I still think we need 8 teams, just so there are some other teams in it and there would be less complaining about P5 teams being left out (all five conference champions, top Go5, and two at larges). Currently, you can probably bet you’ll see Bama, Clemson, and either OU or OSU for sure in any given year. Outside of those, 7 teams have made it. (Bama and Clemson: 6, OSU and OU: 4, ND: 2, LSU, Oregon, UGA, FSU, Mich St, and UW: 1). Moving to 8 would at least give us some new teams to watch. Going back to the start of the CFP, here is how it would look. Typically, it’s the top ranked through seventh ranked, plus the Go5 make it (if number 7 is left out, I noted it because they’ll be the one complaining):
2014-15
1. Alabama (SEC) vs. 20. Boise St (top Go5)
2. Oregon (PAC) vs. 7. Miss St. (at Large)
3. FSU (ACC) vs. 6. TCU (co B12/at Large)
4. OSU (B1G) vs. 5. Baylor (co B12/at Large)
2015-16
1. Clemson (ACC) vs. 18. Houston (top Go5)
2. Alabama (SEC) vs. 7. OSU (at Large)
3. Mich St. (B1G) vs. 6. Stanford (PAC)
4. OU (B12) vs. 5. Iowa (at Large)
2016-17
1. Alabama (SEC) vs. 15. Western Mich (top Go5)
2. Clemson (ACC) vs. 7. OU (B12)
3. OSU (at Large) vs. 6. UM (at Large)
4. UW (PAC) vs. 5. PSU (B1G)
2017-18
1. Clemson (ACC) vs. 12. UCF (top Go5)
2. OU (B12) vs. 8. USC (PAC)
3. UGA (SEC) vs. 6. Wisconsin (at Large)
4. Alabama (at Large) vs. 5. OSU (B1G)
*7. Auburn gets left out.
2018-19
1. Alabama (SEC) vs. 9. UW (PAC)
2. Clemson (ACC) vs. 8. UCF (Top Go5)
3. ND (at Large) vs. 6. OSU (B1G)
4. OU (B12) vs. 5. UGA (at Large)
*7. UM gets left out.
2019-20
1. LSU (SEC) vs. 17. Memphis (top Go5)
2. OSU (B1G) vs. 7. Baylor (at Large)
3. Clemson (ACC) vs. 6. Oregon (PAC)
4. OU (B12) vs. 5. UGA (at Large)
2020-21
1. Alabama (SEC) vs. 25. Oregon (PAC)
2. Clemson (ACC) vs. 8. Cincy (top Go5)
3. OSU (B1G) vs. 6. OU (B12)
4. ND (at Large) vs. 5. TAMU (at Large)
*7. UF gets left out.
You’d still get the top heavy four, and most of the time, the top 4 or 5 teams would advance, but at least there would be a chance for one of the other schools to pull upsets. Here’s the breakdown:
7: OSU
6: Alabama, Clemson, OU
3: UGA
2: Oregon, Baylor, UW, UCF, ND
1: FSU, TCU, Miss St., Boise St., Mich St., Iowa, Stanford, Houston, PSU, UM, Western Mich, Wisconsin, USC, LSU, Memphis, TAMU, Cincy