Wild Bill
Well-known member
- Messages
- 5,580
- Reaction score
- 3,422
Book’s arm played a role in that too - maybe an even bigger role than the receivers. He couldn’t take the top off a defense. If Book had a bigger arm, I’m fairly certain Claypool could have hunted down a lot of 50/50 balls in 2018.In the Brian Kelly playoff era, the ND teams would have WR Corps that looked solid against average teams, it's when they matched up against elite competition where it became glaringly obvious that ND lacked that playmaker on the outside. You could predict when ND would play an Alabama, Clemson, some USC defenses, etc and the opponent would play man and stack the box and Ian Book would have no options.
With the expectation that this squad win a national title, that is what is making people nervous. Now it's only week 2, so I am not panicking at all. But man they really need some 350+ yard games for Carr to shine. Running the ball and dumping to TEs and Faison will not win a title against an elite defense. Clearly Wisconsin was playing two high to challenge ND's run game, and it worked for a half.
Carr has a bigger arm and throws a nice deep ball. That alone forces defenses to play more honestly, even if we don’t have an AA catching his passes.

