti and he is going better in pass co.

Like every season, there will be players who step up in his game and others will be a disappointment. I love the potential of this group of players but i think this is exaggerated.

To each his own, but the bolded statement is the reason for my post. Things will most definitely change from "a few months ago." That's when guys make their biggest strides in the weight room and in the film room. I think it's highly possible that each of TP's points are valid. Will they pan out on game days? We'll have to wait and see. But just to be clear, he's not the only one with these types of reports from spring practice. It's probably a safe bet to assume everyone has gotten better, smarter, stronger, faster, etc. Like he said, this team may not have the big names like Eifert and Teo (yet), but it's very deep and probably the most balanced and athletic roster ND has fielded in years. Good things to come. I'm very excited about this year.

I think part of the reason for not drinking the koolaid is that in so many years past, ND was hyped in spring/summer and then failed to produce in the fall. I realize last year was last year....but that doesn't mean that BK, the staff, and this team can't continue along that trajectory and continue to build on what they accomplished last season.

Btw, thanks for the insight TP.

Go Irish!
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,544
Reaction score
28,990
So what happens if someone gets hurt on the OL? Are we totally effed? Is Hegarty getting close to the point of being able to contribute?
 

aubeirish

Well-known member
Messages
3,601
Reaction score
149
TP. You have just brought great joy to my day. Thanks for your great update my man.
 

WakeUpEchoes

New member
Messages
2,574
Reaction score
101
Thanks for the update but i do not like what i read at all. Everybody is x1000 times better, faster, stronger.. I'm sure you're right but i think we need to be more realistic.

From what i saw a few months ago:

Golson: Still looks bad with his reads and progressions. Of course now he has more experience and he will be more polished, but he has a lot to prove.

GAII: I think everybody here saw a good athlete, but a bad running back who had no carries at the end of the season. Now from what i read, he is a tremendous RB.

Davaris Daniels: Another inconsistent player who is now an future AA. Yes, he has nice potencial but he has to prove a lot.

Troy Niklas: "Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU" I doubt it, we are talking about Carlson, Fasano, Rudolph.. elite tight ends.

Nick Martin: He is already playing at a level better than Cave. C'mon, he does not played a snap in his career as a starter.

Jarrett Grace: He never saw the field in two years and now he fits the D better than Manti and he is going better in pass co.

Like every season, there will be players who step up in his game and others will be a disappointment. I love the potential of this group of players but i think this is exaggerated.

tumblr_lrftqjZ7wZ1qc4pwxo1_250.gif
 

TheTurningPoint

New member
Messages
2,883
Reaction score
662
Thanks for the update but i do not like what i read at all. Everybody is x1000 times better, faster, stronger.. I'm sure you're right but i think we need to be more realistic.

From what i saw a few months ago:

Golson: Still looks bad with his reads and progressions. Of course now he has more experience and he will be more polished, but he has a lot to prove.

GAII: I think everybody here saw a good athlete, but a bad running back who had no carries at the end of the season. Now from what i read, he is a tremendous RB.

Davaris Daniels: Another inconsistent player who is now an future AA. Yes, he has nice potencial but he has to prove a lot.

Troy Niklas: "Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU" I doubt it, we are talking about Carlson, Fasano, Rudolph.. elite tight ends.

Nick Martin: He is already playing at a level better than Cave. C'mon, he does not played a snap in his career as a starter.

Jarrett Grace: He never saw the field in two years and now he fits the D better than Manti and he is going better in pass co.

Like every season, there will be players who step up in his game and others will be a disappointment. I love the potential of this group of players but i think this is exaggerated.


Like someone pointed out you started your comment with From what i saw a few months ago

These kids have worked their *** off. As much as the Natl Title game loss was tough for the fanbase, it was 1000xs worse for the players. They got a taste of the success and what it takes to be a contender. Many of them are taking Lacy and co running up and over the defense as a personal challenge. Thats what you want to see. Coming off 8-5 there is a sense of motivation to get better, but at the sametime its not going 12-0 and losing the title game. None of the kids that played in the title game had played in a BCS game, let alone a game of that stature. The big lights are going to get the best of anyones emotions and focus. If you break the game down from the 2nd -4th quarters, ND played Bama pretty damn well. The 1st quarter was a disaster and no one is saying diff, but these kids are really seeing that "hey Kelly, Martin, Diaco, Elliott, Elston, Alford, Cooks, Longo know what the hell they are talking about".

Golson - Watch the spring game and I feel you will see what I am talking about. He looked more than capable with his reads and progressions this past week. The move of Gunner speaks more volumes of Golson than Gunner if you talk to people that interact daily with the program.

GA3 - I said, "GA3 looks and plays like the GA3 that showed up in the spring game last year. He looks like a college RB and the weight is def helping his game. He has enough power to accelerate out of his cuts and is running inside the tackles with a lot of confidence. Still is a little light on his feet, but theres few perfect backs. If he keeps adding good weight, I think he will put himself on the map this year. Few kids at this level have that speed, and size. He still needs a little work on his ball skills in the pass game. He is more than able to catch in the flats, but he struggled when he was trying to get in the seam" Im not sure how you got he is a tremendous RB out of that. I was speaking of his abilities. Its all a mindset for him, if he wants to get down and dirty, aka run hard...then he has more than a fair shot at being a tremendous RB. Last year, he was used as a situational back, and Cierre lost carries due to Theo's play. Im not sure what point you are trying to make there. Cierre is going to get drafted before Theo so Im confused by that statement.

Davaris - Isn't part of being a first year player inconsistencies and using that experience going into spring ball and improving inconsistencies? I could be wrong, but I will be absolutely shocked if you dont feel the same come fall. The thing for him is staying healthy.

Niklas - You forgot Eifert as elite. He left ND as the best TE to play at ND, and who has Niklas learned from? The best TE to play at ND. He played TE at a competitive level last year and with it being his first year, he played it pretty damn well minus the Stanford game. If you watched what Kelly did with Eifert, his growth was between his 2nd and 3rd year. Do I see Niklas being used like Eifert, no, he is a different athlete that can be used more in the run game game vs flanked off the line.

Nick Martin - The staff disagrees with your comment. Nix is making him better everyday.

Grace - I said he may. His skill set fits what they do defensively better than Manti. Manti's weakness is pass coverage. Grace provides someone that is good in space, and has enough speed to get sideline to sideline. Manti, as you probably saw during his 4 years, wasn't the best in pass coverage. Its not an exaggeration to say someone can be better in pass coverage than Manti. Hell, Dan Fox is better in pass co than Manti.

Here's the thing you are missing my man....This isn't a Weis coached team and his staff is long gone minus Alford. The development of the players in the program is what Kelly has done at every stop. Sure, like you said some players aren't going to turn out or be developed, happens at every school. But it's hard to see the basis of your rebuttals after watching them practice, talking to people in the program, and seeing the development since Jan in kids. To each their own.
 

NDBoiler

The Rep Machine
Messages
4,455
Reaction score
1,826
Thanks for the update but i do not like what i read at all. Everybody is x1000 times better, faster, stronger.. I'm sure you're right but i think we need to be more realistic.

From what i saw a few months ago:

Golson: Still looks bad with his reads and progressions. Of course now he has more experience and he will be more polished, but he has a lot to prove.

GAII: I think everybody here saw a good athlete, but a bad running back who had no carries at the end of the season. Now from what i read, he is a tremendous RB.

Davaris Daniels: Another inconsistent player who is now an future AA. Yes, he has nice potencial but he has to prove a lot.

Troy Niklas: "Niklas is in line to be the next big name TE coming out of TightEndU" I doubt it, we are talking about Carlson, Fasano, Rudolph.. elite tight ends.

Nick Martin: He is already playing at a level better than Cave. C'mon, he does not played a snap in his career as a starter.

Jarrett Grace: He never saw the field in two years and now he fits the D better than Manti and he is going better in pass co.

Like every season, there will be players who step up in his game and others will be a disappointment. I love the potential of this group of players but i think this is exaggerated.

This^

IMO, the truth lies somewhere between EuroDomer's and TP's descriptions. I am sure the team has improved, but if what TP says is 100% true, it's almost as if ND's opponents might as well not even show up. (Mind you, I certainly hope that is the case!)
 

ScooterIrish

New member
Messages
523
Reaction score
36
This^

IMO, the truth lies somewhere between EuroDomer's and TP's descriptions. I am sure the team has improved, but if what TP says is 100% true, it's almost as if ND's opponents might as well not even show up. (Mind you, I certainly hope that is the case!)

Nonsense. TP is in no way prediction what other teams will be like, what kind of bounces go our way, etc.

Look, Daniels and TJ looked like legit top shelf football players against Bama. Is it hard to believe Daniels can be a excellent receiver for us if he continues to improve and stay consistent?

GAIII had some very good moments last year. He had some tough runs against Stanford and made a great move on the BYU defender. Again, those reps with the first team are going to help him become the complete RB. Shouldn't be a surprise since we know he has a ton of talent.

Niklas gets a bad rap because of his poor blocking in the Stanford game.
 

Domina Nostra

Well-known member
Messages
6,251
Reaction score
1,388
Spring is always the time for optimism :)

We went 12-1 and got to the NC last year. This is not 2009! I am not sure thinking our guys are good is optimism at this point. :)

I expect us to look better overall, although I have a hard time seeing 12-0!


Some of these predictions are obvious, but:

- Personally, I think the combination of good CBs and a great DL will stabalize the defense in a big way. We will give up more points, almost necessarily, but I think the unit is going to be very reliable and occassionally exciting.
- Having a tier 1 QB in his second year has not happened since 2008. The offense made a huge jump then. I expect the same in 2013.
- I kind of expect to see Ronnie Stanley at RT and Lombard at RG.
- I also still expect to see a lot of Bryant and Carlisle. I am totally sold on Cam as a soild option, and I think GAIII could have a big impact if he can learn not to stop his momentum, but I think Coach is going to want a little more than these guys offer.
- DD and TJ are going to be big-time players, opening the door for Brown, Robinson, etc.
- Randolph will be groomed as a ILB.
- Springmann becomes a real weapon.
- Farley continues to impress.
 
P

PraetorianND

Guest
Thanks for the great post TP!

Couple of questions:

1) Are you saying that TJ could/will be an NFL receiver or his skill set just matches the slot NFL receiver more than slot in college?

2) Biggest weakness on the team at this point?

3) Which incoming freshman will have the best chance at making an immediate impact based on the above question?

4) Can you describe STs overall? Do you see an improvement over last season at this time or otherwise?

5) Biggest improvement from last season per position and per player?

6) Can you describe the speed of practice? Are they going camp Kelly style where they are running a ton of plays as fast as possible or is it a little slower?

7) How often is the read-option being used in practice at this point?

8) Is anyone going to be able to fill Manti's shoes from a leadership role on the defense?

9) What is Ishaq missing that would make him elite?

10) How does our WR corps compare to last year's (including Eifert)?


Thanks in advance and sorry for the barrage of questions.
 

Domina Nostra

Well-known member
Messages
6,251
Reaction score
1,388
I'll take a stab...

1) Are you saying that TJ could/will be an NFL receiver or his skill set just matches the slot NFL receiver more than slot in college? The latter.
2) Biggest weakness on the team at this point? RB, WR and ILB depth, S experience.
3) Which incoming freshman will have the best chance at making an immediate impact based on the above question? Bryant (Vanderdoes, if not based on that question)
5) Biggest improvement from last season per position and per player? Golson
8) Is anyone going to be able to fill Manti's shoes from a leadership role on the defense? I don't see this as a problem between Nix, Tuitt, Grace, and Jackson.
9) What is Ishaq missing that would make him elite? Instincts
10) How does our WR corps compare to last year's (including Eifert)? More good options to throw to among the starters, depth is still a concern. On 3rd down, I'd still rather have Eifert than DD just because size matters
 

NDBoiler

The Rep Machine
Messages
4,455
Reaction score
1,826
Nonsense. TP is in no way prediction what other teams will be like, what kind of bounces go our way, etc.

Look, Daniels and TJ looked like legit top shelf football players against Bama. Is it hard to believe Daniels can be a excellent receiver for us if he continues to improve and stay consistent?

GAIII had some very good moments last year. He had some tough runs against Stanford and made a great move on the BYU defender. Again, those reps with the first team are going to help him become the complete RB. Shouldn't be a surprise since we know he has a ton of talent.

Niklas gets a bad rap because of his poor blocking in the Stanford game.

I understand your points. I also thought ND would've been a lot more competitive against Alabama than they were, so I am trying to temper my optimism as much as possible for 2013. I'd much prefer to be pleasantly surprised by the team's success than be underwhelmed and thoroughly disappointed. Plus, keep in mind that everyone always looks great in practice. As you mentioned, TP's post wasn't a commentary on the opponents, so you don't know for sure how the matchups will stack up in a game situation either.
 
Top