NorthDakota
Grandson of Loomis
- Messages
- 15,701
- Reaction score
- 5,999
If I recall correctly Ryan Mallett started that ND-MICH game in 2007. Think Hart and Henne were hurt and didn't play in the 2007 game.
If you go by point spread Stanford upsetting USC in the Coliseum is the biggest upset in history. USC were 41 point favorites at home, holding a 35 home game winning streak, and Stanford was 1-11 the year before in 2006 and USC destroyed them like 49-0 in '06. Stanford was also starting a 3rd string QB that game and USC was ranked #2 in the AP and #1 in the coaches poll. That to me is the biggest upset ever.
Michigan upset was big and shocking, don't get me wrong, but App State at that point was THE dominant FCS team and had just won the FCS National Title in 2005 and 2006, and they also won it again that year they upset Michigan in 2007. That was a squad that won 3 straight national titles and was just dominant in there division. Michigan absolutely should've beat them at home and they shit the bed horrifically, but there is no way that is a bigger upset than what Stanford did to USC in my mind. Stanford was a program coming off a 1-11 season and starting it's 3rd string QB against USC.
App was very good but they lost to multiple FCS teams that year. Michigan took it up the ass like a week later too. In terms of famous upsets, that one is bigger than the USC one. App State will forever be that team that beat Michigan. James Madison beat a highly rated VA Tech(eventually lost to Stanford in orange bowl I think) but the cool factor was not remotely similar to the App game.
The Stanford win over SC was crazy. I would agree that it was bigger...just not in a popular culture sense. Tavika Pritchard did become a name I'll always vaguely remember. No idea if I spelled it correctly.
Certainly magic though.