2025 Fall Practice Thread

dublinirish

dublinirish

Everestt Gholstonson
Messages
27,310
Reaction score
13,086
Lol Phil is a legislative aide to some PA state rep these days


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
D

DomeFieldAdvantage

Well-known member
Messages
326
Reaction score
529
IrishBoognish said:
The only thing im seeing so far that gives me some "oh no" vibes is Prister saying he agrees with the analysis that this was an MF decision and "not all were in agreement"

that doesnt make me feel awesome
Click to expand...
To me, it really depends on who was against it. If its Denbrock, then that's bad. If its Geno or some of the auxiliary staff, I don't care that much. If anything, I would be kind of surprised if Geno wasn't for Carr just because Carr might have the higher upside as a pure passer, which, if he hits his ceiling, would make Geno look much better for other jobs than just going with another safe, but lower upside option.
 
Dale

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,103
Reaction score
27,366
To me it really doesn’t change the outlook on the 2025 season, like at all. There is a feeling that Carr being like a 2 year starter stud 1st round pick might be gone though to be disappointed in
 
N

NDFAN2008

Well-known member
Messages
7,330
Reaction score
5,655
Regardless whose QB I don’t think either will have a long leash the coaches won’t make the same mistakes like last year not pulling Leonard against NIU
 
T-Boone

T-Boone

Well-known member
Messages
8,400
Reaction score
4,795
Dale said:
To me it really doesn’t change the outlook on the 2025 season, like at all. There is a feeling that Carr being like a 2 year starter stud 1st round pick might be gone though to be disappointed in
Click to expand...
Hopefully Minch has improved a lot since that Blue Gold game because he wasn’t good.
 
Dale

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,103
Reaction score
27,366
T-Boone said:
Hopefully Minch has improved a lot since that Blue Gold game because he wasn’t good.
Click to expand...

This is what I said in the moment:

“Minchey: He was much more decisive then I expected. Solid arm. Made some quick reads and throws, though some were inaccurate. Two really nice dimes to Burress. Fair amount of RPO Read stuff which he for the most part made the right read but got stuffed on his pulls sometimes, might be better credit to the D then a bad decision. There were some “you’re not allowed to scramble” plays it felt like and he took a sack once, threw into coverage a few times. Might have taken the most deep shots and they were around the WR but I wouldn’t call great placement, best throw was a seam throw to Larsen. Saw a solid QB, don’t think I saw our starter.”
 
Dizzyphil

Dizzyphil

Well-known member
Messages
4,094
Reaction score
1,541
Who on this forum is more informed or knowledgeable of which QB is best to start anyway??? The Backfield is going to determine ND's best shot at the Playoffs anyway.

First person please throw the stone that hasn't trust MFMF......
 
Junkhead

Junkhead

Community Mod
Messages
7,595
Reaction score
1,354
mrmcgrail said:
Fully feels like carr was turning it over too much and freeman for as great of a coach as he is is crazy conservative
Click to expand...
I don't know about conservative, as often as he likes to go for it on 4th down. (Which I love when it works)
 
3

317Irish

Grits are a$$
Messages
1,208
Reaction score
1,052
Apologies as I’ve tried to read through the last few pages and pinpoint where or by whom the “announcement” of the starting QB was. Is this official, semi-official, conjecture, or just the regular, everyday overreaction to a practice highlight video?
 
NDVirginia19

NDVirginia19

Rally
Messages
4,420
Reaction score
5,129
317Irish said:
Apologies as I’ve tried to read through the last few pages and pinpoint where or by whom the “announcement” of the starting QB was. Is this official, semi-official, conjecture, or just the regular, everyday overreaction to a practice highlight video?
Click to expand...
Nothing official, message board chatter and some insider posting that MFMF announced it to the team yesterday
 
GoldenAura

GoldenAura

Well-known member
Messages
1,215
Reaction score
2,577
NDVirginia19 said:
Nothing official, message board chatter and some insider posting that MFMF announced it to the team yesterday
Click to expand...

Also John Brice practically confirming it without saying the exact words.

“Minchey is in an enviable position heading into Sunday’s scrimmage.”

You could interpret that as “Minchey is just ahead right now” but the timing of this statement immediately after all the rumors this morning make me think they definitely know it’s a done deal.
 
ulukinatme

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2025!
Messages
31,509
Reaction score
17,369
T-Boone said:
Hopefully Minch has improved a lot since that Blue Gold game because he wasn’t good.
Click to expand...

SoIll said:
Yeah I just rewatched. Yuck
Click to expand...

I say this as a Carr fan, Spring Game doesn't mean shit and never did. Look at Kizer, he was QB #3 after the Spring Game in 2015 and he was contemplating quitting football because he stunk the joint up at the time. Golson transfers, Zaire gets hurt, and Kizer connected with Fuller to create a crazy tandem which he parlay'd into the Draft as a 2nd round pick after playing one more season. For every Junior Jabbie Spring Game star there's a Kizer that turns it on in the regular season.

8f248c1a-b041-498b-90a1-1d9f6dce9954_text.gif

mrmcgrail said:
Fully feels like carr was turning it over too much and freeman for as great of a coach as he is is crazy conservative
Click to expand...

Could be his exposure to Jim Tressel.
 
greyhammer90

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
16,820
Reaction score
16,079
I don't get where this sudden narrative that Freeman is a Tressel ball coach comes from. The guy plays heavy risk/reward defensive schemes that put corners on islands, loves trick plays on special teams, loves going for it on 4th down even in his own territory, and has made no bones that he wants to beat teams badly if he can. His entire mantra is "challenge everything."

BK was the conservative one. His whole strategy post 2016 was "I'm going to get up by 10-14 points and then turtle up because I don't think you can score". (Which is fine, but definitely more conservative than how Freeman coaches.)
 
Last edited:
C

CoachB

Well-known member
Messages
1,282
Reaction score
1,825
greyhammer90 said:
I don't get where this sudden narrative that Freeman is a Tressel ball coach comes from. The guy plays heavy risk/reward defensive schemes that put corners on islands, loves trick plays on special teams, loves going for it on 4th down even in his own territory, and has made no bones that he wants to beat teams badly if he can. His entire mantra is "challenge everything."

BK was the conservative one. His whole strategy post 2018 was "I'm going to get up by 10-14 points and then turtle up because I don't think you can score". (Which is fine, but definitely more conservative than how Freeman coaches.)
Click to expand...
I absolutely love the way he coaches! It is a lot of fun.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top