Culture

Bishop2b5

SEC Exchange Student
Messages
8,929
Reaction score
6,160
I watched the Matt Walsh documentary "What Is A Woman?" tonight and it's absolutely phenomenal. Regardless of how you feel about transgender issues, this is very well done, fair, and informative. Walsh is conservative and very much opposed to allowing minors to take hormones or have gender reassignment surgery, but he didn't attack or argue with anyone in the documentary, didn't try to ask any "gotcha!" questions, and was respectful to everyone.

He interviews a number of people from all across the political spectrum and experts from both sides of the issue. It was definitely telling to see the reactions and attempts to avoid the question when he'd simply ask, "What is a woman?" It also delves deeply into where did this all come from and why. HIGHLY recommend watching this! This is one of the best documentaries I've seen in years.

Here are a few short clips:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt20256528/#_=_
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
I watched the Matt Walsh documentary "What Is A Woman?" tonight and it's absolutely phenomenal. Regardless of how you feel about transgender issues, this is very well done, fair, and informative. Walsh is conservative and very much opposed to allowing minors to take hormones or have gender reassignment surgery, but he didn't attack or argue with anyone in the documentary, didn't try to ask any "gotcha!" questions, and was respectful to everyone.

He interviews a number of people from all across the political spectrum and experts from both sides of the issue. It was definitely telling to see the reactions and attempts to avoid the question when he'd simply ask, "What is a woman?" It also delves deeply into where did this all come from and why. HIGHLY recommend watching this! This is one of the best documentaries I've seen in years.

Here are a few short clips:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt20256528/#_=_

I thought it was great!! I do see one poster (like clockwork) being passive aggressive and just “laughing”. Sort of epitomizes the whole documentary…
 
Last edited:

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
I thought it was great!! I do see one poster (like clockwork) being passive and aggressive and just “laughing”. Sort of epitomizes the whole documentary…

Truly a generational mind who has totally normal thoughts. Dinesh D'Souza has a great documentary out there, it's very well done, fair reporting.

1654976522022.png

1654976627444.png
 

Rockin’Irish

Hearing Impaired
Messages
3,244
Reaction score
2,507
Speaking honestly……it has taken a bit of getting used to females in the broadcasting booth of football games but then again, I didn’t grow up with that. The female sideline reporters didn’t seem as unusual when they started appearing. I actually know several female football fans that have the same view, not really sure why that is the case. Folks that started watching football games after female commentators/reporters became more common probably wouldn’t notice it nearly as much. There are also male commentators I’m not fond of as well…..it’s just an opinion. I also understand the point that Walsh is trying to make about the rape/abortion tweet although it could have been presented in a much better fashion. If incest is suspected then DNA testing could be accomplished whether the child was born or not.
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
? Are you saying his video was his worst moment? Because I laugh emoji'd that.
I’m saying your passive aggressive response veiled as a laugh emoji is your response… and when called out on your trollish behavior you try to find his worst moment that has really nothing to do with the conversation. If you can’t discredit the message try to discredit the messenger. Hence how it epitomizes the documentary… the question still remains what is Women. So far your response seems to be “laugh emoji”.
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
I’m saying your passive aggressive response veiled as a laugh emoji is your response… and when called out on your trollish behavior you try to find his worst moment that has really nothing to do with the conversation. If you can’t discredit the message try to discredit the messenger. Hence how it epitomizes the documentary… the question still remains what is Women. So far your response seems to be “laugh emoji”.
"trollish" says the guy who initiated a response from me first...but yes I am the troll L O L

If you want to believe that Matt Walsh is making sound arguments then all I have is a laugh emoji for that, because he is a room temp IQ (celsius) kind of guy. Walsh makes tweets/videos that are based purely in stoking emotions of those that want to be offended. He's the campus protestor that grew up to make content for those that want to stay offended.
 

ACamp1900

Counting my ‘bet against ND’ winnings
Messages
48,947
Reaction score
11,226
My mom is a huge nfl fan and hates any time a female is in the booth,… it’s hysterical
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
"trollish" says the guy who initiated a response from me first...but yes I am the troll L O L

If you want to believe that Matt Walsh is making sound arguments then all I have is a laugh emoji for that, because he is a room temp IQ (celsius) kind of guy. Walsh makes tweets/videos that are based purely in stoking emotions of those that want to be offended. He's the campus protestor that grew up to make content for those that want to stay offended.
YESSS!!! NOW THATS A RESPONSE!! In your quest to insult me and be the smartest person in the room, you insulted the original poster and those that supported (liked) the post. And yet still no substantive argument on what a women is…

I would love to stick around but I have a hot date with this feminine human I married that happens to have a vagina… we will call her “woman”.
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
Toronto, have you watched What Is A Woman?
Watched some scenes, and it certainly hits on all the points that some want. Certainly emotional and made to stoke tensions.
YESSS!!! NOW THATS A RESPONSE!! In your quest to insult me and be the smartest person in the room, you insulted the original poster and those that supported (liked) the post. And yet still no substantive argument on what a women is…

I would love to stick around but I have a hot date with this feminine human I married that happens to have a vagina… we will call her “woman”.
I insulted Matt Walsh, and said he makes content for those that want that kind of stuff. Lol because who cares what a women is to me, essentially if someone wants to be one go nuts. Just because I am attracted to women does not mean that I am attracted to each one. Does not hurt me if someone wants to be one, and I am secure enough in knowing what I like.

Have fun, with that kind of wording I'm not convinced it isn't just a sex doll with self cut holes.
 

Bishop2b5

SEC Exchange Student
Messages
8,929
Reaction score
6,160
Watched some scenes, and it certainly hits on all the points that some want. Certainly emotional and made to stoke tensions.
Don't judge it based on watching a few clips. That won't give you a very accurate view of the documentary. Watch the entire thing if you can. It's well done and covers some good points. The inability of even the biggest so-called experts in the field to answer basic questions or deliver a rational explanation of their position is very telling.
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
Watched some scenes, and it certainly hits on all the points that some want. Certainly emotional and made to stoke tensions.

I insulted Matt Walsh, and said he makes content for those that want that kind of stuff. Lol because who cares what a women is to me, essentially if someone wants to be one go nuts. Just because I am attracted to women does not mean that I am attracted to each one. Does not hurt me if someone wants to be one, and I am secure enough in knowing what I like.

Have fun, with that kind of wording I'm not convinced it isn't just a sex doll with self cut holes.
What if it was… you hatin? Seems a bit hypocritical.

What do you mean by “just because I’m attracted to women”. Assuming you don’t ask everyone you are attracted to what their gender is you could be attracted to man, right?
 
Last edited:

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
What if it was… you hatin? Seems a bit hypocritical.

What do you mean by “just because I’m attracted to women”. Assuming you don’t ask everyone you are attracted to what their gender is you could be attracted to man, right?
In this theory that likely encompass both of us? If the person presenting as a woman says that they're a dude that would change the equation for me. I feel like that would the same for you too?
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
In this theory that likely encompass both of us? If the person presenting as a woman says that they're a dude that would change the equation for me. I feel like that would the same for you too?

To what theory? Who’s reality or theory are we talking about? My reality where men have a penis and women have a vagina or the lefts theories/reality where the person with a vagina can identify as a man and person with a penis can identify and be a woman or whatever it wants to be? We have different definitions of what a women/man is or can be. By your definition of a women you are essentially being homophobic assuming every women with breasts and vagina (or in your circles - birthing people) are women. If you subscribe to the idea they can be a man or whatever they want, you might as well have a coming out party. I’d rather you be real with yourself then be so hypocritical. You say you are attracted to women but in the same post essentially say a man with a penis can identify as a woman. You sort of put yourself in a pickle…
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
To what theory? Who’s reality or theory are we talking about? My reality where men have a penis and women have a vagina or the lefts theories/reality where the person with a vagina can identify as a man and person with a penis can identify and be a woman or whatever it wants to be? We have different definitions of what a women/man is or can be. By your definition of a women you are essentially being homophobic assuming every women with breasts and vagina (or in your circles - birthing people) are women. If you subscribe to the idea they can be a man or whatever they want, you might as well have a coming out party. I’d rather you be real with yourself then be so hypocritical. You say you are attracted to women but in the same post essentially say a man with a penis can identify as a woman. You sort of put yourself in a pickle…
You see, I'm not being hypocritical if I say that I am attracted to women with vaginas/breasts. Just because I am straight does not mean I am attracted to all women. It's really not that hard to understand. You can be a woman, I am not required to find all women attractive - do you understand that? Maybe you have lower standards but I don't think its wrong to have preferences.
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
You see, I'm not being hypocritical if I say that I am attracted to women with vaginas/breasts. Just because I am straight does not mean I am attracted to all women. It's really not that hard to understand. You can be a woman, I am not required to find all women attractive - do you understand that? Maybe you have lower standards but I don't think its wrong to have preferences.
Just doesn’t sound like you are being inclusive and affirming their gender choice. You are discriminating…
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,107
Reaction score
5,459
How? Lol

Do you think every woman is attractive? Standards man....standards

Every women by what context? Your context or my context? By my definition of what a woman is, I have preferences but they are not written in stone deal breakers. I’ve dated blondes, brunettes, black, white, Hispanic, Christian, Mormon… I think any woman is capable of my lust… by my definition of what a women is.

You are saying these people who identify as a woman are women but you immediately put them in their own category of women, separate from what I assume would be my definition of a women. Which happens to go against inclusion and affirming and is by definition homophobic. I dare you to tell a person with a penis that identifies as a woman, “You are a woman BUT a different kind of woman”.

It would probably help if you actually had a clear definition of “woman”. Which was Matt Walsh’s quest. The search for truth and reality. Truth and reality matters.
 

Rockin’Irish

Hearing Impaired
Messages
3,244
Reaction score
2,507
I think identifying a man or woman (adult male or adult female) is quite simple……we follow the science. DNA is an excellent and almost foolproof way of identification. I also understand that a person can decide to identify as whatever they like and that is certainly their free will but a DNA test is reality. I, as an adult male, could use hormone treatments, implants and gender reassignment surgery to change my external appearance but I still could not birth a child from my pseudo lady bits and my DNA will still show an adult male (i.e. woman).
 

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2025!
Messages
31,518
Reaction score
17,386
I've got no problem with a woman in the booth. I'm progressive like that. Like Clay Travis I believe in two things: 1st Amendment...and boobs.
 

ACamp1900

Counting my ‘bet against ND’ winnings
Messages
48,947
Reaction score
11,226
I think identifying a man or woman (adult male or adult female) is quite simple……we follow the science. DNA is an excellent and almost foolproof way of identification. I also understand that a person can decide to identify as whatever they like and that is certainly their free will but a DNA test is reality. I, as an adult male, could use hormone treatments, implants and gender reassignment surgery to change my external appearance but I still could not birth a child from my pseudo lady bits and my DNA will still show an adult male (i.e. woman).
Freaking bigot
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
5,709
Every women by what context? Your context or my context? By my definition of what a woman is, I have preferences but they are not written in stone deal breakers. I’ve dated blondes, brunettes, black, white, Hispanic, Christian, Mormon… I think any woman is capable of my lust… by my definition of what a women is.

You are saying these people who identify as a woman are women but you immediately put them in their own category of women, separate from what I assume would be my definition of a women. Which happens to go against inclusion and affirming and is by definition homophobic. I dare you to tell a person with a penis that identifies as a woman, “You are a woman BUT a different kind of woman”.

It would probably help if you actually had a clear definition of “woman”. Which was Matt Walsh’s quest. The search for truth and reality. Truth and reality matters.
Why does having sex with someone mean that it's the deal breaker? Do you feel the need to view each woman as a sexual being? If you don't find a woman attractive that makes them not a woman? I'm sure I could go through some wives/gf here and I wouldn't think they're all knockouts.

Me not finding someone with the same parts downstairs as me as someone I want to sleep with is not something that invalidates them. If a woman doesn't find me attractive then I don't become not a male. If you want to identify as whatever you want go nuts it's not a big deal. Pretty simple approach to take to these things.

At the end of the day....why does this matter? Lol like I thought the Left was supposed to be the snowflakes mad at emotional things....yet here we are. Worst case scenario of all this is....no impact on your life?

(It's transphobic not homophobic btw, homphobic would be like gay agenda etc.)
 
Top