I don't know anything about that but I do know that he made a FC(FutureCast) pick today for Chris Tyree to ND.EJ Holland posted a photo of his coffee on twitter. Who committed?
I don't know anything about that but I do know that he made a FC(FutureCast) pick today for Chris Tyree to ND.EJ Holland posted a photo of his coffee on twitter. Who committed?
How many projected scholarship athletes return in 2020 now
QB - 4
RB - 6
TE - 6
WR - 11
OL - 15
DL - 19 (Jamir Jones projected redshirt)
LB - 12
DB - 12 (Gilman & Crawford counted but doubtful to return)
ST - 4
TOTAL - 89 Scholarships
It’s pretty amazing that it is June 17th and ND is pretty much good on numbers at every single position except for one on their roster. They’re obviously recruiting WR and DB heavily still with DB being a focus because of the need for 5-6 guys potentially in this class. The rest of the class is now just shooting for the best players you can get your hands on. ND’s now got 6+ months to recruit high level prospects and maybe see if any want to flip, any start showing more interest and maybe want to make it to campus for a game day visit. I’d love to see maybe another WR or two if they’re top end talent which ND already seems to be in heavy with (McMillan, Henning, Odunze, Watts, Brunelle). DB we’ll get a lot more clarity on as the next 10 days go by because they’ve got 4 guys visiting this weekend (Gonzalez, Nixon, Offord, Bartleson). After that it’s seeing if you can get traction with maybe a Jay Hardy, maybe Phillip Webb decides to consider ND at some point, or maybe Cody Simon gets a spot in the class, but at this point, the base of the class is very close to finished and the numbers are getting close to met so ND can go big game hunting which is fantastic.
Apparently Watts is open to playing DB and he might end up there. I wonder if that's a plan B or just bringing in an athlete
You should check out his highlight video. I was very impressed by his defensive film.
Just reading ISD article below and it seems like WR is going to be potentially larger. Am I reading the last paragraph right? How many WRs are they taking or is Watts a swing WR/DB? The last pargraph is below.
"Ideally, Notre Dame is able to get Brunelle, Watts, Melton and Offord on board soon and then focus on McMillan and Henning along with the necessary defensive backs to round out a strong class."
https://irishsportsdaily.com/s/9751/2020-recruiting-what-now
In general, I think taking only 2 OL... especially when you look at what is left in the '18 class... is risky. An injury, transfer, suspension, etc. and you're swimming in dark, dangerous, shark infested waters.
I get why ND is doing it. Tight numbers and an abundance of "swing" guys all able to play inside. But you cannot plug-and-play true frosh OL like you can at other positions, which means veteran depth is incredibly valuable on the OL. We have 9 guys right now over three classes and two of those players look like "misses" so you're really talking about 7 total bodies over 3 years... that's living dangerous unless you get some solid 5th year contributors from the '17 class to bridge the development of the guys you recruit in '21.
In general, I think taking only 2 OL... especially when you look at what is left in the '18 class... is risky. An injury, transfer, suspension, etc. and you're swimming in dark, dangerous, shark infested waters.
I get why ND is doing it. Tight numbers and an abundance of "swing" guys all able to play inside. But you cannot plug-and-play true frosh OL like you can at other positions, which means veteran depth is incredibly valuable on the OL. We have 9 guys right now over three classes and two of those players look like "misses" so you're really talking about 7 total bodies over 3 years... that's living dangerous unless you get some solid 5th year contributors from the '17 class to bridge the development of the guys you recruit in '21.
I do think it's a little bit of a gamble but my question would be, at what point are you having this concern, 21'? 22'?
Because I just don't see it. Feels like quite a few things would have to go wrong for us to be starting true freshman anytime soon.
I've followed MIA's flow charts and there's just too many good players to fail.
Also, I think Quinn is like HH in the fact that he doesn't use the depth chart to plug in a different player at each position, it's a hoops style 6th man who can play a couple positions or a starter slides into the injury slot and the the 6th man fills his spot. Next year, Lugg's that guy and it sounds like Dirksen and Gibbons are next.
If they land a class in 2021 that looks something like:
Crippen
Fisher
Tengwell
Davidkov/Sutton
Swinney/Mugharbil
They will be fine.
Bottom line, keep between 13-15 scholarship OLineman on your roster at all times and get as much talent at those numbers as possible. They're LOADED with guys who return in 2020 so 2 this cycle isn't the worst thing. Someone mentioned above about why so many DB's this cycle where they might be underrecruiting OL or other positions. Well, ND currently has 12 scholarship DB's for 2020 and very likely 10 (Crawford and Gilman are gone) and that's simply not enough to field a competitive football roster. Yes, ND would likely use 6 DB's or 7 during a season, but people forget about special teams and if injuries happen then you've got Clarence Lewis playing real football minutes in his first year on campus which would be a huge mistake. That's why ND needs 5-6 freshman so that by fall camp of 2020, maybe 1 or 2 of those freshman have it together enough to play some spot minutes and play well on special teams. The last bunch of seasons, ND has carried 14-16 scholarship DB's and if you see that 10 are likely back including Clarence Lewis then you see that ND needs a bunch of DB's. Ideally 1-2 that could contribute a little freshman year too.
Bottom line, keep between 13-15 scholarship OLineman on your roster at all times and get as much talent at those numbers as possible. They're LOADED with guys who return in 2020 so 2 this cycle isn't the worst thing. Someone mentioned above about why so many DB's this cycle where they might be underrecruiting OL or other positions. Well, ND currently has 12 scholarship DB's for 2020 and very likely 10 (Crawford and Gilman are gone) and that's simply not enough to field a competitive football roster. Yes, ND would likely use 6 DB's or 7 during a season, but people forget about special teams and if injuries happen then you've got Clarence Lewis playing real football minutes in his first year on campus which would be a huge mistake. That's why ND needs 5-6 freshman so that by fall camp of 2020, maybe 1 or 2 of those freshman have it together enough to play some spot minutes and play well on special teams. The last bunch of seasons, ND has carried 14-16 scholarship DB's and if you see that 10 are likely back including Clarence Lewis then you see that ND needs a bunch of DB's. Ideally 1-2 that could contribute a little freshman year too.
This makes for a good offseason conversation. But who would know more about this than Quinn and Kelly? No one. There's probably a reason why they're only taking 2 OL in this class. I think Zeke, Quinn, and potentially Kristofic will be read to roll by year 2 and will be main stays for the next 3-4 years after that.
You want more than that though from a recruiting standpoint to have 15 on the roster. Bama took a 2 person class few years ago, and bookended that with two classes of 5 and a class of 6. ND is consistently fortunate to get OL staying 4/5 years which is exactly what you want, but in general you want to be signing about 4 OL each year with your “light” years being 3. If you recruit 4 per class you’ll usually end up with something like 2-3-3-4-4 gets you 16ish. ND typically has 2ish 5th year players, and loses about 1 guy to attrition in each class by the time they’re upperclassmen.
There is only 1 player from the ‘18 crop people think can be a high level player. No one knows anything about the ‘19 class but you can assume to hit on at least 2 given their lofty rankings. So the year that is potentially dicey is the ‘22 season when this class is true juniors because heaven forbid something bad happens with attrition, etc. then you are reliant on freshmen/RS freshmen. That’s fine if those players are Quenton Nelson, it’s less fine if they’re Steve Elmer or Robert Hainsey. It is extremely difficult to ask young players to immediately contribute on the OL.
Just read the mid week musings from Driskell and he stated that after Offord and Watts potentially committing, as well as adding a pure safety, ND may slow down recruiting for a little bit. That would mean they would end up at 18 commits.
I have seen it posted that ND wants to take a max of 21, if necessary. EJ Holland also said that Will Nixon was a take as well. If Nixon wants in and the 21 max is true, then that would leave 2 spots open for any flip candidates or new evals for 2020. Apparently the staff really likes the roster they have right now, but I have a feeling with attrition, injury, etc ND will get to 21.
21 commits would bring ND’s schollys to 96 for 2020 with 11 Graduate Seniors. If they do 21 or less then they won’t be at 85 by August 2020. I think the class gets to 22-23 eventually by February. For numbers needs I think 1 WR (Xavier Watts) and 3-4 more DB’s is basically all ND needs. Everything else will be bonuses added to the roster. I’d love to get Nixon, Watts, and Offord for the rest of the summer and then push for top dudes and flips (Jerrin Thompson, Christian Gonzalez, Malcolm Greene, and flips).
From what Driskell was saying, he thinks that ND may keep more 5th year seniors than expected.
This also highlights the fact that ND needs to and make a strong point to get 2021's on campus for gameday experiences this fall. I still think one of ND's best times to visit is for a game in the fall and a lot of these 2020 guys who ND recruited really hard saw ND 1 time in the spring and maybe for an OV in the summer. If you get guys on campus twice like that then it is fine, but it is harder to get guys to commit to ND off of 1 visit in the summer for an OV or something like that. I think they did a really solid job of doing that last fall, but they need to continue that and even grow that visitor list come this fall because ND's recruiting classes are done for the most part by the time senior fall rolls around for these guys. A guy like Will Shipley is someone I really hope can get to ND this fall for a game and Camar Wheaton comes back to ND for a game. That would really put ND in a great position going into the following spring to host them for OV's or something like that.
It feels like the Early Signing Day, and the more "fit"-oriented approach BK has taken to recruiting the last few cycles (locking in guys who want ND, as opposed to hats-on-the-table drama queens) really makes this more important. It's crazy to think it's only July 3, 2019 and they're basically done recruiting 2020 aside from two or three BPA kind of slots, especially when you recall the crazy Januarys of not so long ago.
But, yeah, to recruit this way, especially for ND, you need to get guys on campus for games in the fall of their junior year.