There isn’t a more fortified unit on Notre Dame’s 2014 roster than safety — and that includes the coaches aiding its instruction.
Austin Collinsworth
Austin Collinsworth has the most experience at safety for the Irish with 11 starts last year.
First there is Kerry Cooks, who oversees the entire secondary after working exclusively with the cornerbacks the past two years.
Then there is graduate assistant Kyle McCarthy, a starting safety for the Irish in 2008-09 before latching on in the NFL. He exclusively monitors and mentors the safeties in practice while assisting Cooks.
“It helped a lot having a guy fresh out of the game, fresh out of the NFL, and an NFL system here,” fifth-year senior Austin Collinsworth, the graybeard among the safeties, said of McCarthy. “He’s been an unbelievable help.”
Finally, there is Bob Elliott, who is in his fourth decade of instructing college football players, including safeties the past two seasons with the Irish. His role has been to assist new defensive coordinator Brian VanGorder with the sub packages that were heavily emphasized the first third of spring practice.
“It’s like being in final exams for three weeks straight,” Collinsworth said of processing all the information. “I’ve met with Kyle McCarthy. We meet every night. As long as you stay on top of the stuff, it’s not too bad. If you fall behind, then you’re in trouble. … It’s new terminology, new hand signals, new this, new that.
“Coverages are pretty universal. Everyone kind of runs the same stuff. As far as techniques, that’s all different, subtly different, kind of hard to explain.”
No position group at Notre Dame this season appears to be more replete with options than safety. Even the safety with the most career starts (19) and tackles (98), Matthias Farley, is now working at cornerback and nickel to open up opportunities for others, most notably current freshman Max Redfield.
The highly rated recruit Redfield wasn’t inserted into the starting lineup until the Pinstripe Bowl against Rutgers. He has continued to work with the top unit this spring while teaming with Collinsworth, who had 11 starts, 43 tackles and a team-high three interceptions last season. They complement each other in that Collinsworth doesn’t possess Redfield’s “crazy” athletic skills, while Redfield does not yet have the savvy of Collinsworth.
“He’s got a ways to go there, there’s no question,” Kelly said of Redfield’s grasp of his position. “But crazy, crazy, crazy ability. He can make a mistake and get himself out of it. He’s a guy that we just have to keep working with. He’s getting better. His knowledge base was zero with what we’re trying to do with him.
“We feel like we can make the progress necessary that when we line up against Rice [Aug. 30] he’ll be there.”
“Nothing can replace playing time, especially in college football and getting adjusted to the speed of the game,” Collinsworth said. “[Max is] really fast, really athletic guy, picks up on stuff quickly. We’ve been able to work together really well. It’s a very fluid situation.”
There are five other candidates at safety in the myriad defensive packages.
Elijah Shumate as a sophomore last year could never quite grasp the big-picture team defense or making all of its calls, but the fierce hitter did start three games after a strong freshman season in 2012 at nickel. He also battled a hamstring injury in 2013.
Eilar Hardy was off the radar his first two seasons (2011-12) while recovering from major knee surgery, but he started several games in 2013 and was one of the more improved players.
In his third game as a freshman in 2012, Nick Baratti intercepted a halfback pass against Michigan in a goal-line situation during the 13-6 Irish win, and was a regular in all 13 games. Shoulder surgery sidelined him in 2013, but he is back this spring.
A freshman wide receiver who started several games last year, James Onwualu’s 6-1, 215-pound frame is expected to bring more physicality at safety. He and current sophomore John Turner also have lined up as Will linebackers in different packages.
The 6-0½, 217-pound Turner has come out of nowhere to work with the first unit. He would qualify as the top surprise through the first one-third of spring, although the defense has worked primarily on third-down packages. First and second downs are different.
“We’re going to do a lot of different things,” Kelly said of the defense. “We’re focusing on some of our different packages right now that we need some work on. A lot of that is sub personnel. … These are just different segments. They’re not a whole offense or defense right now. They’re just what we’re going through right now. … It’s hard for me to give you any definitive statements one way or another.”
Kelly did note that he would be surprised if Turner doesn’t take advantage of his opportunity.
“We knew he had the ability do it,” Kelly said. “Now he’s been given the chance to do it. I don’t know that he ever really had the chance last year to be quite honest with you.”
Yet for all the numbers and options at safety, there isn’t a standout at this point, a la No. 1 tackler McCarthy in 2008-09 with 110 and 101 stops, respectively, first-round pick Harrison Smith in 2010-11 and Defensive MVP Zeke Motta in 2012.
A common link with all of them is they didn’t really come into their own until their fourth season at the position, which is where Collinsworth is after originally beginning his career at receiver.
“I take it personally,” Collinsworth said. “I want to be that guy. … There’s a lot of competition, a lot of depth at safety.”
After playing in the shadows of the front seven the past two seasons, Collinsworth and his secondary cohorts believe they should be ready to pick up the slack this year.
“We want to put the team on our back,” he said.
There are plenty of players, and coaches, available there to help carry the freight.