3 Years to get a QB1

[BrownerandFry]

If Golson would have learned to tuck the ball when he ran, we might have had a natty. You just knew the fumble was coming. Agree on Coan. He may not have a cannon, but the clips show decent arm strength and the ability to go deep when needed. He lost the job due to injury. That happens at times. He can also run, so don't be surprised if he runs more than expected.

you may be correct about Golson, but I'm not sure.

I always wondered, and still do, if he was more piano player than football player, a guy really too sensitive to put up with the rigors and scrutiny of an ND QB.

I was always fascinated by his incredible abiility to break the pocket, run a few yards with his eyes downfield, reset and throw a 30 yard strike.

oh well,........

I have more hope for Coan than I did for Book. I respect Book's efforts, not his skills....let's leave it there

 

[Some Irish Bloke]

He was a statue with a noodle arm... but he was a gunslinger with ice running through his veins, and he scored the best rushing touchdown of 2012 (of which there were MANY good ones).

Tommy Rees, Notre Dame Man.

1000%, that QB sneak on scUM was glorious.

 

[NDLincPark]

Anyone with a brain would have seen this.

I was spot on

 

[ACamp1900]

That’s how you spike the football in these fanboys’ faces right there,……….

 

[Rack Em]

Anyone with a brain would have seen this.

I was spot on

Don’t throw your out shoulder from patting yourself on the back so hard.

 

[Sea Turtle]

Anyone with a brain would have seen this.

I was spot on

It really is astonishing how bad BK has been with QB's over the last 12 years

 

[ND88]

Anyone with a brain would have seen this.

I was spot on

What a hot take. Upgrade this guy to water distribution engineer.

 

[NDRock]

Anyone with a brain would have seen this.

I was spot on

You really were. Don’t remember anyone discussing the QB problems here before you brought it up. Well done.

 

[NDLincPark]

You really were. Don’t remember anyone discussing the QB problems here before you brought it up. Well done.

you and the majority of the ND Fans boys were lauding Coan, saying How perfect of a fit he’d be here. 5th year with experience! Gamer! Exactly what we need!!

own it. Especially after the FSU game, you guys were gushing over him. FSU is atrocious and you acted like he was Joe Burrow. Can’t make up the annual Irish delusion

 

[Irish#1]

you and the majority of the ND Fans boys were lauding Coan, saying How perfect of a fit he’d be here. 5th year with experience! Gamer! Exactly what we need!!

own it. Especially after the FSU game, you guys were gushing over him. FSU is atrocious and you acted like he was Joe Burrow. Can’t make up the annual Irish delusion

I doubt you'd be able to thump your chest if the O-line did their job, because neither Buchner or Pyne are lighting it up.

 

[NDRock]

you and the majority of the ND Fans boys were lauding Coan, saying How perfect of a fit he’d be here. 5th year with experience! Gamer! Exactly what we need!!

own it. Especially after the FSU game, you guys were gushing over him. FSU is atrocious and you acted like he was Joe Burrow. Can’t make up the annual Irish delusion

You’re right. You’ve shown me the light. Only thing left now is to burn my Coan jersey, take his posters off my wall, and change my son’s name back (we’d started the paperwork of renaming him Jack after the FSU game). Thank you for your service.

 

[NDLincPark]

You’re right. You’ve shown me the light. Only thing left now is to burn my Coan jersey, take his posters off my wall, and change my son’s name back (we’d started the paperwork of renaming him Jack after the FSU game). Thank you for your service.

It’s ok to just realize he was a shit qb in Wisco

had zero upside

and was an embarrassing choice for ND to cling onto, when they had 3 years to plan for a QB under Book.

 

[NorthDakota]

It’s ok to just realize he was a shit qb in Wisco

had zero upside

and was an embarrassing choice for ND to cling onto, when they had 3 years to plan for a QB under Book.

I dont think anyone in the world other than you thought he was bad at Wisconsin.

 

[NDLincPark]

I dont think anyone in the world other than you thought he was bad at Wisconsin.

That’s because Notre dame fans think avg/mediocre is great when it comes to qb

 

[Irish#1]

That’s because Notre dame fans think avg/mediocre is great when it comes to qb

I thought Coan would be a good fit. Not a superstar, but a good fit while Buchner is groomed, but not a college or pro QB around looks great when the O-line is bad.

 

[NorthDakota]

That’s because Notre dame fans think avg/mediocre is great when it comes to qb

What are you defining as great? What makes a guy average or bad? I'm irritated ND didn't have a guy ready too. Phil didn't work out. Hopefully Buchner does.

 

[NDLincPark]

Buchner ain’t the guy either. Sure hope they realize that and don’t waste 3 more years pretending he may be.

he can’t even beat out coan, lol.

Kelly has to be the only d1 coach in history to play all 3 of his qbs routinely. It’s actually hilarious to watch

 

[mango4]

Buchner ain’t the guy either. Sure hope they realize that and don’t waste 3 more years pretending he may be.

he can’t even beat out coan, lol.

Kelly has to be the only d1 coach in history to play all 3 of his qbs routinely. It’s actually hilarious to watch

This is stupid. He has been here for what, 5 games? He didn't play high school football last year either. Let's calm down.

 

[GowerND11]

Buchner ain’t the guy either. Sure hope they realize that and don’t waste 3 more years pretending he may be.

he can’t even beat out coan, lol.

Kelly has to be the only d1 coach in history to play all 3 of his qbs routinely. It’s actually hilarious to watch

This is why I hate a large part of our fan base. What a horrible take about Buchner.

 

[NDLincPark]

What a hilarious List over the last 15 years.

2021	Jack Coan	Sr.	September 5	5	4–1
2020	Ian Book	Sr.		12	10–2
2019	Ian Book	Sr.		13	11–2
2018	Brandon Wimbush	Sr.		4	4–0
Ian Book	Jr.		9	8–1
2017	Brandon Wimbush	Jr.	September 2	12	9–3
Ian Book	So.	October 6	1	1–0
2016	DeShone Kizer	So.		12	4–8
2015	DeShone Kizer	Fr.	September 19	11	8–3
Malik Zaire	Jr.		2	2–0
2014	Everett Golson	Sr.		12	7–5
Malik Zaire	So.	December 30	1	1–0
2013	Tommy Rees	Sr.		13	9–4
2012	Tommy Rees	Jr.		2	2–0
Everett Golson	So.	September 1	11	10–1
2011	Tommy Rees	So.		12	8–4
Dayne Crist	Sr.		1	0–1
2010	Tommy Rees	Fr.	November 13	4	4–0
Dayne Crist	Jr.	September 4	9	4–5
2009	Jimmy Clausen	Jr.		12	6–6	AA
2008	Jimmy Clausen	So.		13	7–6
2007	Evan Sharpley	Jr.	October 20	2	0–2
Jimmy Clausen	Fr.	September 8	9	3–6
Demetrius Jones

 

[ab2cmiller]

I don't think anyone can take you seriously after your Buchner "hot take". Can't tell if you are a troll or not.

 

[Irishize]

What a hilarious List over the last 15 years.

2021	Jack Coan	Sr.	September 5	5	4–1
2020	Ian Book	Sr.		12	10–2
2019	Ian Book	Sr.		13	11–2
2018	Brandon Wimbush	Sr.		4	4–0
Ian Book	Jr.		9	8–1
2017	Brandon Wimbush	Jr.	September 2	12	9–3
Ian Book	So.	October 6	1	1–0
2016	DeShone Kizer	So.		12	4–8
2015	DeShone Kizer	Fr.	September 19	11	8–3
Malik Zaire	Jr.		2	2–0
2014	Everett Golson	Sr.		12	7–5
Malik Zaire	So.	December 30	1	1–0
2013	Tommy Rees	Sr.		13	9–4
2012	Tommy Rees	Jr.		2	2–0
Everett Golson	So.	September 1	11	10–1
2011	Tommy Rees	So.		12	8–4
Dayne Crist	Sr.		1	0–1
2010	Tommy Rees	Fr.	November 13	4	4–0
Dayne Crist	Jr.	September 4	9	4–5
2009	Jimmy Clausen	Jr.		12	6–6	AA
2008	Jimmy Clausen	So.		13	7–6
2007	Evan Sharpley	Jr.	October 20	2	0–2
Jimmy Clausen	Fr.	September 8	9	3–6
Demetrius Jones

You do realize that BK only recruited four of those QBs?

 

[anarin]

This guy isn't a ND fan. lol

Dude stumbled upon this site and thought he'd troll the shit out of the board. And I can't even take the turtle dude serious anymore either....

 

[GowerND11]

Hey, NDLincPark... Here's the list of all 130 FBS teams. You have 129 others to choose from, because clearly Notre Dame isn't for you.

 

[NDLincPark]

This guy isn't a ND fan. lol

Dude stumbled upon this site and thought he'd troll the shit out of the board. And I can't even take the turtle dude serious anymore either....

That is funny. I wonder why I was in Joyce lot Sat tailgating in the rain and going to the game. Hmm

I think I did it just to troll you, actually

 

[dad4aa]

I don't think anyone can take you seriously after your Buchner "hot take". Can't tell if you are a troll or not.

I vote troll

 

[NDLincPark]

Buchner ain’t the guy either. Sure hope they realize that and don’t waste 3 more years pretending he may be.

he can’t even beat out coan, lol.

Kelly has to be the only d1 coach in history to play all 3 of his qbs routinely. It’s actually hilarious to watch

Lol - You lemmings still adore 3 star Tyler Buchner.

 

[NumbersGuy0520]

I’ll keep saying it until I’m blue in the face. WRs and OCs matter more to a team’s offensive success. We’ve had the QB recruiting.

There’s a reason why OSU has such an incredible offense every year, yet none of their QBs have recently panned out past college.

 

[T-Boone]

I’ll keep saying it until I’m blue in the face. WRs and OCs matter more to a team’s offensive success. We’ve had the QB recruiting.

There’s a reason why OSU has such an incredible offense every year, yet none of their QBs have recently panned out past college.

That’s scary because I think it’s more likely ND can fix the QB standard than the WR standard moving forward.

 

[ulukinatme]

Can't let the Isaiah McKenzie's slip through the cracks because of admissions. You wind up with a lot of struggling talent.