ACamp, here's my take on the Brownies.
You're right that the fans are dumb to want Barkley 1st overall. I used to think he was worth that pick, but RB is a revolving door in the league anymore. You can win a SB with mediocre RBs, but you don't often see a team win a SB with Trent Dilfer at QB. Anyhoo, they should take the QB they want with #1 knowing full well that Barkley might be available at #4 after the Giants either sell #2 or pick Rosen and the Jets take whatever QB is left. But, at worst, Chubb and Barkley have to be graded out as comparable prospects. So if Barkley is gone by #4, draft Chubb and build the defense (like the way Jacksonville did all the way to the AFC Championship game).
Bottom line, get your QB and get the best player available at 4.