I think gray is just not good ( in case anyone forgot lol), but is generally over doing what he's supposed to do. Example - The pick vs MSU, yeah, he is taking away short and outside and has safety help, but you absolutely don't just free release them and have them 10 yds by you running full speed 1-1 vs safety. Similar thing happened vs wisconsin. It's how you give up 80yd tds when you let wrs free release against safeties, luckily our safeties made the plays. Both plays, gray should have been in tight trail coverage, instead he was over 10 yds behind. If the Qb gets more time, that WR will most likely work the safety 1-1. Great pass rush and safety play has helped him or saved him.
When browne had descent time on the third and long, gray had no shot to stay with the slot WR 1-1. It was a good route and great throw, probably caught against almost anyone, but if it wasn't a great throw, he wouldn't have been able to break it up since he wasn't even close.
With all that being said, he's playing about 75% of snaps with the first team D (not counting rice), and the D is playing great, so no other team has figured out a way to consistently beat him. I don't have the all 22 to tell how much zone/man he's playing, but I'd bet he's playing the most zone out of our 3 starting corners.
There's just absolutely no way you can have him on Toney or probably even Barkate even with help, and you don't want it to be an obvious zone tell when he lines up over Toney.