My previous point was made last month after I spoke personally with Thomas Holley after his Friday night game against Brooklyn Erasmus and Curtis Samuels. I posted that night, that I was confused about all the information on Bucknuts that had OSU tied for first with PSU on Holley, when Holley had specifically just told me to my face that OSU was not even in his top 4!!
Even after I tried to sell to Holley how OSU had the great coaches and players that would get him to the NFL, and maybe even a NC, he just chuckled and stated clearly that his top three choices were PSU, Fla, ND. He didn't care about cold weather , being a Northern guy. he just liked Fla ability to put DLs in NFL. He said Fla wanted him to replace one of there DLs who was going to the league. He said it was between PSU, FLA, and ND. When I pressed, He even listed Syracuse ahead of OSU. He said he was leaving that weekend to visit OSU, and he liked the coaches, but they were NOT in his top 3. He did not seemed as enthused about OSU as the others from his tone.
I posted later that night on this board that based on my conversation with Holley, that Urban might have more of an uphill battle getting Holley than what was being reported. I will never count out Urban in recruiting, so I was hoping that he might be able to pull a rabbit out of his hat in getting Holley.
Despite my posting what Thomas told me, his recruitment kept being portrayed on this site as an OSU / PSU battle.
That simply was Not accurate then.
Now maybe Our great coaching staff changed Holleys mind after his visit, and I hope they did. But I heard nothing from him then and have heard nothing since that would make me more optimistic about OSU getting him. So I don't know why we wasted so much time hyping this recruitment, when in reality we were not one of his top 2?
I want to know who the real potential OSU 2014 signees will be. I think we made progress but it was not enough.
Now it sounds from what Bill K is saying, we have decided to move on. It sounds like the staff has recently discovered somthing they see in Holleys' game that is not what they are looking for. I believe this, andI think it is a blessing for both parties as Holley probably was going to Fla or PSU ahead of OSU anyways.
i trust the coaching staffs judgement implicitly in this is the case, and feel relieved that we can spend this schollie on a player who will be more successful in the OSU defense. I just feel it this recruitment has been much to do about nothing for quite a few weeks, and we should have been spending our time listening to what Holley was actually saying instead of what we wanted him to say.
Having said that, I am sure we have learned from this oversight, and we will do a more accurate job with recruits going forward.